well, I don't even support the general idea, much less this form of it, where it apparently has no texture, crafting recipes, or way to obtain. I doubt that would be very useful.
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
I'm almost completely inactive, in case you're trawling through really old threads and notice me somewhere.
Upwards transportation has always been lacking compared to horizontal and downwards transportation, which has minecarts and freefalls into water respectively. Being able to travel upwards much faster is definitely something I would love to see!
This is vague. More information would be nice. You can already make elevators out of redstone and pistons, or, if that's too expensive, use ladders or a water elevator or even a minecart elevator.
Because elevators (something that wasn't invented until 1852) fit perfectly in Minecraft!
But... Minecraft has no distinct time period. Perhaps use yoshi's concept of feasibility instead of assuming that Minecraft has a set time frame.
That being said, upward, as well as downward transportation is already possible thanks to water+sign elevators and my personal favorite (because it looks cool with stained glass), minecart elevators. YouTube is a good place to learn how to make these.
But... Minecraft has no distinct time period. Perhaps use yoshi's concept of feasibility instead of assuming that Minecraft has a set time frame.
That being said, upward, as well as downward transportation is already possible thanks to water+sign elevators and my personal favorite (because it looks cool with stained glass), minecart elevators. YouTube is a good place to learn how to make these.
I don't assume that Minecraft has a set time frame, but I think it's pretty clear that modern tech doesn't exist in the world of Minecraft. So yeah.
Also, can I have the link to that theory? I'd like to see it.
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
My battle.net is Kirbyintron#1254, if you want to play some Overwatch with me.
My avatar is a sprite of Mr Saturn from the Earthbound/Mother series of Role Playing Games.
We already have ladders, stairs, water elevators, and redstone elevators. If you want elevators, just use OpenBlocks or some other mod. Besides, the first elevator was invented in 1853, which seems slightly off in a game based in a medieval age atmosphere. No support.
I don't assume that Minecraft has a set time frame, but I think it's pretty clear that modern tech doesn't exist in the world of Minecraft. So yeah.
Also, can I have the link to that theory? I'd like to see it.
It was posted in this thread somewhere in the late pages. Also viewing yoshi9048's profile and then posts might be able to help you find it quicker. If you're not interested in looking for it, then as a quick explanation, instead of looking at Minecraft as having a distinct time frame, when posting think instead if the item is feasible. Minecraft is a universe of it's own which has some features of modern technology (for example, redstone, command blocks, etc, etc) and some features of medieval/olden day (swords and whatnot).
This really isn't fitting in the game. Minecraft takes place in a cross Dark Ages and Industrial Revolution time period, a time when elevators weren't a common thing. They aren't really needed either, unless you are the most impatient person in the world.
No Support; does not fit time period.
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
I post pretty rarely nowadays. Gosh, I wish this place weren't so... empty...
Add more information, crafting recipes, how to use them, limitations, abilities. Also, I think wooden pulley operated elevators would actually (sort of) fit in.
Because elevators (something that wasn't invented until 1852) fit perfectly in Minecraft!
Umm, records weren't invented until 1857.
Correction: The Phonautograph... the first device capable of recording sound waves onto solid medium... wasn't invented until 1857. The actual technology to replay those sounds wasn't invented until 1877. And that used wax cylinders. Disks didn't become a reliable means of listening to music until the early 20th century!
Elevators would be a good idea for version 1.9
I agree, very vague. You need to add more information on how they would work, how to get them, etc.
GENERATION 36: The first time you see this, copy it into your signature
on any forum and add 1 to the generation. This is a Social experiment.
[SSSS]
well, I don't even support the general idea, much less this form of it, where it apparently has no texture, crafting recipes, or way to obtain. I doubt that would be very useful.
I'm almost completely inactive, in case you're trawling through really old threads and notice me somewhere.
Even though the vague rule doesn't exist anymore, we need a bit more information to actually criticize your suggestion.
Honestly, I think elevators don't fit very well in Minecraft.
I think adding elevators would be a great idea!
Upwards transportation has always been lacking compared to horizontal and downwards transportation, which has minecarts and freefalls into water respectively. Being able to travel upwards much faster is definitely something I would love to see!
Full support! Just kidding
plus you can sort of make a elevator with water and signs.
I'm almost completely inactive, in case you're trawling through really old threads and notice me somewhere.
This is vague. More information would be nice. You can already make elevators out of redstone and pistons, or, if that's too expensive, use ladders or a water elevator or even a minecart elevator.
No Support
Because elevators (something that wasn't invented until 1852) fit perfectly in Minecraft!
My battle.net is Kirbyintron#1254, if you want to play some Overwatch with me.
- dosent fit
- vague
- pointless (we have ladders)
no support
My signature is broken. I am currently fixing it
You can support my suggestions at:
Kiwi birds: -The link broke-
Every biome gets at least 1 mob: -The link broke-
Pirates: -The link broke-
Chorus apes: -The link broke
But... Minecraft has no distinct time period. Perhaps use yoshi's concept of feasibility instead of assuming that Minecraft has a set time frame.
That being said, upward, as well as downward transportation is already possible thanks to water+sign elevators and my personal favorite (because it looks cool with stained glass), minecart elevators. YouTube is a good place to learn how to make these.
Please add information before posting, as this is extremely vague. Adding more info will grant your rep rates faster and more positive.
My Avatar: Totally not me.
AND IF YOU THINK IT IS ME THEN YOU HAVE NO REASON TO. MY AVATAR IS UNIQUE AND I HAVE BALLS TO PUT IT UP. >3>
anyway luv u <3
I don't assume that Minecraft has a set time frame, but I think it's pretty clear that modern tech doesn't exist in the world of Minecraft. So yeah.
Also, can I have the link to that theory? I'd like to see it.
My battle.net is Kirbyintron#1254, if you want to play some Overwatch with me.
Extremely Vague. What will the Elevators be made of? How will they work?! Just what are they in general!?!
Coding, Gaming, all the same, there all on Computers, Technology is basically my life.
We already have ladders, stairs, water elevators, and redstone elevators. If you want elevators, just use OpenBlocks or some other mod. Besides, the first elevator was invented in 1853, which seems slightly off in a game based in a medieval age atmosphere. No support.
ok elevators are out
It was posted in this thread somewhere in the late pages. Also viewing yoshi9048's profile and then posts might be able to help you find it quicker. If you're not interested in looking for it, then as a quick explanation, instead of looking at Minecraft as having a distinct time frame, when posting think instead if the item is feasible. Minecraft is a universe of it's own which has some features of modern technology (for example, redstone, command blocks, etc, etc) and some features of medieval/olden day (swords and whatnot).
I still would recommend reading his posts.
I like the idea of a kind of pull-rope elevator like in the Oddworld games.
Example:
It definitely fits into the game more than an electrical/redstone operated elevator would.
I support. But needs more info.
This really isn't fitting in the game. Minecraft takes place in a cross Dark Ages and Industrial Revolution time period, a time when elevators weren't a common thing. They aren't really needed either, unless you are the most impatient person in the world.
No Support; does not fit time period.
I post pretty rarely nowadays. Gosh, I wish this place weren't so... empty...
Add more information, crafting recipes, how to use them, limitations, abilities. Also, I think wooden pulley operated elevators would actually (sort of) fit in.
SUPPORT IF STATEMENTS IN MINECRAFT!!
Umm,
records weren't invented until 1857.Correction: The Phonautograph... the first device capable of recording sound waves onto solid medium... wasn't invented until 1857. The actual technology to replay those sounds wasn't invented until 1877. And that used wax cylinders. Disks didn't become a reliable means of listening to music until the early 20th century!
Capture bats and other mobs in a small cage!
Bedrock edition: Using nether quartz to measure light levels