Dear Gravity69,
your map has been skipped because I clearly said I will not play any alphas or snapshots.
Might want to put some work into your post.
Kind Regards,
Cerberus14321
I now have a partner who reviews maps with me to increase the reviewing speed and process
Original Head of The Reviewer Team: Cerberus14321
Partner: DeviousFrost.
-Slime Jump map has been skipped due to the fact that its an alpha-version (snapshot demo map) -Ore WarZ map has been skipped due to the fact that its an alpha-version (snapshot demo map)
It may just be my internet, but the spoilers don't work. Did you just type:
Only mods can read this text since you need to enter editing mode to keep extraneous code from being entered
or did you go into editing mode (the little light switch in the top left) and then type it?
Anybody can read this.
Also - I can't wait to see your "review" of my post - tell me what you think of the screenshots!
I have no idea why you don't seem to open the spoilers. I know that if I click the 'show' button it will open.
I prefer not entering the 'Full Edit' mode because It will mash EVERYTHING into 1 big pile of text and it requires me 5 minutes to rearrange everything from the beginning. If the problem won't be resolved i'll find a new solution to show my reviews.
Dear Makuta Nazo,
As of your request, your map has been reviewed. Your map, generally speaking, your 'planets' are a creative idea and are attractive to play. Although there is no point of story in this map, the creativity and work you spent to get this map working is outstanding, combining The Nether with the real world and various colorful islands, aswell as the villagers and mobs really make the game more 'interesting'.
Your challenges are abit off though:
Making an infinite water pool is too easy make a 2x2x1 hole and drop water on each edge with 1 bucket is too easy of a challenge.
Challenges 3, 7-13 can all be put up as one challenge. [For example: Challenge #3: Make a farm of the following items: Wheat, Reed, etc..]
Challenges 15-17 are not written correctly. [Fixing Solution: Make a statue of every wool color block, etc...]
A few more suggestions:
Make your post more... organized. A full text block which includes: Explanations, challenges, old history is not appealing the viewer's eye. Make it more organize, divide texts of block by context. Separate every challenge by a new line.
Keep updating constantly and give updates to your post, that should grab people's attention.
SCORES: Creativity: 7/10. Fun: 7/10. Story: 0/5. (no story) Level of Understanding: 2/5.
Yes, it is true! Map Reviews are back again! I've been taking a vacation for a long time but now I'm back!So basic stuff: My name is Andrew, I am here to review your custom maps / adventure maps. I've done around 200+ Map reviews, private and requested. I tend to check all the details of the map and everything that is done in it. I will give you a full review on your map post as well as a copy of it in my post for other members to see it. I give full criticism so don't expect me to be nice to you and lie if your map is bad!
I now have a partner who reviews maps with me to increase the reviewing speed and process
Original Head of The Reviewer Team: Cerberus14321
Partner: DeviousFrost.
Simple, isn't it? Now a few rules: I do not play any alpha(s) or pre-released version(s)! I only play at the current version that is available. I do not use any mods, if a map needs a mod to be able to run, send me the link, i'll install the mod, and remove it after i'm done with your map! Patience is important! I can not always review it in the first hours you post the request. But I promise, your map will be reviewed in less than a week. Thats all!
Score System:
Creativity- How creative your map was, the story, the buildings, the forum post, anything related to the map itself. 10 Points Fun- How much I enjoyed playing the map. Was it too long or boring or interesting. 10 Points Story- Content of the story. 5 Points Level Of Understanding- Was the map easily understood or was it too confusing. 5 Points Currently Playing:An Epix Adventure by Firzen1. Next Map: Pickup by yokcos700
Favorite Maps!
Reviewed:Skyblock Madness:
Skyblock Madness is a map created by UltimateBuildsThe map is an island survival game which requires you to survive with limited resources which you may gain by exploring the floating islands around.The idea of the map is nice but not so original and in-fact, i've seen alot of maps like this one so its the same tactic for all those maps.Some monster traps fail really hard (pigmen in lava, Golden Shrine doesnt spawn at all)My job was to check your map, not complete all the challenges on your forum but the challenges are nice.
Creativity: 7/10 [The map isnt so original but the challenges are ok and the islands are fine] Fun: 2/10 [I wouldn't count waiting long days to gather wood and sand to reach 1 island and then wait again to reach another and complete all those challenges with limited resources AND with the risk of falling off and losing everything as fun.] Story:0/5 [No Story at all] Level Of Understanding: 5/5 [Everything was nice and clear] TOTAL: 14/ 30
Survival Galaxy:
Dear Makuta Nazo,As of your request, your map has been reviewed. Your map, generally speaking, your 'planets' are a creative idea and are attractive to play. Although there is no point of story in this map, the creativity and work you spent to get this map working is outstanding, combining The Nether with the real world and various colorful islands, aswell as the villagers and mobs really make the game more 'interesting'.Your challenges are abit off though:
Making an infinite water pool is too easy make a 2x2x1 hole and drop water on each edge with 1 bucket is too easy of a challenge.
Challenges 3, 7-13 can all be put up as one challenge. [For example: Challenge #3: Make a farm of the following items: Wheat, Reed, etc..]
Challenges 15-17 are not written correctly. [Fixing Solution: Make a statue of every wool color block, etc...]
A few more suggestions:
Make your post more... organized. A full text block which includes: Explanations, challenges, old history is not appealing the viewer's eye. Make it more organize, divide texts of block by context. Separate every challenge by a new line.
Keep updating constantly and give updates to your post, that should grab people's attention.
SCORES: Creativity: 7/10. Fun: 7/10. Story: 0/5. (no story) Level of Understanding: 2/5. Total Score: 16/30. Best of wishes and good luck,
~The Reviewer~
Pickup:
Dear yokcos,
I have played your map and the idea is ok. Although the diamonds keep glitching up and down and there is no clear instructions so it might take some time to even figure out what to do..Atleast put a few signs to guide people through the levels. Just walking around clueless isn't so fun afterall...
Name of Map: 3 big chunks out of survival Type of Map: Survival Approximate time of finishing the map: N/A (It's a survival map) Link: http://www.minecraft...ut-of-survival/
Dear Gumby, We are glad to report you that we have downloaded and checked your map out, here is our reviewer's review!
'After you sent me the request and what you said in the pm. That the people said it was too hard and fun, I wanted to play it. The map is creative. I liked the story. The only noticed thing is the items at the beginning. No mistakes were found. The map is very fun, not very hard for me since I almost did everything. But that wall was awesome and creative! I liked your map very much and you did a great job with a creative map. The traps are awesome. I liked the creeper from the ceiling one.... the first one I think. Nice ideas and great work!' ~The Reviewer~
Score Explanation:
The idea of the map and the creativity of the traps are awesome. 10 out of 10.
The story is great. Nice idea, not too weird.
Your post is missing alot of stuff. Like other people's reviews. Ideas, rules, update history and alot of other needed stuff.
The activity is very good in this map. From traps along the side and the fighting along the way. Great job.
The fun rate is awesome. 10 out of 10. Score: Creativity: 10/10. [**] Story: 10/10. [**] Post: 6/10. [**] Activity: 10/10. [**] Fun Rate: 10/10. [**]
0
Fixed
0
I know I seem harsh with scores but dont forget that if you are missing 1 point in your map like a clear story, its already 5~10 points off.
0
your map has been skipped because I clearly said I will not play any alphas or snapshots.
Might want to put some work into your post.
Kind Regards,
Cerberus14321
0
Original Head of The Reviewer Team: Cerberus14321
Partner: DeviousFrost.
-Slime Jump map has been skipped due to the fact that its an alpha-version (snapshot demo map)
-Ore WarZ map has been skipped due to the fact that its an alpha-version (snapshot demo map)
0
I have no idea why you don't seem to open the spoilers. I know that if I click the 'show' button it will open.
I prefer not entering the 'Full Edit' mode because It will mash EVERYTHING into 1 big pile of text and it requires me 5 minutes to rearrange everything from the beginning. If the problem won't be resolved i'll find a new solution to show my reviews.
With Respect,
~The Reviewer~
0
As of your request, your map has been reviewed. Your map, generally speaking, your 'planets' are a creative idea and are attractive to play. Although there is no point of story in this map, the creativity and work you spent to get this map working is outstanding, combining The Nether with the real world and various colorful islands, aswell as the villagers and mobs really make the game more 'interesting'.
Your challenges are abit off though:
- Making an infinite water pool is too easy make a 2x2x1 hole and drop water on each edge with 1 bucket is too easy of a challenge.
- Challenges 3, 7-13 can all be put up as one challenge. [For example: Challenge #3: Make a farm of the following items: Wheat, Reed, etc..]
- Challenges 15-17 are not written correctly. [Fixing Solution: Make a statue of every wool color block, etc...]
A few more suggestions:- Make your post more... organized. A full text block which includes: Explanations, challenges, old history is not appealing the viewer's eye. Make it more organize, divide texts of block by context. Separate every challenge by a new line.
- Keep updating constantly and give updates to your post, that should grab people's attention.
SCORES:Creativity: 7/10.
Fun: 7/10.
Story: 0/5. (no story)
Level of Understanding: 2/5.
Total Score: 16/30.
Best of wishes and good luck,
~The Reviewer~
0
2
I now have a partner who reviews maps with me to increase the reviewing speed and process
Original Head of The Reviewer Team: Cerberus14321
Partner: DeviousFrost.
Simple, isn't it? Now a few rules:
I do not play any alpha(s) or pre-released version(s)! I only play at the current version that is available.
I do not use any mods, if a map needs a mod to be able to run, send me the link, i'll install the mod, and remove it after i'm done with your map!
Patience is important! I can not always review it in the first hours you post the request. But I promise, your map will be reviewed in less than a week.
Thats all!
Score System:
Creativity- How creative your map was, the story, the buildings, the forum post, anything related to the map itself. 10 Points
Fun- How much I enjoyed playing the map. Was it too long or boring or interesting. 10 Points
Story- Content of the story. 5 Points
Level Of Understanding- Was the map easily understood or was it too confusing. 5 Points
Currently Playing:An Epix Adventure by Firzen1.
Next Map: Pickup by yokcos700
Reviewed:Skyblock Madness:
Creativity: 7/10 [The map isnt so original but the challenges are ok and the islands are fine]
Fun: 2/10 [I wouldn't count waiting long days to gather wood and sand to reach 1 island and then wait again to reach another and complete all those challenges with limited resources AND with the risk of falling off and losing everything as fun.]
Story: 0/5 [No Story at all]
Level Of Understanding: 5/5 [Everything was nice and clear]
TOTAL: 14/ 30
Survival Galaxy:
- Making an infinite water pool is too easy make a 2x2x1 hole and drop water on each edge with 1 bucket is too easy of a challenge.
- Challenges 3, 7-13 can all be put up as one challenge. [For example: Challenge #3: Make a farm of the following items: Wheat, Reed, etc..]
- Challenges 15-17 are not written correctly. [Fixing Solution: Make a statue of every wool color block, etc...]
A few more suggestions:- Make your post more... organized. A full text block which includes: Explanations, challenges, old history is not appealing the viewer's eye. Make it more organize, divide texts of block by context. Separate every challenge by a new line.
- Keep updating constantly and give updates to your post, that should grab people's attention.
SCORES:Creativity: 7/10.
Fun: 7/10.
Story: 0/5. (no story)
Level of Understanding: 2/5.
Total Score: 16/30.
Best of wishes and good luck,
~The Reviewer~
Pickup:
I have played your map and the idea is ok. Although the diamonds keep glitching up and down and there is no clear instructions so it might take some time to even figure out what to do..Atleast put a few signs to guide people through the levels. Just walking around clueless isn't so fun afterall...
Score:
Creativity: 7/10.
Fun: 5/10.
Story: 0/5.
Level of Understanding: 0/5.
TOTAL: 12/30
0
0
0
Youll get everything that is needed.
0
0
1
We are glad to report you that we have downloaded and checked your map out, here is our reviewer's review!
'After you sent me the request and what you said in the pm. That the people said it was too hard and fun, I wanted to play it.
The map is creative. I liked the story. The only noticed thing is the items at the beginning.
No mistakes were found. The map is very fun, not very hard for me since I almost did everything. But that wall was awesome and creative! I liked your map very much and you did a great job with a creative map. The traps are awesome.
I liked the creeper from the ceiling one.... the first one I think. Nice ideas and great work!'
~The Reviewer~
Score Explanation:
The story is great. Nice idea, not too weird.
Your post is missing alot of stuff. Like other people's reviews. Ideas, rules, update history and alot of other needed stuff.
The activity is very good in this map. From traps along the side and the fighting along the way. Great job.
The fun rate is awesome. 10 out of 10.
Score:
Creativity: 10/10. [**]
Story: 10/10. [**]
Post: 6/10. [**]
Activity: 10/10. [**]
Fun Rate: 10/10. [**]
Result: 46/50.
RED- Bad.
ORANGE- Average.
GREEN- Good.
Blue- Excellent.
0
Waiting for more requests!