I frighten easily, and I feel like having scary fish might make Minecraft unplayable for me. If it comes to the point where I must fish to survive, I think I'll have to resort to closing my eyes and hoping that I click the proper objects that will cook and eat the fish or otherwise get rid of it. Notch, please consider toning down how scary your fish are.
But seriously, Minecraft actually scares the hell out of me... I'm such a wimp. The sounds scare me and make me jump when a monster creeps up on me, I have to play music instead of listening for monsters. I'd rather get hit in the back or blown up than be scared to death.
I'm not sure why I find the monsters in this game so scary, there's nothing, logically, scary about them.
I give u a 1+. Minecraft makes me sometimes nervous to but it doesn't scare me.