Seriously, how many people actually build in the nether? Surely it is good for glowstone, and all those nether blocks, but other than that, what do you really go to then nether for? I personally think that the nether uses a lot of space in memory JUST to have a dimension that no one builds in. The only thing that we really use the nether for is getting neat resources. I think nether should be replaced with something interesting, perhaps a magical forest? Something interesting that people will not only get resources from, but also build in! I think the same about the end. What do we really go there for, other than to just kill a boss? It makes sense if someone wants to build in this epic, cool dimension, and it is guarded by a boss. and the only way to build and live there peacefully is to kill it, but to just have a dimension just for the sake of killing something makes little sense to me. If a dimension is going to be taking space in my mc folder, I want to be making FULL USE of it, as well as being interested. Not only is it not really all that fun to build in the nether (to me), it is boring to explore. The more you walk, the more you see: lava, lava, lava, and more lava. Sure there are strongholds, but they all look the same. You know exactly what a stronghold looks like.
Anyway guys, I am not trying to force anyone into thinking what I think, but I would like to see what other people think. Perhaps I am the only one who thinks there is little point in the Nether and The End. Tell me what you think!
By the way. Most of this is personal opinion, and is meant to be personal opinion. IF it has no support, I at least would like to see how other players feel, without receiving indirect, as well as direct insults (which a couple have done already).
I like the nether as it is, and I doubt Mojang would get rid of it since they just updated it... The End was designed to be just for a boss battle but you can build xp grinders and mine up all the End stone. They both have uses and I think a Twilight Forest would ruin it.
The nether needs more content. And if you were to remove it, then alot of people would be angry with losing their builds.
*Stamps* NO SUPPORT.
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
To all of you people who think Notch is still working on the game, he stopped working on Minecraft in late 2011. Get your facts straight and stop spamming his twitter about Minecraft updates.
The nether needs more content. And if you were to remove it, then alot of people would be angry with losing their builds.
*Stamps* NO SUPPORT.
What this guy said. If you watch hermitcraft they rely on the nether a lot. They have shops set up their too. The nether is pretty useful to me and many others.
The end is just a boss arena. But the endstone can be used. You can also build an enderman farm there.
Hey, I think the Nether is too bland, so instead of trying to make it more interesting I'll remove it entirely!!!
I know absolutely NO ONE likes the Nether, and as you know lava is extremely boring.
So please Mojang, just take the Nether code and erase it entirely!
Nether is just stupid and it has zero point to even being in the game, all because I said so!
/sarcasm
Excuse me? Half of my building is in the nether, plus now I need a full time mining operation for nether quartz. The nether is a huge part of the game, and you want to just replace it?
No support what-so-ever.
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
Hey, if you want to make sure I saw what you said, quote me on it.
Without nether fortresses the game is virtually impossible to complete. We NEED the nether, Blazes, Wither Skeletons, all those mobs are NEEDED. You're seriously going to take the fun out of literally walking into hell? My main base is in the Nether as well, and I have an alternate one in the end. I have 2 Enderman grinders and I get LOADS of obsidian in the End as well.
You need some serious work on being considerate.
NO SUPPORT no matter how much you change this idea.
Hey, I think the Nether is too bland, so instead of trying to make it more interesting I'll remove it entirely!!!
I know absolutely NO ONE likes the Nether, and as you know lava is extremely boring.
So please Mojang, just take the Nether code and erase it entirely!
Nether is just stupid and it has zero point to even being in the game, all because I said so!
/sarcasm
NO SUPPORT.
-Has no point in my opinion
-I find Lava very boring
-I didn't say "NO ONE likes nether", I was wondering if anyone does, and it kinda surprises me that so many people seem to like it
-I didn't say it's stupid, I said "It's pointless" Which is actually meant to be a personal opinion
-"I'll remove it entirely!!!" Trust me, I would if I could, but I can't.
-If mojang removed nether, I would be happy
-Yes, it's obviously sarcasm without a doubt, which has little effect on me.
"I can't even explain how wrong you are in making those assumptions" (Mathy)
I may have forgotten to explain to all that all of this is from personal experience, and my personal opinions. Failure to recognize that is my fault, however, my personal feelings about it are not wrong if that is what you are saying.
"You need some serious work on being considerate." (Kyric)
You took this a bit more personal than I would have expected. It is all personal opinion. I doubt nether will be removed anyway. How much support have I got? not much.
Absolutely no way this would ever happen. I love Brewing and all sorts of stuff in the Nether, and it would be ridiculous to try and cram it all into the Overworld. Also, it isn't really a realm for you to build in. You certainly can, but the Nether is more about going there and braving the dangers to get some important Brewing and Redstone stuff, as well as summoning/fighting the Wither.
Also, are they just going to remove all the mobs or shove all the explosive shooting, fire causing, group attacking, life stealing mobs into the Overworld? Either option would be nothing short of awful.
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
Want some advice on how to thrive in the Suggestions section? Check this handy list of guidelines and tips for posting your ideas and responding to the ideas of others!
The Meaning of Life, the Universe, and Everything.
Join Date:
5/12/2012
Posts:
109
Minecraft:
burnttoast609
Member Details
I agree with your POV here. The Nether is a little bit bland on the terrain side, and yes there needs to be more generated features/structures to spice it up. However, I do not agree with removing it completely as it serves many purposes. Must I go into detail:
1. Potion making (blaze rods, nether wart, blaze powder, magma cream, glowstone).
2. Ender Dragon fight (eyes of ender crafted w/ blaze powder).
3. Wither fight (wither skeletons ddropping heads).
4. Redstone lamps/glowstone blocks.
5. Long distance travel (each Nether block is equal to roughly 8 Overworld blocks, so this way you can make minecart tracks/paths to other portals of your selected destination: Notch has stated that this is the main purpose of the Nether).
6. Sunlight detectors (New Nether Quartz to craft).
7. Comparators (Nether Quartz).
8. No reason to make a diamond pickaxe (obsidian for nether portal).
9. No challenge involved (ghasts, blazes, zombie pigmen, magma cubes, wither skeletons).
10. Fireplaces/infinite fire (netherrack).
10 legit reasons why the Nether should not be completely removed, but improved.
Also, it isn't really a realm for you to build in. You certainly can, but the Nether is more about going there and braving the dangers to get some important Brewing and Redstone stuff, as well as summoning/fighting the Wither.
I agree with your POV here. The Nether is a little bit bland on the terrain side, and yes there needs to be more generated features/structures to spice it up. However, I do not agree with removing it completely as it serves many purposes. Must I go into detail:
1. Potion making (blaze rods, nether wart, blaze powder, magma cream, glowstone).
2. Ender Dragon fight (eyes of ender crafted w/ blaze powder).
3. Wither fight (wither skeletons ddropping heads).
4. Redstone lamps/glowstone blocks.
5. Long distance travel (each Nether block is equal to roughly 8 Overworld blocks, so this way you can make minecart tracks/paths to other portals of your selected destination: Notch has stated that this is the main purpose of the Nether).
6. Sunlight detectors (New Nether Quartz to craft).
7. Comparators (Nether Quartz).
8. No reason to make a diamond pickaxe (obsidian for nether portal).
9. No challenge involved (ghasts, blazes, zombie pigmen, magma cubes, wither skeletons).
10. Fireplaces/infinite fire (netherrack).
10 legit reasons why the Nether should not be completely removed, but improved.
See what we're getting at?
I hope they improve it. Make it more interesting to explore for me, and all the other players. Not to say that it is not interesting for everyone. But for me, I do not find it too interesting. You have good points though. Your post was more polite than some I must say.
The Nether is a place of boiling lava seas, giant, floating, deadly jellyfish, Rotten Pigmen, and living things made from fire. And most of the Nether is filled with brittle Netherrack. It isn't the place to build. But they need to be improved instead.
And this is the internet, your opinion will be bashed, stepped on and thrown into the fire, if you said something that did not appease the majority (even the minority).
Anyway guys, I am not trying to force anyone into thinking what I think, but I would like to see what other people think. Perhaps I am the only one who thinks there is little point in the Nether and The End. Tell me what you think!
By the way. Most of this is personal opinion, and is meant to be personal opinion. IF it has no support, I at least would like to see how other players feel, without receiving indirect, as well as direct insults (which a couple have done already).
I do. My friend does. So does my brother.
There's three. And there are probably plenty more here on the forums.
http://www.minecraft...orld-version-3/
I agree that the nether needs some new things to explore, and the Nether Quartz is a good start.
Maybe develop the idea of the Magical Forest better.
Support bits.
No Support.
*Stamps* NO SUPPORT.
What this guy said. If you watch hermitcraft they rely on the nether a lot. They have shops set up their too. The nether is pretty useful to me and many others.
The end is just a boss arena. But the endstone can be used. You can also build an enderman farm there.
I know absolutely NO ONE likes the Nether, and as you know lava is extremely boring.
So please Mojang, just take the Nether code and erase it entirely!
Nether is just stupid and it has zero point to even being in the game, all because I said so!
/sarcasm
NO SUPPORT.
My main base is in the nether, and I like it there.
No support what-so-ever.
You need some serious work on being considerate.
NO SUPPORT no matter how much you change this idea.
-Has no point in my opinion
-I find Lava very boring
-I didn't say "NO ONE likes nether", I was wondering if anyone does, and it kinda surprises me that so many people seem to like it
-I didn't say it's stupid, I said "It's pointless" Which is actually meant to be a personal opinion
-"I'll remove it entirely!!!" Trust me, I would if I could, but I can't.
-If mojang removed nether, I would be happy
-Yes, it's obviously sarcasm without a doubt, which has little effect on me.
"I can't even explain how wrong you are in making those assumptions" (Mathy)
I may have forgotten to explain to all that all of this is from personal experience, and my personal opinions. Failure to recognize that is my fault, however, my personal feelings about it are not wrong if that is what you are saying.
"You need some serious work on being considerate." (Kyric)
You took this a bit more personal than I would have expected. It is all personal opinion. I doubt nether will be removed anyway. How much support have I got? not much.
Also, are they just going to remove all the mobs or shove all the explosive shooting, fire causing, group attacking, life stealing mobs into the Overworld? Either option would be nothing short of awful.
Want some advice on how to thrive in the Suggestions section? Check this handy list of guidelines and tips for posting your ideas and responding to the ideas of others!
http://www.minecraftforum.net/forums/minecraft-discussion/suggestions/2775557-guidelines-for-the-suggestions-forum
1. Potion making (blaze rods, nether wart, blaze powder, magma cream, glowstone).
2. Ender Dragon fight (eyes of ender crafted w/ blaze powder).
3. Wither fight (wither skeletons ddropping heads).
4. Redstone lamps/glowstone blocks.
5. Long distance travel (each Nether block is equal to roughly 8 Overworld blocks, so this way you can make minecart tracks/paths to other portals of your selected destination: Notch has stated that this is the main purpose of the Nether).
6. Sunlight detectors (New Nether Quartz to craft).
7. Comparators (Nether Quartz).
8. No reason to make a diamond pickaxe (obsidian for nether portal).
9. No challenge involved (ghasts, blazes, zombie pigmen, magma cubes, wither skeletons).
10. Fireplaces/infinite fire (netherrack).
10 legit reasons why the Nether should not be completely removed, but improved.
See what we're getting at?
I hope they improve it. Make it more interesting to explore for me, and all the other players. Not to say that it is not interesting for everyone. But for me, I do not find it too interesting. You have good points though. Your post was more polite than some I must say.
...What?
Remove the Nether and End?!
How would we fight the Ender Dragon?!!?
No support at all. (Throws suggestion into the Nether)
"Do we want to be the mediocre brimstone boy, or do we want to be the more-than-enough brimstone man?" - Northernlion
Check out my new game, Legends of Aekran!
And this is the internet, your opinion will be bashed, stepped on and thrown into the fire, if you said something that did not appease the majority (even the minority).