I think it's stupid when people want oceancraft, or farmcraft when this is minecraft forums and should stop spamming and suggest that it can happen IN minecraft
Well, this thread had to appear sooner or later. Not everyone is going to like [fill in the black] craft.
Yes, the focus of Minecraft should be more mining than [name your craft]. I personally don't see [name your craft] as separate as long as it doesn't overshadow the mining aspect of the game. I see [name your craft] is actually just an extension of something minecraft already does or could do. Yes, I am for certain [name your craft] as I'm sure you'll notice in my banner. However, I only support [name your craft] as long as it adds instead of detracts from Minecraft AND DOES NOT OVERSHADOW the mining aspect of Minecraft.
I support Farmcraft for example because I'd like to see more varities of food and I'd like to grow something besides only wheat in Minecraft. I DO NOT want to see Minecraft become all about farming and cooking. I would HATE that. I would however like to see a little more than what there is right now, but not to the point that the game becomes all about food and farming. That would be absolutely awful! There is a reason I do not play farmville on facebook. So, even as a supporter of farmcraft I agree with you that I DO NOT want Minecraft to be all about farming. The farming aspect SHOULD NOT take away from the mining aspect.. That's taking the farming thing way too far, and further than I will support it. Keep in mind that the bulk of the things suggested in [name your craft] aren't likely to get added to the game. Only the best of all those ideas will make it, if at all. I also highly doubt that Notch would EVER allow [pick a craft] to take over his game and have it be more about [pick a craft] than mining. He just would NOT ever allow it.
I think that [name your crafts] are more of a misnomer. I don't believe for one moment that any of the supporters of [pick a craft] want Minecraft to become all about whatever that craft is and completely lose sight of the mining aspect of Minecraft or to have that craft overshadow the mining aspect. It should NEVER be more about any [name your craft] than the mining, this is MINECRAFT after all. This is coming from someone that is a supporter of a craft. We're not all crazies who want our craft to take over Minecraft. The [pick a craft] is only a side dish/accent/supporting role/ side attraction to the main event that is Minecraft.
I think that naming a certain idea somethingcraft is giving and spreading a false idea. The false idea that the supports want that [name your craft] to take over the whole game. In truth it's just a group of people that would like to see a bit more content of a certain theme added to accentuate the mining aspect.
For example, I would like to see Volcanic Biomes in Minecraft. I created a thread for this topic here: http://www.minecraftforum.net/viewtopic.php?f=1&t=88973. Notice I did not call the topic VolcanoCraft. I don't want Minecraft to become all about Volcanoes , but I would like to see them in Minecraft. I should still be able to mine the volcano and everywhere else. The volcanoes should only enhance my mining experience not detract from it.
This goes for all [pick your craft]. The moment that [name your craft] becomes more about that craft than the mining, it doesn't belong in Minecraft anymore. It's madness to want Minecraft to be all about farming. If that's what you want you can go play farmville. If you already play farmville good for you. Don't expect me to join you.
Sorry for the long post. I thought someone who supports a [pick your craft] should be allowed to speak on this and show that we're not all nut jobs that want to destroy or ruin Minecraft. We make suggestions because we love Minecraft even if those suggestions are poorly named.
This is just idiotic. The threads are not called that because that's what they want minecraft to become. It's because all the ideas in that thread have a certain theme. They all know notch can take any or all of an idea and implement it. People just tend to think thematically.
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
Want some advice on how to thrive in the Suggestions section? Check this handy list of guidelines and tips for posting your ideas and responding to the ideas of others!
Well, this thread had to appear sooner or later. Not everyone is going to like [fill in the black] craft...
I agree with your whole post. I support Farmcraft because I want more food in Minecraft, not just cake, pork, bread and the very rare cookie. I DO NOT want MC to become all about farming. I support Oceancraft because I want more animals in the ocean. I would like more Ores in MC, but not a **** ton. I want more animals, but not a **** ton. I want more plants, but not a **** ton. I want more pictures, but not a **** ton.
no im not
Yes, the focus of Minecraft should be more mining than [name your craft]. I personally don't see [name your craft] as separate as long as it doesn't overshadow the mining aspect of the game. I see [name your craft] is actually just an extension of something minecraft already does or could do. Yes, I am for certain [name your craft] as I'm sure you'll notice in my banner. However, I only support [name your craft] as long as it adds instead of detracts from Minecraft AND DOES NOT OVERSHADOW the mining aspect of Minecraft.
I support Farmcraft for example because I'd like to see more varities of food and I'd like to grow something besides only wheat in Minecraft. I DO NOT want to see Minecraft become all about farming and cooking. I would HATE that. I would however like to see a little more than what there is right now, but not to the point that the game becomes all about food and farming. That would be absolutely awful! There is a reason I do not play farmville on facebook. So, even as a supporter of farmcraft I agree with you that I DO NOT want Minecraft to be all about farming. The farming aspect SHOULD NOT take away from the mining aspect.. That's taking the farming thing way too far, and further than I will support it. Keep in mind that the bulk of the things suggested in [name your craft] aren't likely to get added to the game. Only the best of all those ideas will make it, if at all. I also highly doubt that Notch would EVER allow [pick a craft] to take over his game and have it be more about [pick a craft] than mining. He just would NOT ever allow it.
I think that [name your crafts] are more of a misnomer. I don't believe for one moment that any of the supporters of [pick a craft] want Minecraft to become all about whatever that craft is and completely lose sight of the mining aspect of Minecraft or to have that craft overshadow the mining aspect. It should NEVER be more about any [name your craft] than the mining, this is MINECRAFT after all. This is coming from someone that is a supporter of a craft. We're not all crazies who want our craft to take over Minecraft. The [pick a craft] is only a side dish/accent/supporting role/ side attraction to the main event that is Minecraft.
I think that naming a certain idea somethingcraft is giving and spreading a false idea. The false idea that the supports want that [name your craft] to take over the whole game. In truth it's just a group of people that would like to see a bit more content of a certain theme added to accentuate the mining aspect.
For example, I would like to see Volcanic Biomes in Minecraft. I created a thread for this topic here: http://www.minecraftforum.net/viewtopic.php?f=1&t=88973. Notice I did not call the topic VolcanoCraft. I don't want Minecraft to become all about Volcanoes , but I would like to see them in Minecraft. I should still be able to mine the volcano and everywhere else. The volcanoes should only enhance my mining experience not detract from it.
This goes for all [pick your craft]. The moment that [name your craft] becomes more about that craft than the mining, it doesn't belong in Minecraft anymore. It's madness to want Minecraft to be all about farming. If that's what you want you can go play farmville. If you already play farmville good for you. Don't expect me to join you.
Sorry for the long post. I thought someone who supports a [pick your craft] should be allowed to speak on this and show that we're not all nut jobs that want to destroy or ruin Minecraft. We make suggestions because we love Minecraft even if those suggestions are poorly named.
Want some advice on how to thrive in the Suggestions section? Check this handy list of guidelines and tips for posting your ideas and responding to the ideas of others!
http://www.minecraftforum.net/forums/minecraft-discussion/suggestions/2775557-guidelines-for-the-suggestions-forum
I agree with your whole post. I support Farmcraft because I want more food in Minecraft, not just cake, pork, bread and the very rare cookie. I DO NOT want MC to become all about farming. I support Oceancraft because I want more animals in the ocean. I would like more Ores in MC, but not a **** ton. I want more animals, but not a **** ton. I want more plants, but not a **** ton. I want more pictures, but not a **** ton.
But people have their opinions.
Youtube: http://www.youtube.com/user/TheAdamtheClown?feature=mhee
Incompetence is a plague. I am the cure.
For all your wolf suggestion needs, I present the WOLF MEGATHREAD!
Stories: A Miner's Chronicle, The Lost Chronicle [Entries 32-2, 33-1, and 33-2 out!]