Urthman said:
I really, really like the way you've made the smooth stone, dirt, and cobblestone all tile together. I always get hung up over how cobblestone needs to look sort of man-made and sort of like something you'd get from dousing lava with water. This is a great solution to that problem, and also a great way to make natural dirt/rock formations fit together. Your furnace looks great too.
I like the design for the gravel, but having it so dark doesn't fit with the rest quite so well. Maybe you could try making it more of a dirt brown/tan, or let it be gray and rely on a change in the pattern to differentiate it from stone and cobblestone?
I'm personally not a fan of the streaks-style glass, but I like your use of blue there.
I'm not wild about the ores either. Is that yellowish one in the first screen shot gold or iron? They look like a decal pasted onto the stone pattern. Is there a way to make them look like they're embedded in the stone pattern somehow? What if you colored the "cracks" between the stones the color of the ore, maybe widening the cracks in a few places to let more color show through?
Your sand is the best 16x16 sand I've seen. The snow looks great too. In general, having used 32x32 for a while now, I'm really surprised and impressed with how good this looks in 16x16. This is really great work!
Thanks for all of positive feedback there. Also, Those are some really helpful suggestions you gave, and I agree with you about the ores and the gravel. I'll see what I can do with the gravel, and now that I look at it well, I see what you mean about the ores looking pasted on. I will definitely fix that.
About the snow, It was originally a filler, but I liked how it came out, so I kept it that way. Although I do agree that it needs to look more unique, which I will work on.
Thanks for the constructive criticism guys!
Edit:
How's this for the new snow?
-Luis