yes, a game with metal armour, swords, and the 1st thing every player does is build a castle.
yeaaaaah, totally where the **** would medieval themed elements fit into this game?
That's not what we meant. We meant your suggestion sucked. Not the idea, maybe, but put some effot into it. How is it made? How does it work? Why is it balanced.
Also, the first thing I did wasn't build a castle. You're picking and choosing what you want to talk about to fit your argument.
What would be the use of siege engines when there aren't any armies? The largest group of enemies is a grief of creepers, or maybe that annoying kid that is always on your server who has his own posse.
Also, the first thing I did wasn't build a castle. You're picking and choosing what you want to talk about to fit your argument.
In his defense, anybody would.
But enough about defending him.
The only point to have such things would be in SMP, and only in those large enough to have at least 10vs10 clan wars. That makes it a fairly small target audience, and that is why they won't be added.
i was kinda making a point that THIS SUGGESTION HAS BEEN DONE A MILLION TIMES.
i have been playing since alpha, these ****ing catapult suggestions have been about since ****ing alpha. there are so many siege weapon suggestions on this forum i'm pretty sure if i posted one more it would pop up 'congratulations, this it the 1,000,000th time someone has suggested that'.
i was kinda making a point that THIS SUGGESTION HAS BEEN DONE A MILLION TIMES.
i have been playing since alpha, these ****ing catapult suggestions have been about since ****ing alpha. there are so many siege weapon suggestions on this forum i'm pretty sure if i posted one more it would pop up 'congratulations, this it the 1,000,000th time someone has suggested that'.
i was kinda making a point that THIS SUGGESTION HAS BEEN DONE A MILLION TIMES.
i have been playing since alpha, these ****ing catapult suggestions have been about since ****ing alpha. there are so many siege weapon suggestions on this forum i'm pretty sure if i posted one more it would pop up 'congratulations, this it the 1,000,000th time someone has suggested that'.
So then, you are actually saying that this whole thread is spam? I'm getting an itchy trigger finger. It wants to click my mouse over the report button...
i was kinda making a point that THIS SUGGESTION HAS BEEN DONE A MILLION TIMES.
i have been playing since alpha, these ****ing catapult suggestions have been about since ****ing alpha. there are so many siege weapon suggestions on this forum i'm pretty sure if i posted one more it would pop up 'congratulations, this it the 1,000,000th time someone has suggested that'.
So then, you are actually saying that this whole thread is spam? I'm getting an itchy trigger finger. It wants to click my mouse over the report button...
how about you suck my ball then read the original post.
incase you cant work it out the ****ing thread is asking why the most over done suggestion isn't in yet you dumb ****. I AM NOT SUGGESTING IT AGAIN RETARD.
OP, calm down please. You are encouraging an uneeded and pointless flame war.
The closest thing to siege weapons we have are TNT cannons. How usefull they are varies on how they were built and on where they were built. (Look up 'Minecraft TNT cannon' on youtube. You'll see a lot of different TNT cannons.)
In my opinion, we don't need anything other then that. Balistas/hwatchas/other siege weapons that use arrow-like projectiles = dispenser. They are not very powerfull, but they work. Catapult/cannons/other siege weapons that explode or leave a crater wherever the projectile landed = TNT cannon.
Why not ask the same thing of space travel? Surely THAT is the most posted suggestion yet. Anything related to space, that is. So, yes, why are those not in? Tell me that, OP, please, I would like to know your point of view on them.
::edit::
perhaps i should get more detailed on that.
all you have done is make flippant remarks, try to derail this thread, threaten to report me and misinterpret my posts with such incompetence I pray for your sake that it's deliberate. you have only made ONE post the entire thread that is actually on topic and adds anything to discussion. did you have a laps in concentration and forget to be a tool for two seconds? I'm really surprised you haven't edited that post and corrected it yet.
this isn't flame, this is me saying stop ****ing with this thread. 3 out of 4 posts that you have made here are either advertising some serious attention span problems or are simply trying to troll the hell out of me.
yeah, isn't this thread about suggestions that they should add to minecraft?
well? isn't it? go on, report this thread and ask an admin if asking about elements that are popular suggestions being added counts as a thread about suggestions.
I'm trying very hard right now not to make a personal insult against you.
wow, I remember lurking on this forum during the alpha. i left and missed the part where the petty control freaks took over the forums. however since you were kind enough to invite me to attack you... well I couldn't care less myself, I want to discuss the popular alpha age suggestion of proper siege engines being added to the game.
1) I'm not interested in necroing a thread that is over a year old, that is good cause to be banned in most forums.
2) this thread is specifically talking about suggestions, there is no better place in this forum for this discussion.
3) no, not really. i want a detailed discussion not a twitter spam 'lolz, at catapult to the gamz plox'.
Also don't say I'm just complaining, I started this thread with a valid question capable of reviving a very popular suggestion from a while back that died in favour of 'add the moon notch!'.
now lets actually DISCUSS SOMETHING or we could ***** endlessly for no apparent reason.
wow, I remember lurking on this forum during the alpha. i left and missed the part where the petty control freaks took over the forums. however since you were kind enough to invite me to attack you... well I couldn't care less myself, I want to discuss the popular alpha age suggestion of proper siege engines being added to the game.
1) I'm not interested in necroing a thread that is over a year old, that is good cause to be banned in most forums.
2) this thread is specifically talking about suggestions, there is no better place in this forum for this discussion.
3) no, not really. i want a detailed discussion not a twitter spam 'lolz, at catapult to the gamz plox'.
Also don't say I'm just complaining, I started this thread with a valid question capable of reviving a very popular suggestion from a while back that died in favour of 'add the moon notch!'.
now lets actually DISCUSS SOMETHING or we could ***** endlessly for no apparent reason.
There have been other siege weapons suggestions, just less common and not as well thought out as they used to be. I wouldn't mind a catapult or balista, but in my opinion, it's not needed.
And if you want to discuss a suggestion, why not discuss on a thread where someone actually bothered to think of it? You could make a siege engines threads and you would get much better reactions from the people here. You would get some suggested befores, but if you thought your idea through enough, that shouldn't matter much.
so where are they? why cant we fling TNT across the map? just tell me that, why notch? why? 0_o
Also, where are the SIEGE Engines and WMDs? Irak, most likely. Or in some Age of Empire game, where they belong. Definetly not here.
EDIT:
ninja'd :\
yeaaaaah, totally where the **** would medieval themed elements fit into this game?
That's not what we meant. We meant your suggestion sucked. Not the idea, maybe, but put some effot into it. How is it made? How does it work? Why is it balanced.
Also, the first thing I did wasn't build a castle. You're picking and choosing what you want to talk about to fit your argument.
Not true.
In his defense, anybody would.
But enough about defending him.
The only point to have such things would be in SMP, and only in those large enough to have at least 10vs10 clan wars. That makes it a fairly small target audience, and that is why they won't be added.
Plus, as I said before, cannons.
i have been playing since alpha, these ****ing catapult suggestions have been about since ****ing alpha. there are so many siege weapon suggestions on this forum i'm pretty sure if i posted one more it would pop up 'congratulations, this it the 1,000,000th time someone has suggested that'.
Don't you mean 12,000,000th?
So then, you are actually saying that this whole thread is spam? I'm getting an itchy trigger finger. It wants to click my mouse over the report button...
how about you suck my ball then read the original post.
incase you cant work it out the ****ing thread is asking why the most over done suggestion isn't in yet you dumb ****. I AM NOT SUGGESTING IT AGAIN RETARD.
was that clear enough?
User warned for flame.
The closest thing to siege weapons we have are TNT cannons. How usefull they are varies on how they were built and on where they were built. (Look up 'Minecraft TNT cannon' on youtube. You'll see a lot of different TNT cannons.)
In my opinion, we don't need anything other then that. Balistas/hwatchas/other siege weapons that use arrow-like projectiles = dispenser. They are not very powerfull, but they work. Catapult/cannons/other siege weapons that explode or leave a crater wherever the projectile landed = TNT cannon.
Taming Spiders!
My Suggestions on Goblin Villages
::edit::
perhaps i should get more detailed on that.
all you have done is make flippant remarks, try to derail this thread, threaten to report me and misinterpret my posts with such incompetence I pray for your sake that it's deliberate. you have only made ONE post the entire thread that is actually on topic and adds anything to discussion. did you have a laps in concentration and forget to be a tool for two seconds? I'm really surprised you haven't edited that post and corrected it yet.
this isn't flame, this is me saying stop ****ing with this thread. 3 out of 4 posts that you have made here are either advertising some serious attention span problems or are simply trying to troll the hell out of me.
well? isn't it? go on, report this thread and ask an admin if asking about elements that are popular suggestions being added counts as a thread about suggestions.
I'm trying very hard right now not to make a personal insult against you.
1) I'm not interested in necroing a thread that is over a year old, that is good cause to be banned in most forums.
2) this thread is specifically talking about suggestions, there is no better place in this forum for this discussion.
3) no, not really. i want a detailed discussion not a twitter spam 'lolz, at catapult to the gamz plox'.
Also don't say I'm just complaining, I started this thread with a valid question capable of reviving a very popular suggestion from a while back that died in favour of 'add the moon notch!'.
now lets actually DISCUSS SOMETHING or we could ***** endlessly for no apparent reason.
There have been other siege weapons suggestions, just less common and not as well thought out as they used to be. I wouldn't mind a catapult or balista, but in my opinion, it's not needed.
And if you want to discuss a suggestion, why not discuss on a thread where someone actually bothered to think of it? You could make a siege engines threads and you would get much better reactions from the people here. You would get some suggested befores, but if you thought your idea through enough, that shouldn't matter much.