Minecraft Forums

Quote from crazeenuthead

Seems a bit unnecessary for a single item. . . but hey, whatever works right.
I would like to see maybe a different GUI, maybe to be compatible with making different items, but if that doesn't work, then I can live with what we've got.
I support.

I thought about that, but the problem is the only other applicable item is TNT, and including another slot for TNT seems a bit complex.

Quote from jpmrocks

I support, and Dinnerbone should be sen this.

I praise you, oh Void Walker, oh god of the Minecraftian World...
EDIT NOV 12 2013: Never mind. I'm now a glowstone miner.

Anyway, thank you!

Quote from WarPigsLukesWall

Um, dude? It's not confusing to make fireworks. At all. Seriously.

This interface is still nice though, I support it. Is this something you wanna push to have implimented in game? If so count me in.

I know, once you get used to it it isn't complex.

Quote from Nathan2055

I love it! It might be a good idea to keep the Firework Star though and have this alongside it. You can add my name to the support list.

Yep, this is just optional. If you want you can stick with 2x2 crafting.

Quote from Kekilrocks123

I like the idea, but with the current model you can theoretically put every single dye in one firework rocket. This limits it to 3 (6 if you count fading, which I don't.

That's why you can still make fireworks with 2x2 crafting. This is strictly optional, and though less flexible it would be easier.

Quote from BlankTitle

Very Nice! 100% support!

Thank you!

But it still takes time—so firework shows are hard because it takes too much time to just make the fireworks.

Quote from Brinjal66

What are the glitches?
I support as long as it doesn't replace the current system. If it does then I hate this.

No, of course it doesn't. It is an alternative, that might be better for some players and others can still use 2x2 crafting method.

Quote from NitrogenSnow

Support

Thank you.

Quote from Steven42lol

I like the freedom you get with the star, but this is just easier. Support.

Added, and it is optional.

Quote from Brinjal66

Wait, 2x2? You mean we couldn't use the full 3x3 crafting table?

That would make no sense. I'm just saying that you can use 3x3 or 2x2 just like normal.

Quote from Brinjal66

Oh, the fact that you said 2x2 was confusing and made it sound like 3x3 wouldn't work (after all, why else would you specify 2x2?) if this is just an option for people who find standard crafting too hard, I guess I support, even if I would not use it.

Ahh, OK. Yeah, it's intended as an alternative, not a replacement.

Quote from peterdetmig

Good idea, but i do not support because it;s pure laziness.

Pure laziness? How so?
You see, I'd want to spend more time on firework shows only it is so time consuming to make the fireworks that the show isn't that great because I'm spending all my time focusing on the firework making. How is that laziness?

Quote from peterdetmig

To lazy to learn. To adapt. We can already make fireworks with all these things.
Well, the idea is good, so don't misunderstand me. Just sounds a bit lazy.

My point is that while we can do it we can spend more time on the coordinated display, rather than on the individual firework. It's about making sure a full show looks good as a whole which takes a lot of time right now. I'd rather spend maximum time working on the total interface rather than each individual firework. Try making a full firework show and you will see how hard it is currently.

Quote from IAreNinja

its unnecessary
the current method works just fine and fire works serve no actual purpose other than an aesthetic
there are more important things that should be focused on in the next update.( here are a few things just so you won't ask whats more important "bug fixing,redstone, the lighting system dinnerbone was working on, all the other feature they have promised but haven't actually started on".)
and on a semi-related note change your title.
14.29% don't like it & 7.14% don't care. Thats not 100% support

Well one of the no no no's was a trolling post, and the person told me to count those as yes.

Nearbeer summed it up, it's really hard to work on a firework display when half of the time you are just trying to make them.

Quote from IAreNinja

Admittedly it is a little time consuming but no more so than any other major build in minecraft.

Yes, but a simple thing like a firework show should be easy to set up. That way I can make a major build with a firework display with much less work.

Quote from Artifact123

I know how to craft fireworks, but it might be useful for players who don't. How is the stand crafted though?

Do'h. I cannot believe I forgot that. Adding it now.

Also, it's meant to make it easier to make lots of different fireworks, not to make it easier for players who have no clue. Though I suppose it would help them.