Minecraft Forums

Blocks:
Planks: Planks are sort of 'pink' and the light strip near the indents between the boards looks strange. Make them more brown and try to avoid making planks look 'shiny' ect. (They are definitely pinkish and a bit too pale. The shininess, in my opinion is fine, but the planks definitely need to be a darker brown, maybe a similar colour to the wooden doors.)

Dirt: Dirt looks strange, cracked and out of place in large fields. It's also a very strange colour, but none the less it looks nice. Try to reduce the cracks but still keep it textured. (I like the colour of the dirt, and while it looks great surrounded by more dirt and stone, in any somewhat flat field it clearly sticks out and looks really off.)

Sand and SandStone: Sand lacks texture, and seems to be a very pale pinkish pastel yellow mix. Sandstone is very pink, and the sides are weird. Make it smoother, and think of it as solid sand with a darker shade. (The sand looks fine, could be a bit more yellow, but really no big problem. However, the sandstone does have really weird sides, sort of blurry and swirly, if that makes any sense.)

Grass: Grass lacks Texture, looking like a pastel green has smothered the earth. (Grass looks good, I like the colour and it makes the world vibrant, but I agree it could be slightly more textured.)

Plowed Earth: This looks strange and wavey, but lacks the depth to indicate a gap in the earth.

Smoothstone & Smooth Slabs: Smooth slabs look over textured, and smoothstone seems to have a very light aquamarine colour.

Ore blocks: The ores dont look very good, with the diamond looking like randomly coloured and distributed pixels, and the redstone like a mutant starfish. Gold looks nice, but to be realistic it should be thin lines of gold following large quartz (whitish crystal) veins. Coal should be a larger mass, not several small ones. (The diamonds and the lapis lazuli look very similar, just a slight colour difference. Maybe try making the diamonds bigger clumps, and leaving the lapis lazuli as is, because the diamond doesn't look very good as the distributed pixels, as stated above. Redstone does look like a mutant starfish, haha. If you do work the gold out into veins, which I think would look better as well, then maybe you could fashion the redstone in a similar veiny style.)

Diamond block ect: These need the square indents taken away, otherwise very nice. Diamond could be lighter...

Wool: Wool needs the borders taken away, it can be highly detrimental to create statues or pixel art with. (Definitely agree the borders need to go. My giant blue rug in my dinning hall looks terrible :'{ )

Glass: Glass panes are very nicely made, but the edging is a weird colour it needs to be darker.

Misc placeables, eg chests:
*Chests need the verticle lines on the front and sides removed.
*Torches and redstone need the swirls from the flame effects removed.
*Remove the X shape from the bottom of wooden doors, it looks retro/saloonish.
*Bookcases are to dark and monotone.
*Brown mushrooms look strange, as if viewed from a bad angle.
(I think the tops of the crafting tables stand out a lot and look sort a cheesy, might be just me though.)

Mobs & Items:

Animals: Most animals seem to have been taken straight from the painterly pack, and creepers are just ridiculous, sorry but I'm supposed to be scared of them, not invite them in for tea. Sheeps skin needs to be pink, not black as its true to life. (Animals looks great as they are, the sheep being pink doesn't really matter that much to me.)

Items: Cake is hard to see in the inventory, it just happens to be the same shade. Item pictures don't match their appearance, and the gold armour is just iron with a crown and some additions. Also shovels need to be held the default way, the downwards direction option should remain an option.