You know that real life minecraft video, the first one? You know when the guy pulls out the pork chop (that looks like a pancake... or something) after the creeper hits him?
That is what the current texture (for the pork chop) makes me think of. I will try to find a link to the video...
This. For the record, the last I saw of it, liking, or not having a problem with the new textures was winning by a 2:1 ratio.
The thing is, the people who don't care should not be bunched with the people who like it, so for this I would recommend five poll options (or the paraphrases of these):
1) I hate the new textures.
2) I don't like the new and prefer the old, but I am ok, with the new ones
3) I just don't care.
4) I prefer the new, but the old was good as well
5) I love the new ones
That way everyone would get better input and be better able to determine the theoretical best course for the future.