If someone argues with their theories that another ones theory is wrong (although this is just in case,no one is fighting anyway) EVERY THEORY is right,because its just a mystery,but discussing it can be fun,as you learn more possibilities on what it might be,but it will remain a mystery. =D Cheers.
-Bupep
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
If I helped you in any way,remember to push that green arrow button on the bottom-right side of my post!
I think it must have something to do with the Nether. You hear him take out and use some sort of metal tool, then cough. It might be that he is hitting the flint and steel against each other which creates a fire and of course smoke, causing him to cough. The Nether Portal then activates, and so you hear the strange, distorted sound it makes. He might have entered the Nether for a little, then was frightened by the monsters inside and fled. The dog is hear at the end because dogs couldn't go into the Nether when the disk was added/made. Herobrine is commonly associated with the Nether, so perhaps Herobrine emerged from there?
Herorbine isn't associated with the Nether at all.
Herobrine isn't associated with anything since he/she/it isn't even real.
And wow, this thread has been bumped many times. You know how I feel about disc11? Someone light a flint, read a book, got scared, ran. What made him scared? The contents of the book. What was in the book? All of the stuff every Minecraft Herobrine believer has said to try to convince Herobrine was real. Whoever was the one that ran went crazy from the idiocy of these comments and after running outside wherver he was he yelled "Herobrine" because he was mad at how this stupid myth has gone on for.
I have three theories.My first one agrees with your idea of an Enderman chasing him, but, wouldn't it be teleporting after him, instead of just running?My second is that he's changing INTO an Enderman(see further as to why I like this one).It could also explain the barking sounds others have mentioned.He may have had a dog and he's changing into something it doesn't know, so it is trying to attack him.My third is, again, that he is being chased by a mob.By the fact he seems to be in such a hurry, maybe a fast mob.But when he makes a break for it the second time, he may have fallen down a hole or something, which would explain the broken disk-he fell and it broke when it hit the bottom.
This is why I like my second theory
Firstly, it would explain the human-like eyes belonging to Endermen.It could be that Endermen are former humans, but when they changed they...sort of kept their eyes, albeit changing colour and growing.Secondly, if Endermen were humans, it would explain their tendency to pick up blocks.It could be a reminiscence of their former mind, trying to do what it used to:Building.But it can't remember where it's last block was.Another reason is because an Enderman will not keep a disk on it, will it?So it may have dropped it, and broken it.I also like this theory because it would explain some noises.Him coughing may be his body trying to reject the Enderman part of him and failing.It may also be the strange whistling noise right before the disk goes static-It's the Enderman part of him taking over and he loses it.He may not even be running FROM something at all.He could be running TO something, something he believes could save him, which explains the stop.He may have found it, but it didn't work, and as the Enderman him started to win over him, he made a mad run for it, as one does in a situation like that.Those are my reasons, and additions, to my faveroute(second) theory to Music Disk 11.
I like both of your theories and especially like the second one. P.S. look at this video:
i know how important this is to everyone, me and my friends want to find out too, we have been researching the case i know it isnt vital to know but i cant stand it anymore! i want to know and there has got to be a explanation to it. im so desprate that im gathering up as many awnsers and things that it could of couldnt be saying to us, and putting it all into a book, i think we all have a right to know what it is, and as a minecrafter it is my minecraft mission to solve the mystery of...(pause for dramatic affect...) disk 11!
same about me and my friend. there's alot of other options and explanations (that mainly involve Herobrine but I personally think some hacker just planted some kind of virus or something else and it somehow got into other seeds and servers). Wanna know what's Music Disk 11? ASK NOTCH.
I really want to find out what this music disc represents, one of my theories is that,
The person was mining, and he hears something and it freaks him out, so he starts to try to mine up and out of where he is at. He stops to light a torch and place it so he can continue his ecsape, , he than hears something that sound like the thing is getting closer, so he starts just randomly freaking running, when the disk breaks, well use your imagination
I also think the theory about the person turning into an enderman is interesting
I could have sworn I heard slimes bouncing... Or magma cubes as you could faintly hear the sound of a portal in the background before the slime/magma cube...
I'm locking this topic on the base that it's been necroposted long enough. Please check the date of the latest post before deciding to add to the conversion or not.
-Bupep
If I helped you in any way,remember to push that green arrow button on the bottom-right side of my post!
Just wanted to say that I JUST got the music disc 11 and I got it from a skeleton killing a creeper.
Herobrine isn't associated with anything since he/she/it isn't even real.
And wow, this thread has been bumped many times. You know how I feel about disc11? Someone light a flint, read a book, got scared, ran. What made him scared? The contents of the book. What was in the book? All of the stuff every Minecraft Herobrine believer has said to try to convince Herobrine was real. Whoever was the one that ran went crazy from the idiocy of these comments and after running outside wherver he was he yelled "Herobrine" because he was mad at how this stupid myth has gone on for.
Avatar by Geckobutt
Signature by sakuramori-sumomo
OT, what actually IS the 11th mob to be added?
The person was mining, and he hears something and it freaks him out, so he starts to try to mine up and out of where he is at. He stops to light a torch and place it so he can continue his ecsape, , he than hears something that sound like the thing is getting closer, so he starts just randomly freaking running, when the disk breaks, well use your imagination
I also think the theory about the person turning into an enderman is interesting lol
Wow.I always thought it was some guy digging down to get away from a monster.
As far as that animation on page one goes, that's pretty impressive! I could see that being a potential explanation!
~Locked