Jump to content

  • Curse Sites
Become a Premium Member! Help
Latest News Article

rsmalec's Maps & over 590 Ratings!

reviews adventure parkour pvp ctm creation survival puzzle rsmalec game

  • Please log in to reply
2577 replies to this topic

#1

rsmalec
    rsmalec

    Blaze Extinguisher

  • Curse Premium
  • Curse Premium
  • 4541 posts

Posted 13 April 2011 - 10:36 PM

*
POPULAR

Posted Image

YouTube: www.youtube.com/rsmalec

Twitter: @rsmalec


:Green: :Blue: :Green: :Blue: :Green: :Blue: MAP RATING CANDIDATES :Green: :Blue: :Green: :Blue: :Green: :Blue:


Status: FULL

I am not auto-accepting review requests at this time, but please feel free to post your links here for the consideration of the community.
What will catch my eye are truly unique maps that are designed with quality. The shorter the better. Must have screenshot(s) or video.

Maps in progress
Looking back on custom maps month by month, from 2011 - 2014!


:Green: :Blue: :Green: :Blue: :Green: :Blue: RECENTLY REVIEWED MAPS :Green: :Blue: :Green: :Blue: :Green: :Blue:

Apr 14 Perfect Vacations, by Vagosssssssssss: 19 (4+4+3+4+4) vid, Fantasy, 4 hrs
Apr 13 Moblympics, by Golgot100: 14 (3+2+3+3+3), Zombie follower, .5 hrs
Apr 7 Frost Breath, by Ermin Caft: 15 (3+3+3+3+3) vid, Arctic, 2 hrs
Mar 9 Legend of Blocks: Heist, by sicarius_19: 11 (2+2+2+3+2), Modern, 1 hr

Curious about what I'm playing most recently?  I try to change my skin for every LP.  Here's the latest! http://www.mcskinsea...om/skin/rsmalec

You can find other ongoing series on my YouTube channel ( http://www.youtube.com/rsmalec ) including mod reviews, map making tips and vlogs, survival series, multiplayer servers, and more!


Full list of adventure map ratings moved to second post
Full list of ratings for all other map types moved to third post
Ratings explanation and guidance moved to fourth post


:Green: :Blue: :Green: :Blue: :Green: :Blue: MY PUBLISHED MAPS :Green: :Blue: :Green: :Blue: :Green: :Blue:


... have been moved to the bottom of the 4th post.

:Green: :Blue: :Green: :Blue: :Green: :Blue: :Green: :Blue: :Green: :Blue: :Green: :Blue:



If you enjoy my maps and ratings, please consider donating so that I can keep improving!
Posted Image



Posted Image


Register or log in to remove.

#2

rsmalec
    rsmalec

    Blaze Extinguisher

  • Curse Premium
  • Curse Premium
  • 4541 posts

Posted 26 April 2011 - 02:52 PM

Quote

Map Name and Link, by Author: Total Rating (Mechanics+Detail+Experience+Challenge+Progression) Link to Video if available, Genre, Estimated Duration
PF! = denotes one of my PERSONAL FAVORITES (regardless of the numeric rating)

:Green: :Blue: :Green: :Blue: :Green: :Blue: ADVENTURE MAP RATINGS :Green: :Blue: :Green: :Blue: :Green: :Blue:
1st post - recent reviews, in progress maps
3rd post - non-Adventure maps
4th post - rating scale


PF! A Day in Tuscarora, by dasButtocks: 20 (4+4+4+4+4) vid, Groundhog Day, 5 hrs
Chronotide, by Vladimyr: 20 (4+4+4+4+4) vid, Fantasy, 3 hrs
PF! City of Love, by Jigarbov/Team: 20 (4+4+4+4+4) vid, Dating Sim, 1 - 2 hrs
PF! Cruise Ship Down, by Sentimeta: 20 (4+4+4+4+4) vid, Mystery, 1 hr
PF! Déjà vu, by dasButtocks: 20 (4+4+4+4+4) vid, Reincarnation, 1.5 hrs
Eronev 2: Soul Cauldron, by Jigarbov: 20 (4+4+4+4+4) vid, Fantasy, 6 hrs
PF! Eronev Mansion Adventure, by Jigarbov&Feylina: 20 (4+4+4+4+4) vid, Modern Fantasy, 5.5 hrs
Gloria, by ColdFusionGaming: 20 (4+4+4+4+4) vid, SciFi, 1.5 hrs
Herobrine's Return, by Hypixel: 20 (4+4+4+4+4) vid, Fantasy, 1.5 hrs
Kingdom of the Sky, by BlameTheController: 20 (4+4+4+4+4) vid, Sky Islands, 4 hrs
Kingdom of the Sky 2, by BlameTheController: 20 (4+4+4+4+4) vid, Fantasy, 4 hrs
Prof. Grizwald and the Redstone Keys, by ChronoBasher: 20 (4+4+4+4+4) vid, Modern Fantasy, 2.5 hrs
QuestWorld - Shipwrecked, by smenx&ssankoo: 20 (4+4+4+4+4) vid, Modern Fantasy, 3 hrs
Rise of the Rebellion, by ParadiseDecay: 20 (4+4+4+4+4) vid, Star Wars, 2 hrs
PF! Jan 27 The Iron Rose, by SlaimCraft: 20 (4+4+4+4+4) vid, Prison Escape, 3.5 hrs
The L'brour Mansion, by ColdFusionGaming: 20 (4+4+4+4+4) vid, Mystery, 2 hrs
Zombie Apocalypse, by Hypixel: 20 (4+4+4+4+4) vid, Zombies, 1.5 hrs
CUBEception 2, by Gustavo Entertainment Team: 19 (4+4+3+4+4) vid, SciFi, 6.5 hrs
Destiny Craft - Chapitre I : Le village (French), by Wahars & Shayker77: 19 (4+3+4+4+4) vid, Fantasy, 2 hrs
Herobrine's Mansion, by Hypixel: 19 (4+4+4+3+4) vid, Fantasy, 4 hrs
Lord of BloodyCross, by daDonn: 19 (4+4+3+4+4) vid, Fantasy, 3 hrs
Pastry Pirates, by KupoKupo&Featherblade: 19 (4+4+4+3+4) vid, Fantasy, 4 hrs
Apr 14 Perfect Vacations, by Vagosssssssssss: 19 (4+4+3+4+4) vid, Fantasy, 4 hrs
Super Minecraft Bros., by overlordpawel: 19 (4+4+3+4+4), Mario, 1.5 hrs
The Tourist, by stratocrafteur: 19 (4+4+3+4+4) vid, Paris, 2 hrs
Twelve, by JeTSpice: 19 (3+4+4+4+4) vid, Scifi, 4.5 hrs
PF! Wintertide, by Vladimyr: 19 (4+4+4+3+4) vid, Victorian Puzzler, 1 hr
Wrath of the Fallen, by Hypixel: 19 (4+4+4+3+4) vid, Fantasy, 2.5 hrs
A Letter from Silent Heaven, by Vladimyr: 18 (4+4+3+3+4) vid, Silent Hill Adaptation, 5 hrs
PF! A View on Life, by Janeiac: 18 (3+4+4+3+4) vid, Childhood Depression, 2 hrs
Boulefield, by Priest Bob: 18 (4+3+4+4+3) vid, Steampunk, 3 hrs
Deep Space Turtle Chase (Part 1), by The Voxel Box: 18 (4+4+4+3+3) vid, SciFi, 8 hrs
Destiny (WIP), by Barthuc: 18 (4+4+3+4+3), Fantasy, 1.5 hrs
Elemental, by Golgot100: 18 (4+3+3+4+4) vid, Puzzler, 2 hrs
PF! Enigma Island, by yiker: 18 (4+3+3+4+4) vid, Puzzler, 3 hrs
Hard to Be a God (SPANISH), by Rapturegades: 18 (4+4+4+3+3) vid, Sci Fi, 4 hrs
Hero's Quest III: The Forest of Shadows, by ColdFusionGaming: 18 (4+4+3+4+3) vid, Fantasy, 3.5 hrs
Mine4Dead: Blockhawk Down, by bananafone31: 18 (3+4+4+3+4) vid, Zombie Apocalypse, 1 hr
Presumed 4 Dead, by BanzaiBrigade: 18 (3+4+4+3+4) vid, Zombie Apocalypse, .5 hrs
The 2013 Minecon Adventure Map, by Broken Buttons: 18 (4+4+4+3+3) vid, Mindcrack, 3.5 hrs
The Fall of Gondolin, by MCMEAT: 18 (4+4+3+4+3) vid, Lord of the Rings, 3.5 hrs
PF! You Just Got Schooled!, by ZeroG3651 & WhiteKnight001: 18 (4+4+4+3+3) vid, School Escape, .5 hrs
Castlevania: Black Widow, by SlySlasher: 17 (3+4+3+4+3), Castlevania, 2 hrs
Convenience 2, by Aramanon: 17 (3+4+3+4+3) vid, Fantasy, 2.5 hrs
Creeper Invasion, by planetfall666: 17 (4+3+2+4+4) vid, SciFi, 2.5 hrs
Crimson Asylum, by Scix: 17 (4+4+3+3+3) vid, Psychological Escape, 1.5 hrs
Criswelvania, by Criswell: 17 (4+4+3+3+3) vid, Castlevania, 3 hrs
Desperado, by AuraCloud: 17 (4+4+3+3+3) vid, Western, 1 hr
Ghosts of the Sargasso, by Utenan: 17 (4+4+3+3+3) vid, Fantasy, 1 hr
PF! Grinchmas, by rsmalec: 17 (3+4+4+2+4) vid, Christmas, 1 hr
Hammerside, by Razack541: 17 (4+3+3+4+3) vid, Fantasy, 1.5 hrs
Heroes of Minecraftia, by icepak00: 17 (4+4+3+3+3) vid, Fantasy, 2 hrs
Hero's Quest II: Temple of the Sky, by ColdFusionGaming: 17 (4+4+2+3+4) vid, Fantasy, 2.5 hrs
Kurast, by Krimnox: 17 (4+4+2+3+4) vid, Fantasy, 5 hrs
Legend of Zelda: Block to the Past, by Peanuts363 & Koros: 17 (4+4+4+4+1) vid, Zelda, 4 hrs
Mars Mission, by rsmalec: 17 (3+4+4+3+3) vid, SciFi, 1.5 hrs
Memories of Darker Days, by DarkoHexar: 17 (4+4+3+3+3), Fantasy, 1 hr
Monarch of Madness, by DarkoHexar: 17 (4+4+3+3+3) vid, Psychological Escape, 1.5 hrs
Old Hatreds, by Gustavo Entertainment Team: 17 (4+3+3+3+4) vid, Floating Islands, 5 hrs
Respawn: The Unseen Journey, by Tshara: 17 (4+4+2+4+3) vid, Fantasy, 4.5 hrs
Revenge of the Dragon Egg, by DSLMediaPro: 17 (4+4+3+3+3) vid, Fantasy, 10 hrs
The Chase, by Kiwi_as: 17 (4+4+3+3+3), Fantasy, 1 hr
The Tower of Xotl, by Akito12345: 17 (4+4+2+4+3) vid, SciFi, 1.5 hrs
PF! Feb 16 Waterworld 2070, by Rodgermourtagh: 17 (2+4+4+4+3), Post Apocalypse, 3.5 hrs
PF! Accept Your Own Adventure, by Gregolas42: 16 (3+2+4+3+4) vid, Fantasy, 1 hr
Archer Hero, by AuraCloud: 16 (4+3+3+3+3) vid, Archery, 45 min
CUBEception Reloaded, by Gustavo Entertainment Team: 16 (4+3+2+3+4) vid, Escape, 5 hrs
PF! Egypt, by MineKraphte: 16 (4+4+2+3+3) vid, Egyptian, 2.5 hrs
Freeport, by utenan: 16 (4+2+3+4+3) vid, Forgotten Realms D&D, 1 hr
Guardian of the Emerald Forest, by kninj: 16 (3+4+3+3+3), Fantasy, 1 hr
Johto, by blitzscrank: 16 (3+3+3+3+4) vid, Pokemon, 6 hrs
Land of Kronos, by benhutchings: 16 (4+4+2+3+3), Scavenger Hunt, 1 hr
Mt. Everest Expedition, by hunter4hire: 16 (4+3+3+3+3) vid, Mountain Climbing, 1 hr
Nomar (Part Two) - Perilous Depths, by SirPocket: 16 (3+3+3+4+3) vid, Fantasy, 1hr 15 min
Payday: The Minecraft Heist, by Xander369: 16 (3+4+3+3+3) vid, Burglary, 2 hrs
Pharaoh's Curse, by Kiwi_as: 16 (4+3+3+4+2) vid, Egyptian Puzzler, 1.5 hrs
Sherlock Holmes and the Blocky Conspiracy, by RedMineWolf & FacePuncherXL: 16 (4+4+3+3+2) vid, Mystery, 1.5 hrs
The Crofts Treasure, by Bigre: 16 (3+4+2+4+3) vid, Mansion Parkour, 1.5 hrs
The LOST (TV Show) Island Map, by Prof_Snape&iKonakona: 16 (4+3+4+3+2) vid, LOST, 2 hrs
The Redmurk Mystery, by Billiardball: 16 (3+4+3+3+3) vid, Mystery, 4 hrs
The Return of Dr. Frincklebottom, by Vladimyr: 16 (3+3+4+3+3) vid, Secret Agent, 1.5 hrs
The Search for the Queen Bee, by Barlor: 16 (3+3+3+4+3), Fantasy, .5 hrs
The Story of Curious, by Fellonius Wizard: 16 (4+3+3+3+3) vid, Fantasy, 1 hr
Top Ramen, by dasButtocks: 16 (3+4+2+4+3) vid, Modern, 4 hrs
Beneath Zero, by Raziel: 15 (3+4+3+3+2), Modern Fantasy, .5 hrs
Destroy the Diamond Comet, by Munchable901: 15 (3+3+3+4+2) vid, SciFi, .5 hrs
Garfield Digs In, by rsmalec: 15 (3+4+3+2+3) vid, Comic Book Adaptation, .5 hrs
Gloria 2, by ColdFusionGaming: 15 (4+3+2+3+3) vid, Scifi, 3 hrs
God of War, by Jcnator: 15 (3+3+2+4+3), God of War, 3 hrs
Inspector Hemlock and the Bermuda Circus, by Thistlehoof: 15 (3+4+2+3+3) vid, Mystery, 3 hrs
Last of Us, by smokeysamcat: 15 (3+4+3+2+3), Plague Apocalypse, 1.5 hrs
Levi's Nightmare, by Kmilley: 15 (3+3+4+3+2) vid, Infection, 1.5 hrs
Link of Faith, by SkyeGU: 15 (3+3+3+3+3) vid, Myst, 6.5 hrs
Luigi's Mansion: Dark Moon, by ColdFusionGaming: 15 (3+3+3+3+3) vid, Ghost Hunters, 1.5 hrs
Melody, by Thalizar: 15 (3+3+4+3+2) vid, Puzzler/Memories, 2 hrs
Merlin (part 1), by FaithCupid: 15 (3+3+4+3+2) vid, Arthurian Adaptation, 1 hr
Military Base Infiltration, by Vicohen, Flunfish, NomiSter: 15 (3+3+3+3+3) vid, Secret Agent, 1 hr
Poor Pete's Pumpkin Problem, by Razack541: 15 (3+4+2+3+3) vid, Fantasy, 2 hrs
Prof. Grizwald and the Curse of the Pyramid, by ChronoBasher: 15 (3+2+3+4+3) vid, Fantasy, 1 hr
Razul, by BlockFortress: 15 (3+3+2+4+3) vid, Skyrim Inspired, 3 hrs
Reckoning, by Jack & Ryan: 15 (3+3+3+3+3) vid, Fantasy, 3.5 hrs
Red Dead Redstone, by D1280: 15 (3+3+3+4+2) vid, Western, 5 hrs
Secret of Bruce Wayne, by Dandii: 15 (3+3+3+3+3) vid, Batman, 1.5 hrs
Star Wars II, by LordPhyce: 15 (3+3+3+3+3) vid, Star Wars, .5 hrs
Super Mario Galaxy, by 99blockmaking: 15 (3+4+3+3+2) vid, Super Mario, 1.5 hrs
SUPERHEROES, by rsmalec: 15 (3+3+3+3+3) vid, Superheroes, 3 hrs
The Evil Scientist, by BlackCaptain23: 15 (3+3+2+4+3) vid, Time Travel, 1.5 hrs
The Eye, by Openf1rE: 15 (4+4+2+2+3) vid, TV Shows, .5 hrs
The Jugglers Balls, by Jigarbov: 15 (4+3+3+2+3) vid, Crude Humor, .5 hrs
The Mysterious East, by GaoFurui, Pikimon&Cesar123: 15 (3+4+3+3+2) vid, Oriental, 5 - 6 hrs
The Quest of Merravid, by Fellonius Wizard: 15 (3+2+3+3+4) vid, Fantasy, 2 hrs
The Risen Dead: Mansion, by SunFury: 15 (3+3+3+3+3) vid, Mob Fight, .5 hrs
The Sunken Island Adventure, by inHaze: 15 (3+4+3+3+2) vid, Mysterious Island, 2 hrs
Through the Gate, by utenan: 15 (3+4+3+2+3) vid, Fantasy, .5 hrs
Town Terror, by Daruth505: 15 (3+3+3+3+3) vid, Fantasy, 1.5 hrs
Waapantamwa, by Pikimon_2 & Cesar_123: 15 (3+4+3+3+2) vid, Post Apocalypse, 7 hrs
Aramis, by lolo500: 14 (3+3+3+2+3), Fantasy, 4 hrs
Awakening of Demons: Skel-Rads Curse, by Blackpin: 14 (3+2+3+3+3), Fantasy, 1 hr
Creation, by Jvample: 14 (3+2+3+3+3), Escape, 1 hr
Curse of Sunny Springs, by aperture: 14 (3+3+2+3+3) vid, Modern, 1.5 hrs
Mar 2 Doom Island, by Adventurenow: 14 (3+2+3+3+3), Fantasy, 5 hrs
Falling to War, by Andmyster: 14 (3+2+3+3+3) vid, Army, .5 hrs
Finding Atlantis, by The Mine Empire: 14 (2+3+3+3+3) vid, Fantasy, 3 hrs
Feb 22 Floor -2B, by REMO: 14 (3+2+3+3+3), Horror, .5 hrs
Half Minute Adventure, by Golling: 14 (3+3+3+2+3) vid, Modern, 5 min
Illusion Escape 1, by Cocopuffz: 14 (3+3+2+3+3) vid, Escape, 1.5 hrs
Lunar Awakening, by Circleight: 14 (2+4+3+3+2) vid, Fantasy, 1.5 hrs
Murder on the Zurich Express, by Fellonius Wizard: 14 (3+3+3+3+2), Detective, 1 hr
Mystery of the Pumpkin Castle, by DarkoHexar: 14 (2+3+3+3+3) vid, Fantasy, 1.5 hrs
Paradox, by tomdm134, Ad134: 14 (3+3+3+3+2) vid, SciFi, 1.5 hrs
Phantom Protocol, by TheEnderSlayer05 & ThePotatoeSlayer: 14 (3+3+3+3+2) vid, Secret Agent, 15 min
Pokemon! Original Version, by blitzscrank: 14 (3+2+3+3+3) vid, Pokemon, 2 hrs
Project: Central, by Vaaldraem: 14 (2+3+3+3+3), High School, 2.5 hrs
Quest for the Blockforce 1, by VaalDeth: 14 (3+3+2+3+3) vid, Fantasy, 2 hrs
Return of the Netheran, by Exolio: 14 (3+2+3+3+3), Fantasy, 1.5 hrs
Ruins of Kegrin, by JesusNails: 14 (3+3+2+3+3) vid, Fantasy, 1.5 hrs
Satellite Islands, by timmyboyNL: 14 (3+3+2+3+3) vid, SciFi, 1.5 hrs
Save the Children, by PodCrash: 14 (2+3+3+3+3), Rescue, .5 hrs
Star Wars: Final Assault, by Mlnecrqfters: 14 (3+3+3+3+2) vid, Star Wars, .5 hrs
Star Wars: The Republic's Ascent, by TheHydraTank_2: 14 (4+3+2+2+3) vid, Star Wars, 45 min
The Devil's Chase, by yiker: 14 (3+2+3+3+3), Morality, 1 hr
The Island, by Krimnox: 14 (2+3+3+3+3), Fantasy, 1.5 hrs
The Monastery, by BickerCraft: 14 (4+3+3+2+2), Horror, 45 min
The Simpsons School Heist, by 3DZG: 14 (3+2+3+3+3) vid, Simpsons, 1 hr
The Time Traveler's Mission, by Proberoo: 14 (3+2+3+3+3), SciFi, 1.5 hrs
The Time Traveler's Mission 2, by Proberoo: 14 (3+3+2+3+3), SciFi, 1 hr
Feb 4 The Vagary Incident, by Tmtravlr: 14 (3+3+3+3+2) vid, Dreamworlds, 11 hrs+
Tunnels Through Time, by PlayingWithPixels: 14 (3+3+2+3+3) vid, Time Travel, 3.5 hrs
Under Dirt, by Zvede: 14 (2+3+3+3+3) vid, Modern, 2 hrs
Feb 23 When Brothers Fight, by AngryLover: 14 (2+2+4+3+3), US Civil War, 2 hrs
2038: Mobile Murder Mystery, by ColdFusionGaming: 13 (3+2+3+2+3) vid, Detective, 45 min
A Light in the Distance, by MacklinB, Tri2Escape, Scorpionza: 13 (3+2+2+3+3) vid, National Park, 2 hrs
Aneara EnASP, by Fellonius Wizard: 13 (3+2+2+3+3), Fantasy, 3 hrs
Back to the Future, by aperture: 13 (3+2+2+3+3) vid, Adaptation, 1 hr
Bad Weather, by cozash: 13 (3+2+2+3+3) vid, Fantasy, 1.5 hrs
Castlevania: Blood Moon, by SlySlasher: 13 (2+2+2+4+3), Castlevania, 1 hr
Convenience, by Aramanon: 13 (3+2+2+4+2), Fantasy, 1 hr
Cube Inc., by CWHunt456: 13 (3+2+2+3+3), SciFi, 3 hrs
Demonic Presence, by TheWardVG: 13 (3+3+2+2+3), Fantasy, 2 hrs
Destiny, by abababab: 13 (3+2+3+3+2) vid, Morality, 2.5 hrs
Fear in a Handful of Dust, by rsmalec: 13 (2+3+3+3+2) vid, Edge of the Desert, 1 hr
PF! Half Minute Adventure: The Black Knights, by Golling: 13 (2+3+3+2+3) vid, Fantasy, 15 min
In the Shadow of the Tree, by jsext1101&ImManning: 13 (3+3+2+3+2) vid, Post Apocalypse, 3.5 hrs
Indiana Jones and the Source of Life, by MrSmith10: 13 (3+4+2+3+1), Indiana Jones, 3 hrs
Knowing, by ModernTurk: 13 (3+3+2+3+2), Modern, 1 hr
Lands of Xera, by Robertx32: 13 (3+3+2+3+2), Fantasy, 4 hrs
Lands United, by Ressficent: 13 (3+2+3+3+2), Fantasy, 2.5 hrs
Legend of Nazar, by RookieN: 13 (3+2+3+3+2) vid, Fantasy, 1 hr
Legends of Akatosh, by Robertx32, Pixelbits, ICanHaz46, Mazzeltje: 13 (3+2+1+4+3), Fantasy, 3.5 hrs
MCPyramid, by War904: 13 (3+3+1+3+3), Puzzler, 1.5 hrs
Nomar (Part One) - A Miner's Tale, by SirPocket: 13 (3+3+2+3+2), Fantasy, 1 hr
Shadow of Mars, by Raziel: 13 (3+2+3+3+2), SciFi, 1.5 hrs
Staircase, by iMinecraft1337: 13 (3+2+3+2+3) vid, Jump Scares, 2 hrs
Star Wars: Mesa 291, by Fellonius Wizard: 13 (3+2+3+3+2) vid, Star Wars, .5 hrs
Suicide, by Thalizar: 13 (3+2+3+3+2) vid, Modern, 45 min
The E.D.E.N. Project, by Struanm MCD: 13 (3+3+2+3+2) vid, SciFi, 1.5 hrs
The Forbidden Kingdom, by fizzymine: 13 (3+3+2+3+2), Feudal Japan, 1.5 hrs
The Lost Manuscript, by MineKraphte: 13 (3+3+2+3+2), Feudal Japan, 1 hr
The Road to El Dorado, by BurnYourToast: 13 (2+3+3+3+2) vid, City of Gold, 1.5 hrs
The Secret of the Stones, by ihatemimes: 13 (3+2+3+2+3), Fantasy, 2.5 hrs
The Sewers, by tRmz: 13 (2+3+3+3+2), Escape, .5 hrs
The Signature, by Stervma: 13 (3+2+2+3+3) vid, Fantasy, 45 min
The Sky's Wrath, by Skarath: 13 (3+3+3+3+1), Floating Islands, 2 hrs
The Swarm, by stervma: 13 (3+2+3+3+2) vid, Scifi, 1 hr
The Three Princes (Maps 1, 2, and 3), by Sofokal: 13 (2+2+2+4+3), Fantasy, 2.5 hrs
The Tree of Life, by .toggle: 13 (2+3+2+3+3), Fantasy, 1.5 hrs
Unbound, by Verques: 13 (2+3+2+3+3), Fantasy, 5 hrs
Watch the Tardis, by kanokarob: 13 (3+2+3+3+2) vid, Doctor Who, 1.5 hrs
Who Am I, by Thalizar: 13 (3+2+3+3+2), Escape, 1 hr
Wonderland, by rsmalec: 13 (2+3+3+3+2) vid, Alice in Wonderland, 1 hr
World of Puzzles, by niemand203: 13 (3+3+2+3+2), Fantasy, 1 hr
A Robot's Little Story, by Javoras97, dann&mirza: 12 (3+2+3+2+2) vid, SciFi, .5 hrs
Ancient Mystery, by Vaine: 12 (2+3+2+3+2), Fantasy, 1 hr
Ancient Waterways, by Savato: 12 (2+3+2+3+2), Sewer, 1 hr
bryce24's mini rpg, by minecraft24: 12 (2+3+2+3+2), Fantasy, .5 hrs
Castlevania: Rebirth, by Dyz-69: 12 (2+3+2+3+2), Castlevania, 1.5 hrs
Chronicle of Rodrick, by BlueJayNebula: 12 (2+2+3+3+2) vid, Fantasy, 3 hrs
Curing the Darkness, by M0ndy: 12 (2+3+3+2+2) vid, Secret Agent, .5 hrs
Desolate, by GreenGorilla8: 12 (2+2+3+3+2) vid, Drowned City, 8 - 10 hrs
Eldmorang Alpha, by PlanetFall666: 12 (3+2+2+2+3) vid, SciFi, 1.5 hrs
Escape from Zanzer's Dungeon, by Axcalibar: 12 (2+2+2+3+3) vid, Dungeons & Dragons, .5 hrs
Fall From The Sky, by funstuff123: 12 (2+2+3+3+2), Fantasy, 45 min
FFTTS, by idrey: 12 (3+3+2+3+1), Portal, 3 hrs
Forever You, by Komsjer: 12 (3+3+2+2+2), Psychological Escape, 1 hr
Island Quest, by Swkoll: 12 (2+2+2+3+3), Fantasy, 1 hr
Jurrasic Park, by aperture: 12 (3+3+2+2+2), Jurassic Park, .5 hrs
KingKiller, by CreeperFail: 12 (3+2+2+3+2) vid, Modern, 1.5 hrs
Laboratory of Dr. Eastrange, by clevelandballer: 12 (2+3+2+3+2) vid, Modern, 1.5 hrs
Mayhem Mansion, by Moldy Eskimo: 12 (2+2+2+3+3), Modern, .5 hrs
Millenium, by Openf1rE: 12 (2+3+2+3+2), Modern, .5 hrs
Minoria - The Four Keys, by powercutters: 12 (3+2+2+3+2), Fantasy, 1.5 hrs
Mr. Griefer, by Josh Bryden: 12 (3+2+2+3+2), Escape, .5 hrs
Nursery Rhyme Village, by PiperBunny: 12 (3+3+2+2+2), Nursery Rhymes, .5 hrs
Pointless Button, by Zvede: 12 (2+3+2+2+3), Random, .5 hrs
Feb 15 Profane Catacombs, by Excedro2: 12 (2+3+3+3+1), Fantasy, 1 hr
Pumpkin Monsters, by Captain_Bilal: 12 (3+2+2+3+2) vid, Fantasy, .5 hrs
Redwall Abbeycraft: The Corsair's Last Treasure, by Soma Games: 12 (3+3+3+2+1) vid, Redwall, 5 hrs
Search for the Nether Blade, by TotallyEpicFail: 12 (2+3+2+3+2), Fantasy, 1 hr
Secrets of the Paragon Island, by Sinathor: 12 (2+3+2+3+2), Fantasy, 4 hrs
Shadows of the Netherdark, by finalfrog: 12 (3+3+2+2+2), Fantasy, 1.5 hrs
The Chronicles of Ardianor, by Chick0nhead & Oliverthepen: 12 (2+2+2+3+3) vid, Fantasy, 2 hrs
The Dangerous West, by vicohen: 12 (3+2+3+2+2), Aliens, 45 min
The Forest of Silence, by Fangride: 12 (3+2+2+3+2), Fantasy, 2 hrs
The Infinite Improbability Drive, by Verques: 12 (2+3+2+3+2) vid, SciFi, 2.5 hrs
The Legend Of Zelda: Back To Pixels, by theonlybmax: 12 (2+3+2+3+2) vid, Zelda, 1 hr
The Pink Diner, by Kahspiller: 12 (3+3+2+2+2) vid, Modern, .5 hrs
The Quest for Creeper Cove, by Yellow9: 12 (3+2+2+3+2), Fantasy, 1.5 hrs
The Trials of the 7 Beacons, by Wipper1799: 12 (2+3+2+3+2), Fantasy, 1 hr
The Wizard, by Spellyr: 12 (2+3+2+3+2), Fantasy, 2.5 hrs
Trials of Fate, by DarkShadow1223: 12 (3+3+3+1+2) vid, Fantasy, 3 hrs
World of Stories, by komsjer: 12 (3+2+2+3+2), Fantasy, 2 hrs
Zork Craft, by Shwa: 12 (2+2+2+4+2), Zork, 1.5 hrs
4 Pillars of Adventure, by ArchaeopteryxAlex: 11 (2+3+2+3+1), SciFi, 3.5 hrs
Adventerprise, by Zinnsee: 11 (2+3+2+2+2) vid, Star Trek, 1 hr
Alucard, by Broken Buttons: 11 (3+4+2+1+1), Vampire, 1 hr
BreakOut, by TheSmurfAttack: 11 (2+2+2+3+2) vid, Prison Escape, 1 hr
Celestial Seals, by Merrik&Elly Banearrow: 11 (3+2+2+2+2), Fantasy, 4 hrs
Croatoan, by loplop95: 11 (3+2+2+2+2), Historic, .5 hrs
Deserted Kingdom, by CynicalSurvivor: 11 (2+2+2+3+2) vid, Fantasy, .5 hrs
Discoveries of the End, by YouGotConroed: 11 (2+4+1+2+2), Fantasy, 1.5 hrs
Disney Quest, by PiperBunny: 11 (3+2+2+2+2), Disney, 2.5 hrs
Forge of the Ancients, by Sinathor: 11 (2+2+2+2+3), Fantasy, 1.5 hrs
Free Nachos, by oc_llort: 11 (2+2+3+2+2), Strange, .5 hrs
From Beyond, by blub212212: 11 (2+2+2+3+2), Modern, 2.5 hrs
Gotham Craft: Enigma Asylum, by Taizzzzzed: 11 (3+2+2+3+1) vid, Batman, 1.5 hrs
Gourd Avenger, by Akito12345: 11 (2+2+3+2+2), Fantasy, 1.5 hrs
Hero's Quest 1: The Flame of Life, by ColdFusionGaming: 11 (3+2+2+2+2), Fantasy, 1.5 hrs
Into the Far Lands, by LycanSpartan: 11 (2+3+1+3+2) vid, Fantasy, 1 hr
Mar 9 Legend of Blocks: Heist, by sicarius_19: 11 (2+2+2+3+2), Modern, 1 hr
Meteor Mash, by eshancowee: 11 (2+2+3+2+2), Fantasy, 1 hr
Payday the Heist: First Diamond Bank, by SovericAxiom: 11 (2+2+2+3+2) vid, Bank Robbery, .5 hrs
Potion Quest, by abe123: 11 (2+3+2+2+2) vid, Alchemy, .5 hrs
Shipwrecked, by Orange1095: 11 (3+2+2+2+2), Mob Fight/Trading, .5 hrs
Stolen Fortune (World 1), by Ressficent: 11 (2+2+2+3+2), Modern, 2 hrs
Summers End, by Marshall Bro: 11 (2+2+2+3+2), Fantasy, .5 hrs
Super Mario Bros.!, by jaxot: 11 (3+2+2+2+2), Super Mario Bros, .5 hrs
Terrarian Invasion, by Peartnoy518815: 11 (2+2+3+3+1), Fantasy, 3.5 hrs
The Black House, by Openf1rE: 11 (2+3+2+2+2), Modern, .5 hrs
The Cruise Ship, by Red39: 11 (3+2+2+2+2) vid, Modern, .5 hrs
The Employer, by Colonel_Trout&ScarletDevilist: 11 (2+2+2+3+2) vid, Delivery, 45 min
The Infestation, by MyBoner: 11 (3+3+2+1+2) vid, Alien Invasion, 1 hr
The Legend of Zey Vah Dov, by 2204thForge: 11 (2+2+2+3+2) vid, Fantasy, .5 hrs
The Lost City of Maya, by Fatcakes: 11 (3+2+2+3+1) vid, Archeology, 2 hrs
The Ring of the Queen, by ColdFusionGaming: 11 (2+2+2+3+2) vid, Fantasy, .5 hrs
The Tomato, by MyBoner: 11 (3+2+2+2+2) vid, SciFi, 1 hr
The Wizard Burgmund, by Koquitlum: 11 (2+2+2+3+2), Fantasy, 1.5 hrs
Torment of Taskil, by RaApsam: 11 (3+2+2+2+2), SciFi, 3.5 hrs
You Have to Burn the Wool, by Jigarbov: 11 (2+2+2+3+2) vid, Mob Fight, 15 min
Calmere Nightmare, by xaxk: 10 (2+3+2+1+2), Horror, 1 hr
Crash Landing, by LeMinecrafter: 10 (2+2+2+2+2) vid, SciFi, .5 hrs
Cravenwood, by MinecraftCreeprX: 10 (2+2+2+2+2), Horror, 1 hr
Doctor Who Map Pack #1, by TARDISCraft: 10 (3+2+1+2+2), Doctor Who, .5 hrs
Fallen Rose, by TheFRSystem: 10 (2+2+2+2+2), Fantasy, 1 hr
Haunted House and Castle, by xX50callXx: 10 (2+2+2+2+2), Modern, .5 hrs
Hunger Games, by revix2k9: 10 (2+2+3+2+1) vid, Book Adaptation, 1 hr
Inconclusion, by tRmz: 10 (2+2+2+2+2), Fantasy, 1 hr
Legends of Avalon, by Peanuts363: 10 (2+2+2+2+2), Fantasy, 2 hrs
Lost City of Adlez, by Aarow: 10 (3+1+2+3+1), Fantasy, 2.5 hrs
Mar 1 Mystery of the Island of Tmesis, by R10soccer: 10 (2+2+2+2+2), Mystery, 1 hr
Mystery Mountains Adventure, by DantheFOBFan: 10 (2+2+2+2+2), Fantasy, .5 hrs
Pandorum, by Spikesrun: 10 (2+2+2+3+1), SciFi, 2 hrs
Phantom Protocol: The Decision, by TheEnderSlayer05 & ThePotatoSlayer: 10 (2+2+2+2+2) vid, Secret Agent, 15 min
Platoria 2, by Tarquin999: 10 (2+2+2+2+2), Puzzler, 1.5 hrs
Prof. Grizwold Assistant - The Obsidian Armor, by takko0: 10 (2+2+2+3+1) vid, Fantasy, 2.5 hrs
Project Chronos, by El_Dabo: 10 (2+3+2+2+1) vid, SciFi, 2 hrs
Feb 23 Searching for an Answer, by stormman09: 10 (2+2+2+2+2), Modern Fantasy, .5 hrs
Sebastian Hurle and the Forgotten Village, by Cuuldude: 10 (2+2+2+2+2), Fantasy, .5 hrs
Tales of Donnaford, by MartinN95: 10 (2+2+2+2+2), Modern, 1.5 hrs
The Caverns, by KamikazeReaper: 10 (2+2+2+2+2), Fantasy, 1.5 hrs
The Diamond Hunter, by Skylevis: 10 (2+3+1+2+2), Puzzler, 1.5 hrs
The Hyperion's Universe, by BickerCraft: 10 (3+2+2+1+2), Hell Parkour, 1.5 hrs
The Jackal and the Cave, by xaxk: 10 (2+2+2+2+2), Fantasy, 1 hr
The Mystery of Eradallion, by DJCappox: 10 (2+2+2+2+2), Fantasy, 1.5 hrs
The Nether-Ending Story, by laughalotg: 10 (2+1+2+3+2), Puzzler, 1 hr
The Obsidian Fortress, by Sinathor: 10 (2+2+2+2+2) vid, Fantasy, .5 hrs
The Odyssey, by masmaster50: 10 (2+2+2+2+2) vid, Historical, 1 hr
The Secret of Wayhart Point, by rseah: 10 (2+2+2+2+2), Fantasy, 1.5 hrs
The Story of Gorgoth, by Darkfard: 10 (2+2+1+3+2) vid, Time Travel, 1 hr
The Temple of the Gods, by Trumavarium: 10 (2+2+2+2+2), Mythology Puzzler, 1.5 hrs
The Temple of Trials, by Ravioli_Rick: 10 (2+3+2+1+2) vid, Fantasy, 2 hrs
The Village on the Horizon, by Trixionic: 10 (2+2+2+2+2), Fantasy, 1.5 hrs
White Earth, by DiabloTK: 10 (2+2+2+2+2) vid, Post Apocalypse, 2 hrs
World Out of Time, by rsmalec: 10 (2+2+2+2+2), Post Apocalypse, 1 hr

Continued on the next post...

See my fourth post for explanation of the rating scale!

Posted Image


#3

rsmalec
    rsmalec

    Blaze Extinguisher

  • Curse Premium
  • Curse Premium
  • 4541 posts

Posted 22 May 2011 - 12:38 PM

See my first post for my in-progress and review queues!
See my second post for Adventure type maps!
See my fourth post for explanation of the rating scale!


Quote

Anatomy of a Map Listing:
Map Name and Link, by Author: Total Rating (Mechanics+Detail+Experience+Challenge+Progression) Link to Video, Genre, Estimated Duration
PF! = denotes one of my PERSONAL FAVORITES (regardless of the numeric rating)

:Green: :Blue: :Green: :Blue: :Green: :Blue: ADVENTURE MAP RATINGS Continued :Green: :Blue: :Green: :Blue: :Green: :Blue:

Abducted by the Taco, by Nicky41205: 9 (3+2+2+1+1) vid, Escape, .5 hrs
Assault of the Mobs, by AndrasX: 9 (3+2+1+1+2) vid, Post Apocalypse, 2.5 hrs
Bellmoore, by Shermantank93462: 9 (2+2+2+2+1), Fantasy, 1.5 hrs
Bitterwind Sanctum, by Kriptini: 9 (3+2+2+1+1), Frozen Ruins, 1 hr
Cataclysm: Wrath of the Wither, by deathwarrior999: 9 (2+2+2+1+2) vid, Fantasy, 1 hr
Dahlia's Freedom, by Jordip: 9 (2+1+2+2+2) vid, Testing Facility, 1 hr
Dungeon Quest, by MightyPork: 9 (2+2+2+1+2) vid, Fantasy, .5 hrs
Fishy World, by AF12Gamer: 9 (1+1+2+3+2), Fish Sim, 15 min
Hitchminer's Guide to the Galaxy, by ExtraBB: 9 (2+2+1+2+2) vid, SciFi, .5 hrs
Indiana Notch and the Pyramid of Life, by Ddreamers: 9 (2+2+1+3+1), Indiana Jones, .5 hrs
Invasion and Quarantine, by 353blaze: 9 (2+1+2+2+2) vid, Zombie Apocalypse, .5 hrs
Jinu, the Lost Land, by StreamofAdventure&ChocolateChip33: 9 (2+1+2+3+1), Puzzler, 1.5 hrs
Joe Bill and the Nazi Scientist part 2, by xbgaming685: 9 (2+1+2+2+2) vid, WWII, .5 hrs
Matt's Army, by cdop: 9 (2+2+2+2+1) vid, Army, .5 hrs
Minecraft Missions I: Infiltrate!, by invinciblemode: 9 (3+2+2+1+1) vid, Secret Agent, 2 hrs
Minecraft Missions II: Hijack!, by invinciblemode: 9 (3+2+1+2+1) vid, Secret Agent, .5 hrs
Mysteries of the Far Lands, by Gankerrr: 9 (2+2+2+2+1) vid, Fantasy, .5 hrs
Platoria 1, by Tarquin999: 9 (2+2+1+2+2), Puzzler, 1.5 hrs
Port Cross: The Lost Darkblade, by FaithCupid: 9 (2+2+2+1+2) vid, Fantasy, .5 hrs
Revenge of the Nerds, by Kataang203: 9 (2+1+2+3+1), Modern Puzzler, .5 hrs
Save Man-Kara Village, by SpinGamer: 9 (2+2+1+3+1), Modern, 1 hr
Terra Deserta, by BamDutchie: 9 (2+2+2+2+1), Fantasy, 1 hr
The Kingdom of Cobble, by SquintyThePanda: 9 (2+1+2+2+2), Fantasy, 45 min
The Substitute Santa, by kiwikrazy: 9 (2+2+1+2+2) vid, Christmas, .5 hrs
The Wizard's Robes, by stervma: 9 (2+2+2+2+1), Fantasy, 1.5 hrs
When Funerals Go Mad, by Lissu6789: 9 (2+1+2+2+2) vid, Murder, 15 min
Alone, by ddcoolreid & Squeeze King: 8 (2+2+1+2+1), Fantasy, 1.5 hrs
Amicable You, by aniket200929: 8 (2+1+2+2+1), Search, .5 hrs
Astability, by Midipidemy: 8 (1+3+1+1+2) vid, Scifi, 2 hrs
Authorn, by Johnny the Miner: 8 (2+2+1+2+1) vid, Fantasy, .5 hrs
Curse of the Monolith, by Concrist: 8 (1+1+2+2+2), Fantasy, .5 hrs
Dream, by 11401140: 8 (2+2+1+1+2), Escape, .5 hrs
Father's Treasure Beyond, by MineAndCraftADL: 8 (2+1+2+2+1), Treasure Hunt, .5 hrs
Hawkeye's Story, by Mason: 8 (2+2+1+2+1) vid, Superhero, .5 hrs
Kirby Multiplayer Adventure Map!, by RockWrecker10: 8 (2+1+2+2+1) vid, Kirby, 1 hr
NASA Adventure, by McBatmans: 8 (2+1+2+2+1), Astronaut Training, .5 hrs
Quest for Xanadu, by dilbertyard: 8 (2+2+1+2+1), Fantasy, 2 hrs
Reconstruction, by takanski: 8 (2+1+1+3+1) vid, Pyramid Puzzler, .5 hrs
Return to Mars, by TacticalCreeper: 8 (2+2+1+2+1) vid, SciFi, .5 hrs
Rosswood Park, by SheerCatAttack: 8 (2+1+1+2+2), Marble Hornets, 15 min
Sanctum/CaveDiving, by TheRussianPigeon: 8 (2+1+2+2+1), Spelunking, .5 hrs
Sleep Walk, by SparklyWalrusss: 8 (2+1+2+2+1), Desert, 15 min
The Heart of the Nether, by powercutters: 8 (2+1+1+2+2), Fantasy, 1 hr
The Revenge of the Squids, by PeterisBuilding: 8 (2+1+2+1+2) vid, Escape, .5 hrs
The Witch's Keep, by Scorpionza: 8 (2+2+1+2+1), Fantasy, 1 hr
Arnold Adventure, Chapter 1, by CrazyKyddultez: 7 (2+1+1+2+1), Action Hero, .5 hrs
Fugitive, by Gameznstuff: 7 (2+1+1+2+1), Fantasy, 1 hr
Steve, the Inside Story, by rsmalec: 7 (2+1+1+2+1), Puzzler, .5 hrs
The Alien Abduction, by Jenni_Biebzz_18 & SPARKYxSNIP35: 7 (2+1+1+2+1), Scifi, .5 hrs
The Avenger, by TuNeZz: 7 (2+2+1+1+1) vid, Modern, 1.5 hrs
The Lost Cleopatra (Demo), by Geheim1111: 7 (2+1+1+2+1) vid, Time Travel, 5 min
The Sorceror's Revenge, by piano9uber: 7 (2+1+1+2+1) vid, Boss battles, .5 hrs
Epic Batman, by EpickDuck44: 6 (1+1+1+2+1) vid, Batman, .5 hrs
Pixelmon, by flerbergerber: 6 (1+1+1+2+1) vid, Pokemon, .5 hrs
Quest for Gallell, by gistop: 6 (1+1+1+2+1), Fantasy, .5 hrs
Sun Knights vs. Ice Lord, by cukis: 6 (1+1+1+1+2), Fantasy, .5 hrs
Pokemon, by HomeCereals: 5 (1+1+1+1+1), Mob Fight, .5 hrs
The Voice Inside You, by alexthebest: 5 (1+1+1+1+1), Troll, 15 min

:Green: :Blue: :Green: :Blue: :Green: :Blue: Non-ADVENTURE MAP RATINGS :Green: :Blue: :Green: :Blue: :Green: :Blue:


Creation Maps

A Fly in the House, by Bigre: 20 (4+4+4+4+4), Scale Creation, .5 hrs
Airport, by mextremel: 20 (4+4+4+4+4) vid, Airport Creation, .5 hrs
High Rossferry City, by darkone: 20 (4+4+4+4+4) vid, Modern, .5 hrs
qmagnet's Resource Pack Test Map, by Qmagnet: 20 (4+4+4+4+4) vid, Textures, .5 hrs
Steve and the Beanstalk, by greg26400: 20 (4+4+4+4+4) vid, Jack and the Beanstalk, .5 hrs
USS Enterprise NCC1701A, by Mozzie: 20 (4+4+4+4+4), Star Trek, .5 hrs
PF! Crafting Azeroth, by Rumsey: 19 (4+3+4+4+4) vid, World of Warcraft, 8 to 10 hrs
Delfino Plaza, by Pressedlee: 19 (3+4+4+4+4), Mario Kart Creation, .5 hrs
PF! Kanto, by Eisenbahn: 19 (4+4+4+4+3) vid, Pokemon, 3 hrs
ParadiseDecay's YouTube Project, by ParadiseDecay: 19 (3+4+4+4+4) vid, Compilation, 1 hr
Tutorial World, by The Minecraft Teacher: 18 (3+3+4+4+4) vid, Tutorial, 1 hr
Sledlord Ivana's Sledmansion, by Antlia: 17 (4+4+3+4+2) vid, Arctic, .5 hrs
Twisted Logic: Redstone, by Kerblah: 17 (4+3+3+4+3) vid, Tutorial, 4 hrs
UCP - Skyscraper, by 5urface: 17 (3+4+3+4+3) vid, Modern, 15 min
Speak and Spell, by rsmalec: 16 (4+3+3+2+4) vid, Phonetic Device, 15 min
The Earth, by salexp: 16 (4+2+2+4+4), Scale Creation, 2 hrs
Mojam 2013 Map, by Faume/Community: 15 (2+4+3+4+2), Build Contest, .5 hrs
Broville, by Oldshoes: 14 (2+3+2+4+3), City, 1 hr
Death Star Roller Coaster, by ParadiseDecay: 14 (2+3+3+4+2) vid, Star Wars, 20 min
Lego Mars Mission Build, by MaDventures7: 14 (2+3+3+4+2) vid, Build, .5 hrs
The Resort, by Mjin79: 14 (3+2+3+4+2) vid, Resort, 15 min
Medieval City - Golden Kingdom, by ChinaTown10: 12 (2+2+2+4+2), Fantasy, .5 hrs
Stopping by Woods on a Snowy Evening, by n1n3: 8 (1+1+1+4+1) vid, Poem, 2 min

Complete the Monument (CTM) Maps

PF! Jan 24 Infinity Dungeon, by Jigarbov: 20 (4+4+4+4+4) vid, Random Dungeon, 1.5 hrs
Pantheon, by Hybran/Community: 20 (4+4+4+4+4) vid, Compilation, 20 - 40 hrs
Vinyl Fantasy II, by three_two: 20 (4+4+4+4+4) vid, Fantasy, 16 - 20 hrs
PF! Blight Castle, by Thadiwyn: 19 (3+4+4+4+4) vid, Fantasy, 16 hrs
Float (bRan's Mini-CTM 3), by Brandonn: 19 (4+4+4+4+3) vid, Fantasy, 6 hrs
Spellbound Caves, by Vechs: 19 (4+3+4+4+4) vid, Caverns, 4 hrs
Conquest Chute 1: Killer Banquet, by z_bill: 18 (4+4+4+3+3) vid, Creations, 4 hrs
PF! Feb 8 Emerald Dream: Keystone, by Orange1095: 18 (4+4+3+4+3) vid, SciFi/Fantasy, 15 - 30 hrs
From Ashes, by Gustavo Entertainment Team: 18 (4+4+4+3+3) vid, Post-Apocalypse, 16 - 30 hrs
PF! GiftWarped, by Vechs: 18 (3+3+4+4+4) vid, Modern, 15 hrs
Pathfinder Elemental, by ColdFusionGaming: 18 (3+3+4+4+4) vid, CTM, 1 hr
Twisted Logic II: Moon 2, by Kerblah: 18 (4+4+3+4+3) vid, SciFi, 15 - 30 hrs
Feb 11 Frostburn, by ColdFusionGaming: 17 (3+3+3+4+4) vid, MiniCTM, 4 - 8 hrs
Infernal Sky, by Vechs: 16 (3+3+3+4+3) vid, Floating Islands, 2 hrs
Inkstar, by StoneyPlays: 16 (3+4+3+3+3) vid, Fantasy, 50 - 100 hrs
Bridge Out, by Vladimyr: 15 (3+3+3+3+3) vid, Bridging, 4 -7 hrs
Canopy Carnage, by Vechs: 15 (3+3+3+3+3) vid, Massive jungle, 2 hrs
Waking Up, by Vechs: 15 (3+2+3+4+3) vid, Caverns, 15 - 20 hrs
Wool World, by Fumbuckle: 15 (3+2+3+4+3) vid, Wool, 3 hrs
Lost, by rsmalec: 14 (2+3+3+3+3) vid, LOST, 10 - 18 hrs
Sea of Flames II, by Vechs: 14 (3+2+3+3+3) vid, Volcanic, 3 hrs
The Vagrant Isles, by Dack105: 14 (3+3+2+3+3), Floating Islands, 6 hrs
Desert of Demons, by PlanetFall666: 13 (3+2+2+3+3) vid, Desert, 2 hrs
Hills of Moo, by Vechs: 13 (2+3+2+3+3) vid, Entry Level, 1.5 hrs
Soaring No Longer, by ColdFusionGaming: 13 (2+2+3+3+3) vid, Fantasy, 5 hrs
Spherecraft 2: Deep Sea, by Jep3: 13 (3+2+2+4+2), Underwater, 4 - 6 hrs
Spherecraft 4: The Corrupted Sky, by Jep3: 13 (3+2+2+4+2), Floating Islands, 4 - 6 hrs
Tyrannical Turf: Mythic Waters, by DinosaurWizard: 13 (2+2+3+3+3) vid, Islands, 10 - 20 hrs
Lethamyr, by Vechs: 11 (2+2+2+3+2) vid, Continental, 2.5 hrs
Golden Soul, by SpinGamer: 10 (2+2+1+3+2) vid, Modern, 1.5 hrs
Flight of the Phoenix, by Vuzok: 9 (2+2+2+2+1), Plane Crash, 2 hrs
Calliass44 New World, by Calliass44: 8 (2+2+1+2+1), CTM, 1 hr
Flood of Flames, by piano9uber: 8 (1+1+2+3+1), Lava, 5 hrs
Mini-Shorties: The Snow Island, by SerbiaPhantom: 7 (2+1+1+2+1), Snow Island, 3 hrs

Game Maps

PF! The Dropper, by Bigre: 20 (4+4+4+4+4) vid, Falling, 1 hr
The Dropper 2: Newton VS Darwin, by Bigre: 20 (4+4+4+4+4) vid, Falling, 2 hrs
PF! The Library, by rsmalec/Community: 20 (4+4+4+4+4) vid, Dropper, 8 hrs
PF! Eronev Chronicles: The Flood, by Jigarbov: 19 (4+3+4+4+4) vid, Flood, .5 hrs
Evil Santa Boss Fight, by disco: 19 (4+4+4+4+3) vid, Minigame, 15 min
The Building Game, by SethBling: 18 (4+2+4+4+4) vid, Operator, .5 hrs
Tiny Minecraft, by rsmalec: 18 (4+3+4+3+4) vid, World Building App, .5 hrs
Battleship, by magib1: 17 (4+4+3+3+3) vid, Board game adaptation, 45 min
Etho's Beastmaster Speed Challenge, by bRanN: 16 (4+2+3+3+4) vid, Mob Safari, .5 hrs
Super Tetragon, by Flaggerlaggerskate: 16 (4+4+2+3+3) vid, Block Dodge, 15 min
Beer Cascade, by MyBoner: 15 (4+3+3+3+2) vid, Minigame, .5 hrs
Bermuda Bay, by Pixelbits: 15 (4+4+2+2+3) vid, Water Park, .5 hrs
Spot the Difference, by Lukeys: 15 (4+3+2+3+3) vid, Brain Teaser, 1.5 hrs
Blood Magic, Altar of the Blood God, by Dragnoz: 14 (3+3+3+3+2) vid, Minigame, 15 min
CLUE, by rsmalec: 14 (2+3+3+2+4) vid, Board Game Adaptation, 1 hr
Criswelympics, by Criswell: 14 (4+3+2+2+3), Olympics, .5 hrs
Flying the MT Convoy, by Mining Turtles: 14 (4+2+3+3+2) vid, Spaceship Battle Sim, .5 hrs
Golfturat's Country Club, by Golfturat: 14 (3+3+3+3+2), Golf, 1.5 hrs
Apr 13 Moblympics, by Golgot100: 14 (3+2+3+3+3), Zombie follower, .5 hrs

Raft Craft, by Catastrophe51: 14 (2+2+3+4+3) vid, Boat Race, 15 min
Sesame Street, by Prof_Snape&iKonakona: 14 (4+3+2+3+2) vid, Scavenger Hunt, 1 hr
Archery, by disco: 13 (3+2+2+3+3), Archery, .5 hrs
Bingo, by Lorgon111: 13 (3+3+2+2+3) vid, Board Game, 1-2 hrs
Don't Wake Vee!, by VeeAndC: 13 (3+3+2+3+2), Board Game Adaptation, .5 hrs
Feb 15 Gregor's Ascension, by lurkngshadow: 13 (3+2+2+3+3), Minigolf, 45 min
Mega Golf - 72 Hole Course, by Prof_Snape&iKonakona: 13 (3+2+2+3+3) vid, Minigolf, 1 hr
Sevens Hills Golf Course, by VIIs: 13 (3+3+2+3+2) vid, Golf, .5 hrs
Sharp Shooter, by Zsamkj: 12 (3+1+1+4+3), Archery, 1 hr
I Am Alien, by ParadiseDecay: 11 (3+2+2+2+2) vid, Scavenger Hunt, .5 hrs
MineSweeper, by Altio: 11 (3+2+2+2+2), Game Adaptation, .5 hrs
Build My Thing, by tRmz: 10 (3+2+1+3+1), Build Contest, 15 min
Holiday Villa Boat Race, by technoanimate100: 10 (2+2+2+2+2), Boat Race, 15 min
Tower Defense, by OTTOPI: 10 (3+2+2+2+1), Tower Defense, .5 hrs
Minecraft Kong, by bobpie6: 8 (2+1+1+2+2) vid, Donkey Kong, .5 hrs

Multi-Genre Maps

PF! Adventure Multiplex 2: The Village, by Jigarbov/Community: 20 (4+4+4+4+4) vid, Collaboration, 18 hrs
The 12 Days of Minemas, by FoamyTrampoline/Community: 17 (4+3+3+4+3) vid, Christmas, 3.5 hrs
The Toybox, by rsmalec/Community: 17 (4+4+3+4+2) vid, Choose your own adventure, 2 - 8 hrs
Diversity, by Qmagnet: 16 (4+3+2+4+3) vid, Multi-genre, 10 hrs
Adventure Multiplex, by Jigarbov/Community: 15 (4+2+3+4+2) vid, Collaboration, 10 - 15 hrs

Parkour Maps

Jerry's Adventure, by overlordpawel: 20 (4+4+4+4+4) vid, Cartoon Adaptation, 3 hrs
PF! Toy Story 2, by PitchBlack: 20 (4+4+4+4+4) vid, Toy Story, 3.5 hrs
Around the Hills, by Symphonym: 19 (4+4+3+4+4) vid, City Exploration, 2 hrs
Epic Jump Map: Sky Butter Edition, by bodil40: 19 (4+3+4+4+4) vid, SkyDoesMinecraft, 1.5 hrs
Epic Jump Map: Mario Edition, by Bodil40: 18 (3+3+4+4+4), Super Mario Bros., 2 hrs
Assassin's Creep, by selib & DrChriz: 17 (3+4+4+3+3), Assassin's Creed, 1.5 hrs
Parkour Thief, by CheesefryC00k: 17 (3+3+4+3+4) vid, Thief, 2 hrs
Slabbing It, by nl4l1f3: 16 (4+2+3+4+3), Smart Moving, .5 hrs
Minecraft's Edge, by DrChriz: 15 (3+3+3+3+3), Parkour Adaptation, 1 hr
Parkour Runner, by Hippy500: 14 (3+3+2+3+3), Puzzler, .5 hrs
Epic Jump Map: Tropical Vacation, by Bodil40: 13 (2+3+2+3+3) vid, Tropical, 1.5 hrs
Eribney Parkour, by Mishukax: 13 (3+2+2+3+3), Creations, 6 - 8 hrs
Minecrafter's Creed: Revelations, by xLidlx123: 13 (3+3+2+3+2), Assassin's Creed Adaptation, 2 hrs
World of Parkour, by Taizzzzzed: 13 (3+2+2+3+3), Stories, 3.5 hrs
Adventure Escape, by Bodil40: 12 (3+2+2+3+2) vid, Hunted Chase, .5 hrs
Greed, by GeraldoCockerhan: 10 (2+2+2+2+2), Sprinter, .5 hrs
Punishment Parkour, by DocHavoc2: 9 (2+1+1+3+2), Afterlife, 2 hrs
Run Run Says Herobrine, by 3guysplayingmc: 9 (3+1+2+1+2), Chase, .5 hrs
Temple Runner, by El_Dabo: 9 (2+2+1+3+1), Temple, 3.5 hrs
Biome Parkour, by cheesepants9: 7 (1+1+2+2+1), Jumping, .5 hrs
An Archer's Trials, by ParkourArcher: 6 (1+1+1+2+1) vid, Parkour, 5 min

Puzzle Maps

PF! The Code II: Infinite, by jespertheend: 20 (4+4+4+4+4) vid, Logic/Navigation, 2 hrs
PF! The Puzzle Cube, by Tmtravlr: 20 (4+4+4+4+4) vid, 3D Puzzles, 3 hrs
Acatalepsy, by Phi_NES: 19 (4+4+3+4+4) vid, Black and White Logic/Parkour, 1 hr
It's Better Together, by FloddyFosh: 19 (4+3+4+4+4) vid, Co-Op Escape, 3 hrs
PF! The Code, by jespertheend: 19 (4+3+4+4+4) vid, Logic/Navigation, 7 hrs
The Code III, by Jespertheend: 19 (4+4+3+4+4) vid, Logic/Navigation, 4.5 hrs
Complex, by Qmagnet: 18 (3+3+4+4+4) vid, 3D Puzzle Maze, 2 hrs
Dimension Jumper, by Bigre: 18 (4+3+4+4+3) vid, Teleportation, 1.5 hrs
Karoshi, by yokcos700: 18 (4+3+3+4+4) vid, Suicide, .5 hrs
Craft Bandicoot - The Tomb of Rath, by Lukeys: 17 (4+3+2+4+4), Tomb Escape, 2 hrs
The Legend of Flint & Steel, by Lukeys: 17 (3+3+3+4+4) vid, Fantasy, 1 hr
Chamber of the Creators, by Jaever & Gelvin: 16 (4+3+3+4+2) vid, Modern, 2.5 hrs
Coordination, by y2bd: 16 (4+2+3+3+4) vid, Co-Op Escape, 2 hrs
Monster Mash, by Aaron & Kendra: 16 (3+3+3+4+3) vid, Mob Mechanics, 1.5 hrs
Chamber of the Creators 2: The Grim Future, by Jaever & Gelvin: 15 (3+3+3+3+3) vid, Modern, 2 hrs
Cooperation!, by y2bd: 15 (3+2+3+3+4) vid, Co-Op Escape, .5 hrs
Levels, by Kinglau3: 15 (3+3+3+3+3) vid, Fantasy, 1 hr
The Clock, by Robotinator: 15 (3+4+3+3+2) vid, SciFi, .5 hrs
Clueless, by anincompoop25: 14 (4+2+2+4+2), Puzzler, 1 hr
Date Your Mate, by KoldT: 14 (2+3+3+3+3) vid, Co-Op, 2 hrs
Escape Island, by yiker: 14 (3+2+3+3+3) vid, Escape, 1 hr
Escapecraft 3, by merlinus12: 14 (2+2+2+4+4), Escape, 2 hrs
Silverspring Island, by SausageVB: 14 (3+3+3+1+4), Fantasy, 4.5 hrs
The Dream, by Stijnnl: 14 (3+3+3+3+2) vid, Dream, .5 hrs
The Gold Hunter (WIP), by Xav: 14 (3+3+3+3+2), Fantasy, 2.5 hrs
The Lair, by ZyloFan: 14 (3+2+2+3+4), Co-Op Escape, 1 hr
The Waffle Chamber, by TheWaffleGalaxy: 14 (3+2+3+3+3), Escape, 1 hr
241, by jellewietsma&Jespertheend: 13 (3+2+2+3+3) vid, Co-Op, 4 hrs
Babel, by TheDanMan: 13 (3+2+3+3+2), Puzzler, 1.5 hrs
Feb 16 Gravity Switcher, by theTrixFixz: 13 (3+3+2+3+2), Teleportation, 45 min
ShrinkCraft, by Ditto64: 13 (2+2+3+3+3), Escape, 2 hrs
Feb 15 The Head Game, by aopell: 13 (3+2+2+3+3), Trivia, 15 min
Trials of Romenhal, by xBlackJack413x: 13 (3+2+2+3+3), Escape, 1 hr
Escape the T.R.O.L.L., by G00DG04T: 12 (3+2+3+2+2), Escape, 1 hr
Escapecraft, by merlinus12: 12 (2+2+2+3+3), Escape, 3 hrs
Lure into the Endless, by F2B: 12 (3+2+2+3+2), Escape, .5 hrs
The Labirynth, by fireb0rn: 12 (3+2+2+1+4), Escape, .5 hrs
Tombs of Tal Rasha, by Traxis: 12 (3+2+2+3+2), Tomb Escape, 1 hr
Feb 15 Bedrock Prison Escape, by koeniedoenie: 11 (3+2+2+2+2), Escape, .5 hrs
Captured, by xtreme654: 11 (2+2+2+3+2) vid, Escape, 1.5 hrs
Dimension of DooM, by Lurler: 11 (2+2+2+3+2), Escape, .5 hrs
Just Go Home, by JOSSPOOL: 11 (3+2+2+3+1) vid, Modern, 2 hrs
The Basement, by littlesm: 11 (2+2+2+3+2), Escape, 1 hr
The Bridge, by Kranitoko: 11 (2+2+2+3+2), Escape, 1 hr
The Enderpearl Puzzles, by adpad309: 11 (3+2+2+1+3), Escape, 1 hr
Four Towers, by Wreckage: 10 (2+2+2+1+3), Escape, 1.5 hrs
From Dirt to Bedrock, by chez911: 10 (2+2+1+3+2), Tiered, 1.5 hrs
Marvellous, by MinecraftMasterz: 10 (2+2+2+2+2) vid, Playland, 1 hr
Woolington!, by TheMapReview: 10 (3+2+1+3+1) vid, Escape, 1.5 hrs
Elements, by TechFestServer: 9 (2+2+2+1+2), Fantasy, 1 hr
Halls of the Dead, by Traxis: 9 (2+1+1+3+2), Tomb Escape, 1 hr
Room after Room, by Plaatinum10: 8 (2+2+1+1+2), Escape, 1 hr
Saw: Death Factory, by Hrd2GtProds: 8 (2+1+1+2+2), Escape, .5 hrs
Diamond and Gold, by dean10973: 7 (2+1+1+2+1), Co-Op Escape, .5 hrs

PvP Maps

PF! Alpha vs. Beta, by Faume: 19 (4+3+4+4+4) vid, Arathi Basin PvP, 3 hrs
GSW, by Temporarily9, pvt_meatshield, wiskeyweasel: 19 (4+4+4+4+3) vid, Spaceship Battle Sim, 1 hr
The Survival Games 2, by Vareide: 19 (3+4+4+4+4) vid, Hunger Games, 1 hr
Twisted Desert, by FellLock: 19 (4+3+4+4+4) vid, RFW, .5 hrs
Cluster Chunk, by three_two: 18 (4+2+4+4+4) vid, Floating Islands, .5 hrs
NAIL, by Rixiot: 17 (3+3+4+4+3) vid, Castle Defense, .5 hrs
Ghostbusters, by Podcrash: 16 (3+4+3+3+3), RP/Chase, 15 min
The Walls 2, by Hypixel: 16 (3+3+3+4+3) vid, Team Survival, .5 hrs
Cops and Robbers 3: Escape from Alcatraz, by Podcrash: 15 (2+4+3+3+3), RP/Escape, .5 hrs
Divided Together (RFW #3), by Thungon: 15 (4+2+3+3+3) vid, Race for Wool, .5 hrs
Mar 1 Petals, by DeciTM: 15 (3+2+3+4+3) vid, Control point, 5 min
Super Pirate Battle Royale, by disco_: 15 (3+3+3+3+3) vid, Cannon Battle, .5 hrs
The Survival Games, by Vareide: 15 (3+2+3+4+3) vid, Hunger Games, 3 hrs
The Walls, by Hypixel: 14 (3+2+3+3+3) vid, Team Surviavl, .5 hrs
Cops and Robbers!, by Podcrash: 13 (3+3+2+2+3) vid, RP/Escape, .5 hrs
Fields of Glory, by Vechs: 12 (2+2+2+3+3) vid, Capture the Wool, .5 hrs
Hall of Statues, by rsmalec: 12 (2+2+2+3+3) vid, Team CTM, 1 hr
Tablet, by ColdFusionGaming: 12 (3+2+2+3+2), CTM, 1 hr
Teacher, by NoahCraftFTW: 8 (2+1+2+2+1) vid, RP/Escape, .5 hrs
Arena SMP, by gmemstr: 7 (1+1+2+2+1), PvP, 15 min
Run from the Beast, by NoahCraftFTW: 7 (1+2+1+2+1), Chase, 15 min
The Elements, by Lewis Milton: 7 (1+1+1+2+2), Rooms, 1 hr

Survival Maps

SkyGrid, by SethBling: 20 (4+4+4+4+4) vid, Floating Islands, .5 hrs
Stratosphere Survival, by haders: 18 (3+4+3+4+4) vid, Fantasy, 3 hrs
Tranquil Nightmare, by inHaze: 18 (4+4+4+3+3) vid, Winter, .5 hrs
Archaeologist's Island, by Divinux: 17 (3+3+4+4+3) vid, Archaeology, 2 hrs
Skylands, by BarthVader: 17 (4+4+3+3+3) vid, Sky Islands, 8 hrs
Feb 5 Deadly Orbit, by Ermin Caft: 16 (3+4+3+3+3) vid, Space Station, 4 hrs
Skyblock, by Noobcrew: 16 (4+2+3+4+3) vid, Minimalist, 2 hrs
The Jumper, by GreenGorilla8: 16 (4+2+3+3+4), Floating Islands, 1.5 hrs
Captain Razack's Treasure, by generalscare: 15 (4+2+3+3+3), Pirates, 1 hr
Apr 7 Frost Breath, by Ermin Caft: 15 (3+3+3+3+3) vid, Arctic, 2 hrs
Obbie Town, by Grazer46: 15 (2+3+3+3+4), SciFi, 4 hrs
Letters from a Dead Earth, by d341jerman: 14 (2+4+3+2+3), Post Apocalypse, 2 hrs
The Block Museum, by Grazer46: 13 (3+2+3+2+3), Scifi, 1.5 hrs
Feb 23 Training Center, by Ermin Caft: 13 (3+3+3+2+2) vid, Hunger Games, .5 hrs
Concorde Down, by erinkara: 12 (3+2+3+2+2), Plane Crash, .5 hrs
Jan 25 Giant Minecraft Survival, by Tmtravlr: 12 (3+2+2+3+2), Oversized Blocks, tbd
Snow Survival Mountain, by TLB_Dutch: 12 (3+2+3+2+2), Snow Mountain Survival, .5 hrs
Space Survival, by Faithfulcupid: 12 (3+3+2+2+2), Scifi, .5 hrs
Survival in the Sky, by MrSlimer: 12 (2+2+2+3+3), Floating Islands, 3 hrs
Terraforming Mars, by SweetRevenge: 12 (3+2+3+2+2), SciFi, 1 hr
Trade Wars, by ColdFusionGaming: 12 (3+2+2+3+2), Trading, 1.5 hrs
Ant Farm of Doom, by jojinator97: 11 (3+2+2+2+2), Ant Farm, .5 hrs
Lost in the Space, by Cristomen007: 11 (3+2+2+2+2) vid, Moon survival, .5 hrs
Survival Island, by Ashien: 11 (3+2+2+2+2), Minimalist, 2 hrs
Time Bomb, by rsmalec: 11 (2+2+2+3+2) vid, Time-based, 1 hr
Escape Jungle Island, by Kotschi Games: 10 (2+2+2+2+2), Jungle Islands, 2 hrs
Moon, by Im a Block: 10 (2+3+2+2+1) vid, Moon survival, 1 hr
My Head Hurts... Why?, by polas100: 10 (3+2+2+2+1), Vertical, 2 hrs
Peaceful Lands, by ColdFusionGaming: 10 (2+2+2+2+2), Fantasy, 1 hr
Eruption Survival, by Mollett: 9 (2+2+2+2+1), Volcanic Island Survival, .5 hrs
Jay's Challenge Map, by Starwind626: 9 (2+1+1+3+2) vid, Challenges, .5 hrs
Lifeless Island, by nexust: 9 (2+2+2+1+2), Barren, .5 hrs
Living in a Dome, by apples123: 9 (2+2+2+2+1), Glass Dome, .5 hrs
Sky Conqueror, by ocomobock: 9 (2+2+1+2+2), Sky Islands, 1 hr
Stonecraft, by DarkFlashz: 9 (2+2+2+2+1), Stone Islands, 2 hrs
Don't Starve in Minecraft, by LordBlackSoul: 8 (3+1+1+2+1), Adaptation, .5 hrs
TreeTop Survival, by MelonCrafters: 7 (2+1+1+2+1), Floating Tree, 1 hr
Survive, by thejon4321: 5 (1+1+1+1+1) vid, Mob Battle, 1 hr

See my second post Adventure type maps!
See my fourth post for explanation of the rating scale!

Posted Image


#4

rsmalec
    rsmalec

    Blaze Extinguisher

  • Curse Premium
  • Curse Premium
  • 4541 posts

Posted 28 May 2011 - 02:40 PM

Posted Image Posted Image Posted Image Posted Image MAP RATING SCALE Posted Image Posted Image Posted Image Posted Image

ALL RATINGS ARE SUBJECTIVE!

The following rating scale applies to all map types, EXCEPT for Multi-Genre maps (see below).

Mechanics: Applies to all map types.  Unique theme.  Utilizes Minecraft functions.  Use of rules.  Clever creations. Environment Complexity.
1 = below average
2 = average
3 = above average
4 = astounding!

Detail: Applies to all map types. Visual décor and detail.  Consistency between large scale/environment build and player-level/point-of-view detail. Realism and/or appropriate to theme.
1 = below average
2 = average
3 = above average
4 = astounding!

Experience: (Adventure) Overall story effort and duration. Engaging. Consistent. Character motivation.  Dialogue/Narration.
1 = below average
2 = average
3 = above average
4 = astounding!

Experience: (Survival, Puzzle Maps) Overall experience that I have while playing compared against what I believe is the theme/intent of the map. Rationale for character being in this situation. Motivation, Dialogue, or Narration, if exists.
1 = below average
2 = average
3 = above average
4 = Outstanding!

Experience: (PvP) Overall experience that I have while playing compared against what I believe is the theme/intent of the map (Timed Attack/Defend, Score-based, Location Control, etc...).  Clarity of Rules.
1 = below average
2 = average
3 = above average
4 = Outstanding!

Challenge: Applies to all map types.  Puzzles.  Risk density and variety (Player vs. Environment, Player vs. Mobs, Traps).  Lighting.  Secondary goal (e.g. Hidden items/challenges).  Resource management.
1 = Impossibly hard, may not be able to see the end of the map without cheating.  Poorly designed (masses of spawners) / unbalanced.
2 = Too easy
3 = At least one element is Challenging (e.g. puzzles or mobs are well planned)
4 = Multiple elements are Challenging (e.g. puzzles -AND- mobs are well planned).  Or intentionally hard and well designed/balanced

Progression: Applies to all map types.  Pacing of scenes. Pacing of score, gear, loot. Experience builds or arcs.  Clear delineation between "in character" and "out of character" notes/signs (Adventure). Replayability (PvP). Scalability (solo, small team, large team).  Map supports balance (PvP).  Includes both Prep and Combat phases (PvP).
1 = below average; uneven or no progression
2 = average
3 = above average
4 = astounding!

Posted Image Posted Image Posted Image Posted Image Multi-Genre Map Rating Scale (TENATIVE) Posted Image Posted Image Posted Image Posted Image

The following rating scale applies to Multi-Genre maps only.  These maps are comprised of 10+ mini-maps with an overarching meta-map.  These do not necessarily have to be community/collaboration maps (e.g. Diversity) and this category does not include community/collaboration maps where the theme is consistent throughout (e.g. The Library, Pantheon).  This category is only for maps where the mini-maps have different genres.  It's impossible to rate them as a whole.  I had the option of rating every mini-map and then doing an average, or taking the max() or  min() rating for each category.  But honestly, that never really felt right using the current 'adventure' rating scale.

Mechanics: Variety of mechanics or special effects in the mini-maps AND the meta-map.
1 = below average
2 = average
3 = above average
4 = astounding!

Detail: Relative average visual detail in the mini-maps, but more heavily weighted by visuals in the meta-map.
1 = below average
2 = average
3 = above average
4 = astounding!

Experience: Relative average experience in the mini-maps, but more heavily weighted by overarching experience in the meta-map.
1 = below average
2 = average
3 = above average
4 = astounding!

Challenge: Variety of challenge in the mini-maps.  Meta-map not weighted.
1 = Impossibly hard, may not be able to see the end of the map without cheating.  Poorly designed (masses of spawners) / unbalanced.
2 = Too easy
3 = At least one element is Challenging (e.g. puzzles or mobs are well planned)
4 = Multiple elements are Challenging (e.g. puzzles -AND- mobs are well planned).  Or intentionally hard and well designed/balanced

Progression: Overall sequence of accessing the mini-maps from the meta-map.
1 = below average; uneven or no progression
2 = average
3 = above average
4 = astounding!

Posted Image Posted Image Posted Image Posted Image RATING CONSIDERATIONS Posted Image Posted Image Posted Image Posted Image


I don't always film a Let's Play of every map I play.  It takes 2 to 4 times longer to edit, render, and upload a video, than simply playing your map and taking notes.

If I do not film a video, I provide play-by-play notes on what I'm noticing in your map, my reactions, etc... I believe many map makers find this as valuable or more than a raw rating score.

It's important for map-makers to understand my rating scale and the weights before asking to have your map reviewed!

My rating scale is centered around an 'average' rating (2).  The more maps that I play, the higher the bar is raised on 'above average' (3) and 'astounding' (4).  Therefore, I consider a 10 to be a GOOD score.  That means you're hitting all of the basics, the average player will likely make it to the end, and if they like the 'theme' of the map, will probably enjoy it.

You will lose points for:
  • Excessive use of foul language that is not 'in character'
  • Derogatory insults aimed at members of the community
  • Sudden, inescapable death for no reason
  • An unfinished map that ends abruptly, if you did not state up front that it was Work-In-Progress

There are many elements that I don't like, or see too often in custom maps.  I don't subtract points for them, and I try to see the THOUGHT that you put into including them.  But if your map is full of cliche elements, it will most likely have a death-by-a-thousand-cuts impact on the 'experience' rating.
  • Jumping puzzles that are not part of the landscape
  • Any puzzle in a rectangular room with no visual details
  • Ability for a player to see 'behind the scenes' flat world, exposed redstone, undecorated exteriors, etc...
  • LONG walks or minecart rides with no attempt to keep my attention
  • "Wall of text" notes (I tend to lose attention after paragraph 3)
  • Completely dark rooms full of mob spawners for the sake of mob spawners
  • Maps that begin; you wake up in a strange place with no memory of who you are or how you got here
  • Excessive references or fanboyism that overshadow your actual story

I typically don't take off points for small bugs, if I trust that the map maker is attentive and will attempt to fix them in reasonable amount of time.  Particularly if the bug is caused by a Minecraft release.

When I play a map for a review, my goal is to experience every moment of your map including the end.  If I die too many times or get significantly lost or frustrated, I will most likely rate it a "1 - too hard" but continue on through the map using mods to figure out where things went wrong, or how the rest of the map plays out.  

Some maps are intentionally hard - and in this case I try to scrutinize the design principles that were used to make it hard - is it well balanced and requires brainpower, or is it just an endless stream of mob spawners?  If it looks like you put thought into the design, you are likely to receive a 3 or 4.  If you just filled a room with mob spawners, you will most likely receive a 1.

If you feel that I missed a critical element in your map review, please let me know.  I often go back and re-evaluate scores when asked, with a logical reason.  Sometimes I make mistakes.  However, I will never lower your map score once posted.

I almost never go back and re-play maps.  There's just not enough time and soooo many more maps out there that I want to see.  Therefore, don't send me a Work-In-Progress map unless you're sure it's close to completion.  If you make significant alterations to your map after the fact, I will reconsider my rating based on how you describe the change, and possibly replaying that section.
The main exception to this bit of guidance is if you formally arrange for me to test your map in advance of release.  In this case, we'll discuss how/if I rate the map separately.

I don't always play maps in the order of my published queue.  This is at my discretion.

I don't always list all of the maps I intend to play in my queue. Reasons I might play maps out of order; I may pencil in an upcoming map, but choose not to list it in my queue; I may be holding a map to play multiplayer, subject to scheduling; I sometimes try to squeeze in shorter maps if I have limited play time.

The number of downloads, views, or replies is NOT a reflection of the map's quality.

:Green: :Blue: :Green: :Blue: :Green: :Blue: MY PUBLISHED MAPS :Green: :Blue: :Green: :Blue: :Green: :Blue:

(Click each thumbnail for map details and download)
Posted Image
Posted Image
Posted Image Posted Image Posted Image
Posted Image Posted Image Posted Image Posted Image Posted Image Posted Image Posted Image Posted Image Posted Image
Posted Image Posted Image



:Green: :Blue: :Green: :Blue: :Green: :Blue: Maps I've Contributed To :Green: :Blue: :Green: :Blue: :Green: :Blue:

(Click each thumbnail for map details and download)


Posted Image


Posted Image


Posted Image

Posted Image

Posted Image

Posted Image

Posted Image

Posted Image

:Green: :Blue: :Green: :Blue: :Green: :Blue: :Green: :Blue: :Green: :Blue: :Green: :Blue:


Posted Image


#5

Fellonius the Wizard

Posted 07 June 2011 - 02:35 PM

As usual you're having the most significant thoughts ever. If I read some of your opinions above, I would hesitated even more than I did.

There are some tips to add:
*Trust your Minecraft instincts. Even if you've done something everybody else has, as long as you and your friends thinks it as good as (or even better as) some of the Custom maps on the forum, put it up and learn by the feedback.
* Do not sell yourself short: "It's my first map so go easy on me". Please!? This isn't Facebook. If you can't stand behind your map, don't release it at all.
* No, not every map can be played by Yogscast. I understand the wish, but some things may never happen. Learn to deal with that, and head on to your next map.
* I'm a "no mod at all"-builder myself. I have another thought in every build I do; It must withstand the next update Mojang does. It will make your map easier to update, but it will also give you more good ideas.

That's my 2p.
Fellonius, working on his last one...

#6

Scix
    Scix

    Gold Miner

  • Members
  • 475 posts

Posted 16 June 2011 - 04:38 PM

View Postrsmalec, on 26 April 2011 - 02:52 PM, said:

"You wake up in a strange place with no memory of how you got there..."  c'mon... give your character a back story.  Even if they are entering a mysterious place, it helps the player feel connected to the game.  

Well, crap.

Actually, there's more to it than that, but that's kinda my starting point. Everything else on your hit list I dodged, though.

Useful advice. Since I loved your Wonderland so much (and am downloading Dust and Clue and World as we speak), I think you're likely a good source for mapmaking wisdom.

I am hoping "the adventure update" includes the writable books that Notch hinted at -- I have lots of backstory that's just in my head. Version 2.0 could have a lot of it in-game.

I am really not a fan of "Now read note #79," though it's often the only way, unless you want to make 132 signs.

I look forward to seeing how your narration mod works out.

View PostFellonius the Wizard, on 07 June 2011 - 02:35 PM, said:

* I'm a "no mod at all"-builder myself. I have another thought in every build I do; It must withstand the next update Mojang does. It will make your map easier to update, but it will also give you more good ideas.

I feel the same way. I had to leave out a section because I couldn't think of how to do it, but what I did instead is better. That's kinda how creativity works. "Necessity is the mother..." and yaddah yaddah.
~~Scix
Posted Image

#7

thedutchman44
  • Minecraft: thedutchman44

Posted 18 June 2011 - 08:56 AM

I got to say man I absolutely love your maps!
Your my favorite mapper and Please dont stop making them.
You deserve  :Diamond: x 5000

#8

rsmalec
    rsmalec

    Blaze Extinguisher

  • Curse Premium
  • Curse Premium
  • 4541 posts

Posted 20 June 2011 - 12:08 PM

Revised post layout.

Adding a centralized place for map ratings.

Posted Image


#9

Fellonius the Wizard

Posted 28 June 2011 - 05:58 AM

rsmalec said:

Revised post layout.

Adding a centralized place for map ratings.
As such, it needs bumping. :-)

Alright, I see your rating system and I understand it. My next version of Aneara should get +1 or +2 for the story, and with that, I'm pleased.
Fellonius, the reviewing of the reviewer...

#10

rsmalec
    rsmalec

    Blaze Extinguisher

  • Curse Premium
  • Curse Premium
  • 4541 posts

Posted 28 June 2011 - 02:12 PM

Simplified the map rating list  - trying to make it fixed-width got all garbledy.

Posted Image


#11

rsmalec
    rsmalec

    Blaze Extinguisher

  • Curse Premium
  • Curse Premium
  • 4541 posts

Posted 30 June 2011 - 03:37 AM

Newly added: Prof. Grizwald and the Redstone Keys, by ChronoBasher: 20 (4+4+4+4+4) http://www.minecraft...t/topic/401386-

The first map I'm giving a 20/20 to.  It's well written, brilliant puzzles, looks beautiful, consistent, well paced, I can't say enough.

Posted Image


#12

ChronoBasher

Posted 30 June 2011 - 04:04 AM

View Postrsmalec, on 30 June 2011 - 03:37 AM, said:

Newly added: Prof. Grizwald and the Redstone Keys, by ChronoBasher: 20 (4+4+4+4+4) http://www.minecraft...t/topic/401386-

The first map I'm giving a 20/20 to.  It's well written, brilliant puzzles, looks beautiful, consistent, well paced, I can't say enough.


Thanks so much for the generous rating.  Seriously, it means a lot coming from another map creator, and someone who has played so many adventure maps as well.  Thanks :)
Posted Image

#13

rsmalec
    rsmalec

    Blaze Extinguisher

  • Curse Premium
  • Curse Premium
  • 4541 posts

Posted 01 July 2011 - 11:50 AM

Early morning play through of a great little map: Guardian of the Emerald Forest
http://www.minecraft...t/topic/382200-

16/20

Posted Image


#14

rsmalec
    rsmalec

    Blaze Extinguisher

  • Curse Premium
  • Curse Premium
  • 4541 posts

Posted 03 July 2011 - 12:51 PM

Uploaded a 'unique' playthrough video of my new favorite map; Prof. Grizwald and the Redstone Keys.

As played on SMP by two 8 year olds and myself as silent chaperone.


Posted Image


#15

rsmalec
    rsmalec

    Blaze Extinguisher

  • Curse Premium
  • Curse Premium
  • 4541 posts

Posted 03 July 2011 - 07:35 PM

Added rating for MAYHEM MANSION (10/20)

A decent set of non-linear puzzles.  A little too difficult in some spots and not much in the way of decoration (except for one room with very nice bunk beds.  Rathere enjoyed that some chests were hidden behind wooden walls and wooden stairs which allowed you to reach into a small hole.

Map: Mayhem Mansion
Version: v2
By: Moldy Eskimo
URL: http://www.minecraft...t/topic/380209-

Posted Image


#16

rsmalec
    rsmalec

    Blaze Extinguisher

  • Curse Premium
  • Curse Premium
  • 4541 posts

Posted 04 July 2011 - 08:29 AM

Added MY new map - [Surv] Time Bomb
12 / 20

How long can you survive and keep feeding the furnace?  If the furnace goes out, the house explodes and you lose!  A NEW twist to basic survival.

http://www.minecraft...t/topic/424554-

Posted Image


#17

Scix
    Scix

    Gold Miner

  • Members
  • 475 posts

Posted 04 July 2011 - 12:43 PM

hm.... sounds like it uses the furnace as a change-state thingie... (I know that's incoherent, I've been up all night)
~~Scix
Posted Image

#18

rsmalec
    rsmalec

    Blaze Extinguisher

  • Curse Premium
  • Curse Premium
  • 4541 posts

Posted 04 July 2011 - 07:56 PM

View PostScix, on 04 July 2011 - 12:43 PM, said:

hm.... sounds like it uses the furnace as a change-state thingie... (I know that's incoherent, I've been up all night)

You got it.

Video uploading now...

Posted Image


#19

rsmalec
    rsmalec

    Blaze Extinguisher

  • Curse Premium
  • Curse Premium
  • 4541 posts

Posted 07 July 2011 - 02:29 PM

reserved

Posted Image


#20

rsmalec
    rsmalec

    Blaze Extinguisher

  • Curse Premium
  • Curse Premium
  • 4541 posts

Posted 08 July 2011 - 05:05 AM

Players and map makers, please consider taking 3 SHORT surveys on Custom Adventure maps.  These will help me (and other map makers) provide you with more enjoyable experiences.

More details can be found here http://www.minecraft...t/topic/444748-

THANK YOU

Posted Image