They look flat. There is little to no detail and no shading whatsoever. Also, stray away from default colors...as they look like default colors. However from what's there there are no tiling issues.
A bit too basic for my likings (even though it's intentionally like that), but seems like it's going to be a nice looking pack when you're done with it.
A bit too basic for my likings (even though it's intentionally like that), but seems like it's going to be a nice looking pack when you're done with it.
Undetailed is a really bad thing.
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
The official Bluebird continuation is underway! Please come and help keep the pack alive!
They look flat. There is little to no detail and no shading whatsoever. Also, stray away from default colors...as they look like default colors. However from what's there there are no tiling issues.
It's too flat. 1/10. Shading, wood grain, detail... please.
Guys maybe he's trying to make a simple pack. If you don't like them then that's your problem just don't hate on other peoples work because it not like a usual pack.
Guys maybe he's trying to make a simple pack. If you don't like them then that's your problem just don't hate on other peoples work because it not like a usual pack.
I rate it 7/10 for the look your going for.
Did you even look into who we are? I am a simple pack creator. I get lots of positive feedback because I know how to make a simple pack that will not get flamed by everybody. If there is no shading in this pack, it will be flamed by all of us when he posts a thread, we are trying to help prevent that.
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
The official Bluebird continuation is underway! Please come and help keep the pack alive!
There's a difference between smooth and nonsensical. Smooth objects have shadows, it all depends on light.
You're also setting yourself up to do a half-job. Why make a simple pack? Anyone could make a simple pack in a few minutes, no shading or anything. This forum is cluttered by them and the raging, hating, 'wtf you idiot' posting that comes after them. Rating something that takes 20 seconds is stupid. If you want good, wholehearted feedback, do something original and challenging.
*sees simple pack wood*
Umm... Dude, have you ever heard of PMC? That might be the best place to post this.
You can still have smooth and detailed at the same time, look at Bluebird or Doll's House.
People have been bringing Bluebird up lately, that makes me happy.
But we will still flame it even if it is posted on PMC.
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
The official Bluebird continuation is underway! Please come and help keep the pack alive!
Unh3lpful, please try and be a little more helpful. And less rude. Anyway, 1/10. Add shading, grain, better colours etc. basically what everyone here has said.
It is smooth if you add shading, look at any really good simple pack out there, they all have shading of some sort.
You do want shading.
It needs shading to look good.
Something can easily be smooth and shaded at the same time.
There's yet more to come!
So IMO 6/10
A bit too basic for my likings (even though it's intentionally like that), but seems like it's going to be a nice looking pack when you're done with it.
Undetailed is a really bad thing.
Guys maybe he's trying to make a simple pack. If you don't like them then that's your problem just don't hate on other peoples work because it not like a usual pack.
I rate it 7/10 for the look your going for.
Did you even look into who we are? I am a simple pack creator. I get lots of positive feedback because I know how to make a simple pack that will not get flamed by everybody. If there is no shading in this pack, it will be flamed by all of us when he posts a thread, we are trying to help prevent that.
What you essentially said here is that you are only interested in opinions that agree with yours.
...But that's just my opinion.
My DeviantART, requests welcome.
B14 - My Texture Pack!
Need textures for your mod? Inquire within, just read the rules.
You're also setting yourself up to do a half-job. Why make a simple pack? Anyone could make a simple pack in a few minutes, no shading or anything. This forum is cluttered by them and the raging, hating, 'wtf you idiot' posting that comes after them. Rating something that takes 20 seconds is stupid. If you want good, wholehearted feedback, do something original and challenging.
Lol.. Not this again!
People have been bringing Bluebird up lately, that makes me happy.
But we will still flame it even if it is posted on PMC.
I am ninja'd far too often.