In DevineRPG enemies commonly dropped tomatoes. You could eat them and/or craft a tomato stew. So I thought it would be cool to add them so players can farm them and then eat them.
Tell me what you think about adding tomatoes into Minecraft!
Threads You Are Not Allowed to Make Unless you have a "getting my own threads locked" fetish.
Vague Ideas
It won't kill you. Explain your idea in more than 2 rushed "I have to go to school soon" sentences. Vague ideas usually get locked instantly here, so you may lose that chance to edit your thread for the better.
Excuses You Shouldn't Use And you should feel bad if you use them.
"Game X has this, so Minecraft should have this!"
I actually seen a thread where someone suggested that hot water magically heal you because a Legend of Zelda game had sauna's that could heal you. Uhhh okay.
We get it. Some of you like Skyrim. Some of you like Call of Duty. Some of you like Mario games. That's fine, but don't shut your brain off and start copy and pasting crap from those games. Shooting fire from your hands doesn't work in every game. Using your UAV killstreak doesn't work in every game.
Basically, you liking something in a game doesn't mean Minecraft should have it. Try to think outside yourself and not base the community around your thoughts. At the very best, if you're gonna copy and paste an idea from another game, at least reshape it so it's more balanced.
Presentations You Need to Avoid Because people will probably hate you a little if you don't avoid them.
"Add this mod!" Thank you, FrozenS2M
Gotta love it when people forget why mods are mods. Anyone at their own liesure can use the mod or not. Yes, we know there are mods you like, but that doesn't you should make a thread and go "add this to the game I'd really appreciate so yeah bye and support". Duuuumb.
This is usually caused by users with that mentality of "everyone else's opinions always match mine so errr yeah!" No. They don't. I'm sure you'd get all giddy if Mojang added the "Mo' Creatures" mod just for you, but the other 10,000,000 people that play this game may not. And those other 10,000,000 people, believe it or not, might have a different opinion than you! Woah! Strange right?!
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
There are things known as the 10 Suggestion Commandments. Many know the obvious, such as, "Thou shalt search before typing thy post," or, "Thou shalt not be vague," but one that no one knows is, "Thou shalt organize thy post." More people need to know of this commandment.
I don't see how this is vague. I explained everything about tomatoes that there is. I did not make this post because I like DevineRPG. I just think it would be cool to have tomatoes in Minecraft. We have potatoes, why not tomatoes?
You gave me an idea! A MO' Vegetables and/or MO' Fruit mod! I would make that, if I actually had any idea how to make mods or anything else on a computer...
I don't see how this is vague. I explained everything about tomatoes that there is. I did not make this post because I like DevineRPG. I just think it would be cool to have tomatoes in Minecraft. We have potatoes, why not tomatoes?
You gave me an idea! A MO' Vegetables and/or MO' Fruit mod! I would make that, if I actually had any idea how to make mods or anything else on a computer...
Nothing vague here... "Game X has this, so Minecraft should have this!" In DevineRPG enemies commonly dropped tomatoes....So I thought it would be cool to add them so players can farm them and then eat them.
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
If you'd like to quickly respond to me. quote me so I get notified
If I helped you, whether it's a question or not, press the for me.
This is still vague even ignoring the fact that you do a lot of what other threads say not to. You don't list where you get seeds or tomatos (saying that enemies drop them in some mod doesn't count, how would they drop in vanilla?), how much hunger they restore, recipes that use them, and what those items do. Like saying how tomato stew is made and how much hunger it restores.
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
Want some advice on how to thrive in the Suggestions section? Check this handy list of guidelines and tips for posting your ideas and responding to the ideas of others!
I don't see how this is vague. I explained everything about tomatoes that there is. I did not make this post because I like DevineRPG. I just think it would be cool to have tomatoes in Minecraft. We have potatoes, why not tomatoes?
No explanation on the look, how you get it, how much food it heals, if you can grow it or not, and other missing details.
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
There are things known as the 10 Suggestion Commandments. Many know the obvious, such as, "Thou shalt search before typing thy post," or, "Thou shalt not be vague," but one that no one knows is, "Thou shalt organize thy post." More people need to know of this commandment.
Ok. This was my first topic. I'll create another one with a lot more info.
Don't.
Just fix your first post. Also, mentioning that is your first topic means nothing, and it doesn't make you "catch a break" of some sort. At least tell us the healing hunger values of your tomato/tomato stew/whatever.
Vague, and most likely redundant. Also, do not reference mods in your suggestion.
I agree with all the other comments as well as Darkstar, except for this one part: "Also, do not reference mods in your suggestion."
I feel it's perfectly fair to reference mods in a suggestion as long as the suggestion stands up on its own without the reference. Think of the mod as great supporting evidence (much like with the cubic chunks suggestion which has a mod to show technical feasibility).
I agree with all the other comments as well as Darkstar, except for this one part: "Also, do not reference mods in your suggestion."
I feel it's perfectly fair to reference mods in a suggestion as long as the suggestion stands up on its own without the reference. Think of the mod as great supporting evidence (much like with the cubic chunks suggestion which has a mod to show technical feasibility).
It is alright to reference mods, as long as you actually explain the suggestion from that mod, rather than just linking the mod and wanting the exact same thing as that added. Sorry that I did not specify.
Did you know? Fun Facts with Talons7331! Fun for the whole family!
In today's episode of Did you know?Fun Facts with Talons7331! Fun for the whole family! we explore TOMATOES!
TOMATOES are an actual thing that exist in real life!
Wow!
That was really interesting!
Did you know? Fun Facts with Talons7331! Fun for the whole family!
Credits:
Tomatoes
Nic Cage
Lord Gaben
Talons7331
Tomatoes
Potatoes
Talons7331
Lord Gaben
Donald Trump's Hair
Tony Abbott
Prince Harry's Bald Patch
Obama
Lord Gaben
Apple Pie
WOO! I LOVE THIS SHOW!!!
Back on topic, besides the vague and irrelevant post(s), I think some more food would be nice. :/
Please be more detailed with your suggestions and use the search feature to check if your idea has been previously suggested before posting. This forum doesn't appreciate nor allow redundant topics.
Tell me what you think about adding tomatoes into Minecraft!
Miner's nightmare preset
Miner's nightmare preset (original terrain)
Killing the Ender Dragon, no damage (no armor/potions/enchantments/pumpkin)
gg dice
Nothing vague here...
"Game X has this, so Minecraft should have this!"
In DevineRPG enemies commonly dropped tomatoes....So I thought it would be cool to add them so players can farm them and then eat them.
If I helped you, whether it's a question or not, press the for me.
Want some advice on how to thrive in the Suggestions section? Check this handy list of guidelines and tips for posting your ideas and responding to the ideas of others!
http://www.minecraftforum.net/forums/minecraft-discussion/suggestions/2775557-guidelines-for-the-suggestions-forum
No explanation on the look, how you get it, how much food it heals, if you can grow it or not, and other missing details.
gg dice
Don't.
Just fix your first post. Also, mentioning that is your first topic means nothing, and it doesn't make you "catch a break" of some sort. At least tell us the healing hunger values of your tomato/tomato stew/whatever.
Every time a noob doesn't read the guide for Suggestions here and makes a fail post, God kills a kitten.
I agree with all the other comments as well as Darkstar, except for this one part: "Also, do not reference mods in your suggestion."
I feel it's perfectly fair to reference mods in a suggestion as long as the suggestion stands up on its own without the reference. Think of the mod as great supporting evidence (much like with the cubic chunks suggestion which has a mod to show technical feasibility).
It is alright to reference mods, as long as you actually explain the suggestion from that mod, rather than just linking the mod and wanting the exact same thing as that added. Sorry that I did not specify.
WOO! I LOVE THIS SHOW!!!
Back on topic, besides the vague and irrelevant post(s), I think some more food would be nice. :/
What did you think I meant?
http://www.minecraft.../2135716-tomato
http://www.minecraft...398503-tomatoes
Locking.