Hello friends,
I am not telling you about any confirmed feature or possible feature that could be added in mcpe 0.9.0
this is a discussion topic in which I am raising the following question :
Should Mojang add a crafting interface like MC:PC in MCPE 0.9.0?
-What is a Crafting interface in MC:PC?
- A crafting interface is a feature that you see in MC:PC. There are 9 blocks area for crafting different items through a crafting table and a 4 block area for crafting things anywhere without using a crafting table. No recipes are given in this interface and the user has to explore new recipes themselves. This feature is currently not in MC:PE and a list of recipes is given with the crafting screen.you can see pictures of this interface on internet.
POSSIBLE REASONS FOR ADDING A CRAFTING INTERFACE LIKE MC:PC IN MCPE --
(1)The user will have to explore new recipes and it would create a type of adventure in the survival mode.
(2)As more items get added to McPe in the next updates, the list of items in the crafting screen will increase a lot.
By adding a crafting interface like MC:PC, the user can craft quickly without searching items in the list.
POSSIBLE REASONS FOR NOT ADDING A CRAFTING INTERFACE LIKE MC:PC IN MCPE --
(1)The user does not need to learn crafting recipes and it becomes easier for beginners to play MC:PE.
(2)The screen of phones are quite smaller than PC, so it could become very difficult for people to craft easily in the small screen.
NOTE : Mojang has not confirmed this feature or discussed about this at all. Do not expect this in the next update.
if you want to know about the confirmed and possible updates, please see the topic pinned to this forums section.
Mojang is not at all affiliated to this post and nor are they concerned with the replies here. This is a disscussion topic where people can discuss thier views.
I HAVE ONLY MENTIONED THE REASONS I FELT, IF YOU HAVE A PRACTICAL REASON FOR MOJANG TO ADD / NOT ADD THIS FEATURE, THEN YOU CAN REPLY HERE.
YOU MAY DISSCUSS YOUR YHOUGHTS OR REPLY BACK YOUR VIEWS CONCERNED TO THIS FEATURE HERE.
You seem to have an interest in minecraft pe so surely you follow the pocket edition forum section and have run into these types of discussions before, so I'm sure you are aware that only 2% of 1% of everyone that plays mcpe would actually agree with this!...
No but seriously adding the PC crafting system would be a really bad idea!
You seem to have an interest in minecraft pe so surely you follow the pocket edition forum section and have run into these types of discussions before, so I'm sure you are aware that only 2% of 1% of everyone that plays mcpe would actually agree with this!...
yes, I am a MCPE player. I actually do not disagree with this. I feel that there should be toggle by which wecan just switch the interface.
I also agree that many people will disagree but there are some people who want more adventure and exploration in MCPE.
actually, mcpc players dont understand the demands of mcpe players.
I hope that people would definitely want crafting interface like mcpc in mcpe.
yes, I am a MCPE player. I actually do not disagree with this. I feel that there should be toggle by which wecan just switch the interface.
I also agree that many people will disagree but there are some people who want more adventure and exploration in MCPE.
actually, mcpc players dont understand the demands of mcpe players.
I hope that people would definitely want crafting interface like mcpc in mcpe.
I don't believe I said you disagreed with the idea! It's been explained over and over why PC crafting would not work on mcpe . True there are people who want this added but not nearly enough to change the minds of the dev team.
I think there should be a switch to turn this on or off (so beginners can choose and more advanced players)
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
King Robertzilla22 HE IZ BOSS OF MCPE. (sorry about any bad grammar)
I luv minecraft cuz its cool Twitter use #Robertzilla22
I luv derping, derp and the world will derp with you( nerdy and weird quote from me )
Well If I am not mistaken the devs did say something about changing the crafting system a bit but there is no guarantee that it will be the PC crafting interface
Well If I am not mistaken the devs did say something about changing the crafting system a bit but there is no guarantee that it will be the PC crafting interface
yeah. There is a 10 or 20% chance for changing the interface but we need to say that many people want it.
guys, if you have some practical reasons for the implementation of a new crafting interface, you must reply back here.
this is the topic where we want discussions abouf this feature to be held.
I agree. A toggle switch would be best of both worlds. I have several fan based apps just because they use the pc style crafting but there aretimes where the pe and xbox crafting style allows me to focus on the game instead of figuring out recipes. I think recipes are integral to the exploration feel but can be distracting under certain circumstances
I agree. A toggle switch would be best of both worlds. I have several fan based apps just because they use the pc style crafting but there aretimes where the pe and xbox crafting style allows me to focus on the game instead of figuring out recipes. I think recipes are integral to the exploration feel but can be distracting under certain circumstances
I totally agree with a toggle switch i an a PC player and always loved that ability I wish that would add a toggle switch to all mincrafts
I don't believe I said you disagreed with the idea! It's been explained over and over why PC crafting would not work on mcpe . True there are people who want this added but not nearly enough to change the minds of the dev team.
It works just fine on Survival Craft, even on an older phone with a smaller screen. One guy working in his spare time pulled it off, if a Dev team with a real budget can't manage the same then something is wrong.
For what it's worth; I find MCPE's crafting system breaks my immersion somewhat, especially if I've been playing any other voxel game recently. It feels like a chunk of the experience is missing. It's actually #2 on my new feature want-list for MCPE, right after infinite worlds.
It works just fine on Survival Craft, even on an older phone with a smaller screen. One guy working in his spare time pulled it off, if a Dev team with a real budget can't manage the same then something is wrong.
For what it's worth; I find MCPE's crafting system breaks my immersion somewhat, especially if I've been playing any other voxel game recently. It feels like a chunk of the experience is missing. It's actually #2 on my new feature want-list for MCPE, right after infinite worlds.
yes. Thats quite correct. Some features which are similar to MCPC attract people and make them go to the games like survival craft.
mojang does not provide effective features for MCPE and that the reason thousands of mcpe players quit every week.
Most people would disagree with this idea and thats the reason mojang does not pays attention to this.
if people dislike this and dont actually respond. I don't think that mojang would ever implement this idea.
yes, I am a MCPE player. I actually do not disagree with this. I feel that there should be toggle by which wecan just switch the interface.
I also agree that many people will disagree but there are some people who want more adventure and exploration in MCPE.
actually, mcpc players dont understand the demands of mcpe players.
I hope that people would definitely want crafting interface like mcpc in mcpe.
I agree that there should be a way to switch.
It would add an extra challenge and would work well on a tablet.
Just have it off when working on a smaller device.
I think its a great idea.
I believe there actually is a mod for xbox360/pe crafting. Im not a pc user (yet) so no link but ive seen video reviews of it in passing
So you are saying that there is a mod for mcpe which allows you to do so.
if so, please send me the website name/video name or something related to it so that we can find it. Thanks for that suggestion dood.
The crafting on pe is what helped me with PC originally, the current crafting in pe tells you what you need, how many you got and what it does, it's a lot harder and time consuming for a noob on PC because they see it as punch block throw it in and something pops out.
I disagree with this point only because of how it will be done, because how would make it so that you could only put one item in a square? or even how will the crafting square fit in? This is kind of pointless to add to the game because people like me will always have to search up how to craft this and that and that the game was very well done even without this feature because it is so minor. So I disagree.
a. Do, for example, a pickaxe because you need three of the stone e.t.c. and two of the sticks? Because how you split up the items? If it would place one item to the place where you tap in the crafting menu, it would be hard to craft loooots of stone bricks e.t.c.
b. Where the items you have in your inventory would be? (In the crafting)
Would it have the recipe "reset" button, so if you missclick one thing to the crafting slot and you couldn't craft anything because the recipe is wrong?
I know what you mean to say. If you want to know how the pc crafting would work in mcpe, just download an android game called "survival craft". Also people would like to o use pc crafting on bigger devices like tablets or 5 inch phones.Adding a toggle switch will be the best idea. It would allow people to choose what they want.
I am not telling you about any confirmed feature or possible feature that could be added in mcpe 0.9.0
this is a discussion topic in which I am raising the following question :
Should Mojang add a crafting interface like MC:PC in MCPE 0.9.0?
-What is a Crafting interface in MC:PC?
- A crafting interface is a feature that you see in MC:PC. There are 9 blocks area for crafting different items through a crafting table and a 4 block area for crafting things anywhere without using a crafting table. No recipes are given in this interface and the user has to explore new recipes themselves. This feature is currently not in MC:PE and a list of recipes is given with the crafting screen.you can see pictures of this interface on internet.
POSSIBLE REASONS FOR ADDING A CRAFTING INTERFACE LIKE MC:PC IN MCPE --
(1)The user will have to explore new recipes and it would create a type of adventure in the survival mode.
(2)As more items get added to McPe in the next updates, the list of items in the crafting screen will increase a lot.
By adding a crafting interface like MC:PC, the user can craft quickly without searching items in the list.
POSSIBLE REASONS FOR NOT ADDING A CRAFTING INTERFACE LIKE MC:PC IN MCPE --
(1)The user does not need to learn crafting recipes and it becomes easier for beginners to play MC:PE.
(2)The screen of phones are quite smaller than PC, so it could become very difficult for people to craft easily in the small screen.
NOTE : Mojang has not confirmed this feature or discussed about this at all. Do not expect this in the next update.
if you want to know about the confirmed and possible updates, please see the topic pinned to this forums section.
Mojang is not at all affiliated to this post and nor are they concerned with the replies here. This is a disscussion topic where people can discuss thier views.
I HAVE ONLY MENTIONED THE REASONS I FELT, IF YOU HAVE A PRACTICAL REASON FOR MOJANG TO ADD / NOT ADD THIS FEATURE, THEN YOU CAN REPLY HERE.
YOU MAY DISSCUSS YOUR YHOUGHTS OR REPLY BACK YOUR VIEWS CONCERNED TO THIS FEATURE HERE.
You seem to have an interest in minecraft pe so surely you follow the pocket edition forum section and have run into these types of discussions before, so I'm sure you are aware that only 2% of 1% of everyone that plays mcpe would actually agree with this!...
No but seriously adding the PC crafting system would be a really bad idea!
Image Removed
yes, I am a MCPE player. I actually do not disagree with this. I feel that there should be toggle by which wecan just switch the interface.
I also agree that many people will disagree but there are some people who want more adventure and exploration in MCPE.
actually, mcpc players dont understand the demands of mcpe players.
I hope that people would definitely want crafting interface like mcpc in mcpe.
I don't believe I said you disagreed with the idea! It's been explained over and over why PC crafting would not work on mcpe . True there are people who want this added but not nearly enough to change the minds of the dev team.
Image Removed
I luv minecraft cuz its cool Twitter use #Robertzilla22
I luv derping, derp and the world will derp with you( nerdy and weird quote from me )
yeah. There is a 10 or 20% chance for changing the interface but we need to say that many people want it.
guys, if you have some practical reasons for the implementation of a new crafting interface, you must reply back here.
this is the topic where we want discussions abouf this feature to be held.
I totally agree with a toggle switch i an a PC player and always loved that ability I wish that would add a toggle switch to all mincrafts
It works just fine on Survival Craft, even on an older phone with a smaller screen. One guy working in his spare time pulled it off, if a Dev team with a real budget can't manage the same then something is wrong.
For what it's worth; I find MCPE's crafting system breaks my immersion somewhat, especially if I've been playing any other voxel game recently. It feels like a chunk of the experience is missing. It's actually #2 on my new feature want-list for MCPE, right after infinite worlds.
yes. Thats quite correct. Some features which are similar to MCPC attract people and make them go to the games like survival craft.
mojang does not provide effective features for MCPE and that the reason thousands of mcpe players quit every week.
Most people would disagree with this idea and thats the reason mojang does not pays attention to this.
if people dislike this and dont actually respond. I don't think that mojang would ever implement this idea.
I agree that there should be a way to switch.
It would add an extra challenge and would work well on a tablet.
Just have it off when working on a smaller device.
I think its a great idea.
http://www.reddit.com/r/MCPE/comments/1ssgsu/bug_can_only_craft_red_carpet_in_survival/ce1ix4d?context=1
I believe there actually is a mod for xbox360/pe crafting. Im not a pc user (yet) so no link but ive seen video reviews of it in passing
if so, please send me the website name/video name or something related to it so that we can find it. Thanks for that suggestion dood.
http://www.minecraftforum.net/forums/mapping-and-modding/maps/2340039-city-map-merriston-v1-airport-pc-map-mcpe-map-in