I recently decided to download OBS Multi-Platform for recording purposes; however, I ran into some issues, mainly being lag.
When I turn on the recorder, it seems like everything runs perfectly, and it does. Minecraft runs as smooth as smooth can be other than lag spikes a little often. However, it seems that whenever I try to record a different game such as Shadow of Mordor I get frame drops. It'll run perfectly and then I'll get a major lag spike and it'll be unplayable for a few seconds. Minecraft gets lag spikes as well but not this entirely bad. I've run over my settings; my settings don't seem to be at fault. My computer hardware itself seems fine, other than maybe the hard drive or the CPU.
The CPU, an i3 4150, almost seems like it COULD possibly bottleneck me during recording sessions; however, other people with the same CPU and sometimes a worse GPU get quite a few better frames than I do. I don't really seeing it getting to be this bad.
The other part, the HDD, possibly could be bottlenecking me a little bit. It's an old 160GB Blue drive of some sort that was sitting on my father's desk I believe. Not sure of the exact model, but it isn't the best of hard drives. Could it be struggling to keep up with processing the files as well as keeping a game loaded?
Not quite sure what to think here.
My Specs:
CPU: i3 4150 @3.5GHz
Motherboard: ASRock H97M Anniversary
Ram: 8GB Kingston Fury HYPERX Black @1866MHz
Storage: 160GB WD Blue of some sort
GPU: Gigabyte Geforce GTX 960 G1 Gaming
Case: Lian Li PC-50
PSU: EVGA 500w W1
OS: Linux Ubuntu 14.04 LTS
Please do not blame it on the OS unless you research on that specific piece, as I can't really see any issue on it. When I'm not recording, everything is perfect. OBS seems stable for other people as well, so I can't find a reason to suggest that as the cause.
Any help is highly appreciated and my settings for OBS are below!
Using MP4, 2500 bitrate, custom buffer size of 0, no cbr, crf 15, ultrafast, no profile, x264, 30 fps, bilinear filter, l444 color format, 709 YUV color space and partial YUV color range.
What resolution are you recording at and what frame rate? 2500 is a bit low unless you are streaming. Also, try out the Quick Sync and Nvidia NVENC encoders to see if you still get this problem.
I would recommend getting a bigger hard-drive if you record a lot. It could be a problem depending on the amount of space you have. Try running a disk fragment.
The main issue if probably your CPU. Try setting the Priority higher in Advance settings.
There might be a way to log what is happening in OBS. Usually when I get FPS dips, OBS will put red text on the bottom, under Scenes, saying High Encoding. If you only have one monitor, I am not sure there is a way to see this.
What resolution are you recording at and what frame rate? 2500 is a bit low unless you are streaming. Also, try out the Quick Sync and Nvidia NVENC encoders to see if you still get this problem.
I would recommend getting a bigger hard-drive if you record a lot. It could be a problem depending on the amount of space you have. Try running a disk fragment.
The main issue if probably your CPU. Try setting the Priority higher in Advance settings.
There might be a way to log what is happening in OBS. Usually when I get FPS dips, OBS will put red text on the bottom, under Scenes, saying High Encoding. If you only have one monitor, I am not sure there is a way to see this.
Resolution: 1680x1050
FPS: 30 (Would do 60, but let's not stretch it with an i3.)
Sadly Quicksync and NVENC are not on OBS for Linux from the beginning; in fact, Quicksync isn't supported at all.
However, Nvidia recently added support for NVENC on Linux in recent drivers through ffmpeg, allowing people to have built it in to OBS themselves. I'm actually currently attempting to do this myself. It definitely will take a lot of work though, so that's why I'm asking if there's a way for better performance on x264.
I could switch to Windows and make it simple; however, I honestly don't like Windows. I mainly like Linux because I can customize it to my liking. (Games are getting pretty good now, including Alien . Isolation soon as well as Arma 3 while Shadow of Mordor is compatible already. Quite a few more you'll see on Steam.) That being said, the NVENC is worth it me. The main reason it's so hard for me is the fact that I'm trying to get a grasp on what I'm doing and planning it out.
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
• CPU: Intel Core i3 4150 @3.5GHz
• Mobo: ASRock H97M Anniversary
• Ram: Kingston Fury HyperX Black 8GB(2x4) @1866MHz
Generally OBS shouldn't be limited by the write speed of your HDD as it encodes the footage to x264 before saving to disk. That does however, mean that the i3 4150 may be an issue which you are obviously aware of. What sort of CPU usage vs GPU usage are you getting when recording with SOM?
If you only have one screen you could probably set up MSI Afterburner Overla- wait, Ubuntu. Mm. Dunno then. Doesn't seem like there are any decent overlay options for *nix.
Also, is ShadowPlay available under Linux, or is that a Windows only thing? I haven't really ever bothered checking, i'm guessing it isn't.
Generally OBS shouldn't be limited by the write speed of your HDD as it encodes the footage to x264 before saving to disk. That does however, mean that the i3 4150 may be an issue which you are obviously aware of. What sort of CPU usage vs GPU usage are you getting when recording with SOM?
If you only have one screen you could probably set up MSI Afterburner Overla- wait, Ubuntu. Mm. Dunno then. Doesn't seem like there are any decent overlay options for *nix.
Also, is ShadowPlay available under Linux, or is that a Windows only thing? I haven't really ever bothered checking, i'm guessing it isn't.
No, sadly. I may be able to get the NVENC set up in the nearby future. I really do wish Shadowplay was available through Linux, as that'd be a top pick for me. I'll check the usage tomorrow after school when I get some time. Though the CPU usage when I looked at OBS was at around 15-30 percent I believe. Course, that was instantly after I left the game. And yes, I do have one screen to answer that question!
Seems Linux is pretty good now on games and the such, but not so good for things such as this.
Seems Linux is pretty good now on games and the such, but not so good for things such as this.
False statement. Way false.
I usually use a recorder named SimpleScreenRecorder. It worked well but it was slow. That was why I tried OBS. When I saw that NVENC was generally built in, (Though it's supported.) I tried implementing it myself. Failed.
However, just a couple minutes ago I got back on SimpleScreenRecorder and looked around to see if I could fix it. Huh. I found an H264 format hidden in the list of formats. Hey, I figured I'd load it on and screw around and laugh at the lag.
Well, I loaded up Shadow of Mordor on ultra settings (Texture quality set to medium because I only have a 2GB card. I don't like motion blur either so I got rid of that.) and hey. I got a steady 40-60 fps solid. Only a frame drop here and there in intense spots to 25-30.
What the heck just happened.
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
• CPU: Intel Core i3 4150 @3.5GHz
• Mobo: ASRock H97M Anniversary
• Ram: Kingston Fury HyperX Black 8GB(2x4) @1866MHz
Resolution: 1680x1050
FPS: 30 (Would do 60, but let's not stretch it with an i3.)
Sadly Quicksync and NVENC are not on OBS for Linux from the beginning; in fact, Quicksync isn't supported at all.
I could switch to Windows and make it simple; however, I honestly don't like Windows. I mainly like Linux because I can customize it to my liking. (Games are getting pretty good now, including Alien . Isolation soon as well as Arma 3 while Shadow of Mordor is compatible already. Quite a few more you'll see on Steam.) That being said, the NVENC is worth it me. The main reason it's so hard for me is the fact that I'm trying to get a grasp on what I'm doing and planning it out.
You could do a dual boot option and have Windows just for recording and playing games, kind of a pain though. Did not know that NVENC was not on Linux, kind of sucks. Not really sure why OBS is lagging for you. Could be just so optimizations with OBS. If you plan on doing a lot of recording, you might wan't to get capture card, but their expensive and not really worth it.
Anyways, hope you can find a good screen recorder on linux. SimpleScreenRecorder looks ok.
You could do a dual boot option and have Windows just for recording and playing games, kind of a pain though. Did not know that NVENC was not on Linux, kind of sucks. Not really sure why OBS is lagging for you. Could be just so optimizations with OBS. If you plan on doing a lot of recording, you might wan't to get capture card, but their expensive and not really worth it.
Anyways, hope you can find a good screen recorder on linux. SimpleScreenRecorder looks ok.
I like it better than OBS now. I switched the file format on it to FLV experimenting rather than the H264 and I squeezed out even more performance. I was worried that the picture quality wouldn't be as good but holy crap it's far better than OBS would ever be. I think I found my recorder :).
I recently decided to download OBS Multi-Platform for recording purposes; however, I ran into some issues, mainly being lag.
When I turn on the recorder, it seems like everything runs perfectly, and it does. Minecraft runs as smooth as smooth can be other than lag spikes a little often. However, it seems that whenever I try to record a different game such as Shadow of Mordor I get frame drops. It'll run perfectly and then I'll get a major lag spike and it'll be unplayable for a few seconds. Minecraft gets lag spikes as well but not this entirely bad. I've run over my settings; my settings don't seem to be at fault. My computer hardware itself seems fine, other than maybe the hard drive or the CPU.
The CPU, an i3 4150, almost seems like it COULD possibly bottleneck me during recording sessions; however, other people with the same CPU and sometimes a worse GPU get quite a few better frames than I do. I don't really seeing it getting to be this bad.
The other part, the HDD, possibly could be bottlenecking me a little bit. It's an old 160GB Blue drive of some sort that was sitting on my father's desk I believe. Not sure of the exact model, but it isn't the best of hard drives. Could it be struggling to keep up with processing the files as well as keeping a game loaded?
Not quite sure what to think here.
My Specs:
CPU: i3 4150 @3.5GHz
Motherboard: ASRock H97M Anniversary
Ram: 8GB Kingston Fury HYPERX Black @1866MHz
Storage: 160GB WD Blue of some sort
GPU: Gigabyte Geforce GTX 960 G1 Gaming
Case: Lian Li PC-50
PSU: EVGA 500w W1
OS: Linux Ubuntu 14.04 LTS
Please do not blame it on the OS unless you research on that specific piece, as I can't really see any issue on it. When I'm not recording, everything is perfect. OBS seems stable for other people as well, so I can't find a reason to suggest that as the cause.
Any help is highly appreciated and my settings for OBS are below!
Using MP4, 2500 bitrate, custom buffer size of 0, no cbr, crf 15, ultrafast, no profile, x264, 30 fps, bilinear filter, l444 color format, 709 YUV color space and partial YUV color range.
• CPU: Intel Core i3 4150 @3.5GHz
• Mobo: ASRock H97M Anniversary
• Ram: Kingston Fury HyperX Black 8GB(2x4) @1866MHz
• GPU: Gigabyte GeForce GTX 960 G1 Gaming 2GB GDDR5
• PSU: EVGA 500W 80+ Certified
• HDD: Western Digital Caviar Blue 1TB
• HDD: Western Digital Caviar Blue 160GB
• Case: Lian Li PC-50
• Monitor: Acer P221w 22" 1680x1050 60Hz
• Headset: Kingston Fury HyperX Clouds
• Mouse: Razer Deathadder 3.5G 3500DPI
• Keyboard: Cooler Master Storm Quickfire Rapid w/ Cherry MX Blues
What resolution are you recording at and what frame rate? 2500 is a bit low unless you are streaming. Also, try out the Quick Sync and Nvidia NVENC encoders to see if you still get this problem.
I would recommend getting a bigger hard-drive if you record a lot. It could be a problem depending on the amount of space you have. Try running a disk fragment.
The main issue if probably your CPU. Try setting the Priority higher in Advance settings.
There might be a way to log what is happening in OBS. Usually when I get FPS dips, OBS will put red text on the bottom, under Scenes, saying High Encoding. If you only have one monitor, I am not sure there is a way to see this.
Check out my Animation Channel: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCVy57y58kWOd6zRYJNGQkNg/feed
Resolution: 1680x1050
FPS: 30 (Would do 60, but let's not stretch it with an i3.)
Sadly Quicksync and NVENC are not on OBS for Linux from the beginning; in fact, Quicksync isn't supported at all.
However, Nvidia recently added support for NVENC on Linux in recent drivers through ffmpeg, allowing people to have built it in to OBS themselves. I'm actually currently attempting to do this myself. It definitely will take a lot of work though, so that's why I'm asking if there's a way for better performance on x264.
I could switch to Windows and make it simple; however, I honestly don't like Windows. I mainly like Linux because I can customize it to my liking. (Games are getting pretty good now, including Alien . Isolation soon as well as Arma 3 while Shadow of Mordor is compatible already. Quite a few more you'll see on Steam.) That being said, the NVENC is worth it me. The main reason it's so hard for me is the fact that I'm trying to get a grasp on what I'm doing and planning it out.
• CPU: Intel Core i3 4150 @3.5GHz
• Mobo: ASRock H97M Anniversary
• Ram: Kingston Fury HyperX Black 8GB(2x4) @1866MHz
• GPU: Gigabyte GeForce GTX 960 G1 Gaming 2GB GDDR5
• PSU: EVGA 500W 80+ Certified
• HDD: Western Digital Caviar Blue 1TB
• HDD: Western Digital Caviar Blue 160GB
• Case: Lian Li PC-50
• Monitor: Acer P221w 22" 1680x1050 60Hz
• Headset: Kingston Fury HyperX Clouds
• Mouse: Razer Deathadder 3.5G 3500DPI
• Keyboard: Cooler Master Storm Quickfire Rapid w/ Cherry MX Blues
Generally OBS shouldn't be limited by the write speed of your HDD as it encodes the footage to x264 before saving to disk. That does however, mean that the i3 4150 may be an issue which you are obviously aware of. What sort of CPU usage vs GPU usage are you getting when recording with SOM?
If you only have one screen you could probably set up MSI Afterburner Overla- wait, Ubuntu. Mm. Dunno then. Doesn't seem like there are any decent overlay options for *nix.
Also, is ShadowPlay available under Linux, or is that a Windows only thing? I haven't really ever bothered checking, i'm guessing it isn't.
K95 RGB / Logitech G502 PS / Alienware AW3418DW / ViewSonic XG2703-GS / Sennheiser HD 598
No, sadly. I may be able to get the NVENC set up in the nearby future. I really do wish Shadowplay was available through Linux, as that'd be a top pick for me. I'll check the usage tomorrow after school when I get some time. Though the CPU usage when I looked at OBS was at around 15-30 percent I believe. Course, that was instantly after I left the game. And yes, I do have one screen to answer that question!
Seems Linux is pretty good now on games and the such, but not so good for things such as this.
• CPU: Intel Core i3 4150 @3.5GHz
• Mobo: ASRock H97M Anniversary
• Ram: Kingston Fury HyperX Black 8GB(2x4) @1866MHz
• GPU: Gigabyte GeForce GTX 960 G1 Gaming 2GB GDDR5
• PSU: EVGA 500W 80+ Certified
• HDD: Western Digital Caviar Blue 1TB
• HDD: Western Digital Caviar Blue 160GB
• Case: Lian Li PC-50
• Monitor: Acer P221w 22" 1680x1050 60Hz
• Headset: Kingston Fury HyperX Clouds
• Mouse: Razer Deathadder 3.5G 3500DPI
• Keyboard: Cooler Master Storm Quickfire Rapid w/ Cherry MX Blues
False statement. Way false.
I usually use a recorder named SimpleScreenRecorder. It worked well but it was slow. That was why I tried OBS. When I saw that NVENC was generally built in, (Though it's supported.) I tried implementing it myself. Failed.
However, just a couple minutes ago I got back on SimpleScreenRecorder and looked around to see if I could fix it. Huh. I found an H264 format hidden in the list of formats. Hey, I figured I'd load it on and screw around and laugh at the lag.
Well, I loaded up Shadow of Mordor on ultra settings (Texture quality set to medium because I only have a 2GB card. I don't like motion blur either so I got rid of that.) and hey. I got a steady 40-60 fps solid. Only a frame drop here and there in intense spots to 25-30.
What the heck just happened.
• CPU: Intel Core i3 4150 @3.5GHz
• Mobo: ASRock H97M Anniversary
• Ram: Kingston Fury HyperX Black 8GB(2x4) @1866MHz
• GPU: Gigabyte GeForce GTX 960 G1 Gaming 2GB GDDR5
• PSU: EVGA 500W 80+ Certified
• HDD: Western Digital Caviar Blue 1TB
• HDD: Western Digital Caviar Blue 160GB
• Case: Lian Li PC-50
• Monitor: Acer P221w 22" 1680x1050 60Hz
• Headset: Kingston Fury HyperX Clouds
• Mouse: Razer Deathadder 3.5G 3500DPI
• Keyboard: Cooler Master Storm Quickfire Rapid w/ Cherry MX Blues
You could do a dual boot option and have Windows just for recording and playing games, kind of a pain though. Did not know that NVENC was not on Linux, kind of sucks. Not really sure why OBS is lagging for you. Could be just so optimizations with OBS. If you plan on doing a lot of recording, you might wan't to get capture card, but their expensive and not really worth it.
Anyways, hope you can find a good screen recorder on linux. SimpleScreenRecorder looks ok.
Check out my Animation Channel: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCVy57y58kWOd6zRYJNGQkNg/feed
I like it better than OBS now. I switched the file format on it to FLV experimenting rather than the H264 and I squeezed out even more performance. I was worried that the picture quality wouldn't be as good but holy crap it's far better than OBS would ever be. I think I found my recorder :).
• CPU: Intel Core i3 4150 @3.5GHz
• Mobo: ASRock H97M Anniversary
• Ram: Kingston Fury HyperX Black 8GB(2x4) @1866MHz
• GPU: Gigabyte GeForce GTX 960 G1 Gaming 2GB GDDR5
• PSU: EVGA 500W 80+ Certified
• HDD: Western Digital Caviar Blue 1TB
• HDD: Western Digital Caviar Blue 160GB
• Case: Lian Li PC-50
• Monitor: Acer P221w 22" 1680x1050 60Hz
• Headset: Kingston Fury HyperX Clouds
• Mouse: Razer Deathadder 3.5G 3500DPI
• Keyboard: Cooler Master Storm Quickfire Rapid w/ Cherry MX Blues
The i3 definitely isnt helping. I would recommend an i5 at least for fraps and or shadowplay.
I already solved the issue by optimizing SimpleScreenRecorder better. Thanks though!
• CPU: Intel Core i3 4150 @3.5GHz
• Mobo: ASRock H97M Anniversary
• Ram: Kingston Fury HyperX Black 8GB(2x4) @1866MHz
• GPU: Gigabyte GeForce GTX 960 G1 Gaming 2GB GDDR5
• PSU: EVGA 500W 80+ Certified
• HDD: Western Digital Caviar Blue 1TB
• HDD: Western Digital Caviar Blue 160GB
• Case: Lian Li PC-50
• Monitor: Acer P221w 22" 1680x1050 60Hz
• Headset: Kingston Fury HyperX Clouds
• Mouse: Razer Deathadder 3.5G 3500DPI
• Keyboard: Cooler Master Storm Quickfire Rapid w/ Cherry MX Blues