I love how you just expect everyone to come and listen to your whining. Nobody cares, honestly, the time I took to write this, was the time I took taking a ****. Opinions are like assholes, everybody has one. Don't force an opinion on anybody else, they may think differently, which they can. This thread is merely implying that any suggestions we post about an RPG is invalid in the terms of an opinion by a mere ignorant little girl. Try harder.
#1. I like listing things, so I'm gonna list some stuff
#2. These aren't just a "Little" girl's Opinion, these are multiple peoples opinions, and I'm pretty sure most people will value just her opinion over a 5:1 Ratio if you and your friends are 5, but we have more or less a 1:2 Ratio (you always being the left)
#3. These "Facts" are applying to MOST of the redundant RPG Threads that pop up saying, we should have a leveling system where we can only use wood tools at level 1 and then at level 5 you can use Stone tools and etc., etc., morebullshit., morebullshit. or we should have 1Googleplex more weapons that are all reskinned swords with different stat tweaks, Or a bunch of Requests for Realistic from people who aren't codders
I think you should be happy we have less RPG Spam
I can tell you right now, that if you want those things, go find levelcraft, download Balkons weapon mod and download Millenaire, you should be set until the next patch/update
#4. Of course these are hyperboles
I think it had done a pretty good job doing so since I haven't seen any RPG threads like these popping up
Quote from peu »
this post is so goddamn funny, but that's just my opinion
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
These guys make awesome art for Mods (Items, New Blocks and Mobs)
I will be using them soon
I'm Starting to be known as a Balancer, A.K.A. I'm starting to become pessimist
I love how you just expect everyone to come and listen to your whining. Nobody cares, honestly, the time I took to write this, was the time I took taking a ****. Opinions are like assholes, everybody has one. Don't force an opinion on anybody else, they may think differently, which they can. This thread is merely implying that any suggestions we post about an RPG is invalid in the terms of an opinion by a mere ignorant little girl. Try harder.
#1. I like listing things, so I'm gonna list some stuff
#2. These aren't just a "Little" girl's Opinion, these are multiple peoples opinions, and I'm pretty sure most people will value just her opinion over a 5:1 Ratio if you and your friends are 5, but we have more or less a 1:2 Ratio (you always being the left)
#3. These "Facts" are applying to MOST of the redundant RPG Threads that pop up saying, we should have a leveling system where we can only use wood tools at level 1 and then at level 5 you can use Stone tools and etc., etc., morebullshit., morebullshit. or we should have 1Googleplex more weapons that are all reskinned swords with different stat tweaks, Or a bunch of Requests for Realistic from people who aren't codders
I think you should be happy we have less RPG Spam
I can tell you right now, that if you want those things, go find levelcraft, download Balkons weapon mod and download Millenaire, you should be set until the next patch/update
#4. Of course these are hyperboles
I think it had done a pretty good job doing so since I haven't seen any RPG threads like these popping up
Quote from peu »
this post is so goddamn funny, but that's just my opinion
Obviously those other people who agree with her didn't take the time to whine about it either. So it must not be as important as you may think. Also, the spam about RPG's isn't up to you or anyone else besides Notch himself, and the staff he has chosen to moderate these forums. If he had chosen you to do so, I'd appreciate it, but, seeing as he has not, anything you say or do contains no merit or point. Get over it, find something new to do other than whine about there being RPG threads. You will soon find out that most of the people on this game are willing to do such a change, only a minority don't want it. There are way more important suggestions/information threads than this, which should be stickied.
I love how you just expect everyone to come and listen to your whining. Nobody cares, honestly, the time I took to write this, was the time I took taking a ****. Opinions are like assholes, everybody has one. Don't force an opinion on anybody else, they may think differently, which they can. This thread is merely implying that any suggestions we post about an RPG is invalid in the terms of an opinion by a mere ignorant little girl. Try harder.
#1. I like listing things, so I'm gonna list some stuff
#2. These aren't just a "Little" girl's Opinion, these are multiple peoples opinions, and I'm pretty sure most people will value just her opinion over a 5:1 Ratio if you and your friends are 5, but we have more or less a 1:2 Ratio (you always being the left)
#3. These "Facts" are applying to MOST of the redundant RPG Threads that pop up saying, we should have a leveling system where we can only use wood tools at level 1 and then at level 5 you can use Stone tools and etc., etc., morebullshit., morebullshit. or we should have 1Googleplex more weapons that are all reskinned swords with different stat tweaks, Or a bunch of Requests for Realistic from people who aren't codders
I think you should be happy we have less RPG Spam
I can tell you right now, that if you want those things, go find levelcraft, download Balkons weapon mod and download Millenaire, you should be set until the next patch/update
#4. Of course these are hyperboles
I think it had done a pretty good job doing so since I haven't seen any RPG threads like these popping up
Quote from peu »
this post is so goddamn funny, but that's just my opinion
Obviously those other people who agree with her didn't take the time to whine about it either. So it must not be as important as you may think. Also, the spam about RPG's isn't up to you or anyone else besides Notch himself, and the staff he has chosen to moderate these forums. If he had chosen you to do so, I'd appreciate it, but, seeing as he has not, anything you say or do contains no merit or point. Get over it, find something new to do other than whine about there being RPG threads. You will soon find out that most of the people on this game are willing to do such a change, only a minority don't want it. There are way more important suggestions/information threads than this, which should be stickied.
Notch does not want to make Minecraft an RPG, and this sticky says why. The majority of the people who play Minecraft do not want a change, and want to keep it a sandbox game. This is a very important thread that tells people why their RPG ideas will not work for Minecraft, thus removing stupid, unneeded, already made suggestions.
Notch does not want to make Minecraft an RPG, and this sticky says why. The majority of the people who play Minecraft do not want a change, and want to keep it a sandbox game. This is a very important thread that tells people why their RPG ideas will not work for Minecraft, thus removing stupid, unneeded, already made suggestions.
Notch has never said that he didn't want an RPG, so therefore, you are incorrect. A Role Playing Game is simply a mode where a role is given, and you must play that roles. I personally don't care what he does to the game, its his game. But, if he implemented an RPG system, I wouldn't care, it'd only be better than what it is now. I don't understand why people should just sit around complaining about it, if the suggestion is about RPG's, and it is a bad one, let the Moderators/Administrators handle it.
#1. The people that took the time to agree with her and support her, will fall into the General Categorie :
- Someone who likes Minecraft the way it is, withouth this stuff
- Someone who understands what Minecraft is about and basically is more intelligent then the first
- Is someone who is sick and tired of seeing redundant RPG ideas in the forum, and is thankful that we will have to explain the general reasons why, less often
- Is someone who is sick and tired of seeing redundant RPG ideas that do not fit Minecraft Vanilla
#2. So you want specifically someone chosen to do the job, when there is almost no one to do the job?
Think of this as a Lack of official workers and some people are taking the Lead, I am not, I'm just reinforcing this, a meer labour worker
#3. we will be getting Moderators soon enough, soon after we make the switch
#4. It's up to Notch and the people who he let's moderate these forums? I think, if Notch roamed these forums, he would be thankful for less spam of RPG threads, you can even go ask him on twitter, doubt he will respond with anything useful, (this is really badly written I know, sorry, It's just late)
#5. Yeah cause Notch is really gonna choose me? Notch doesn't have time to moderate these forums, so he choose Curse (People with Pink Names) to be "Everything (Moderator of the who Site, Who Decides Almost Everything)" and they choose people in Yellow to be "Sectional Admins" and people in red to be "Site Admins", so technically you would only be happy if Criticsquid himself told you something like this, and the Words I say contain no value, no point?
Well that is a bit ignorant, but I see where you are coming from, since I did not create the game,
My Words don't have any value or merrit of what can't be implemented and what can,
But some of us know how Minecraft works and gets people, with it's Innovative style of gameplay and simplicity, yes Minecraft has potential for amazing RPGs, but in my Opinion keep it out of Vanilla
#6. I am not whining about being RPG threads, I'm "Whining" about the Bad RPG threads, the ones that we can all agree (most of us anyways) that they are game breaking and some times, literally stupid, this here was stickied so we don't find as much already posted threads that are against the rules to do, since this has gone up, I think it has done it's job of making less Already Suggested Mirror Threads
#7. Most people would be happy to go through a change where Minecraft Survival becomes Minecraft RPG?...some people wouldn't mind, but some people wouldn't update Minecraft anymore...if you know what I mean
#8. Can you please Name the informative threads that need or should be stickied instead of this one? and is the title blunt or attractive enough that it gets the attention of the people who are about to post? would it be able to be changed to do so?
Please list them, and I'll give you my (so called) "worthless" Opinions on them
P.S. It's rare to see a suggestive thread for Minecraft to get stickied, So far there has only been 1 (Since I've been here) good luck actually finding one that all (or atleast 99%) of the Minecraft Public + Mods and that makes sense and etc.
Quote from GmZ »
Quote from Mr_Spandexpants »
Notch does not want to make Minecraft an RPG, and this sticky says why. The majority of the people who play Minecraft do not want a change, and want to keep it a sandbox game. This is a very important thread that tells people why their RPG ideas will not work for Minecraft, thus removing stupid, unneeded, already made suggestions.
Notch has never said that he didn't want an RPG, so therefore, you are incorrect. A Role Playing Game is simply a mode where a role is given, and you must play that roles. I personally don't care what he does to the game, its his game. But, if he implemented an RPG system, I wouldn't care, it'd only be better than what it is now. I don't understand why people should just sit around complaining about it
You know that is the Real Description of an RPG, but you also know what kind of RPG this is talking about, (Minecraft is technically an RPG since I'm playing the role of Steve)
if the suggestion is about RPG's, and it is a bad one, let the Moderators/Administrators handle it.
I now think you have no idea how the suggestion forum works, do you?
It works by Everyday people, suggestion ideas and then other people, criticising, trolling, improving and building upon said idea, saying let the mods handle it is really not-smart since they aren't always on and like us, they have a life (+ you don't see a lot of suggestion thread moderators for some reason)
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
These guys make awesome art for Mods (Items, New Blocks and Mobs)
I will be using them soon
I'm Starting to be known as a Balancer, A.K.A. I'm starting to become pessimist
This is great, I hope everyone is convinced now that RPG elements and advanced ideas should not be implemented into Minecraft and the game should stay raw. I wish Notch would add some more simple blocks and items to the game. I need stuff to do :smile.gif:)
Check out the Wubcraft server. It has the answer to all the problems in your post visit www.wubcraft.dk to get whitelisted and see what i am talking about
Minecraft = Sandbox
meaning do anything you want thats not linear. If i want to play a role i use a mod to suit how i want it . Mine craft can be changed to want you want, the issues you raise are just logical issues that can be sorted out with a structured system. Say we make a main thread which has a mod for currency, Everyone gets the code of the currency and can adapt it with modloader to use in their mod, Like mergeing IC , Bluiders and Millnere cash to one type of currency would be so much better With more structure all those issues you raise can be solved.
Also, to those who think you cannot do a roleplaying game in minecraft without mods...
I've successfully Played a roleplaying game in HALO REACH.
HALO REACH DAMMIT.
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
Paranoid: Moderate. Schizoid: Moderate. Schizotypal: High. Antisocial: Low. Borderline: Low. Histrionic: Moderate. Narcissistic: Moderate. Avoidant: Moderate. Dependent: Moderate. Obsessive-Compulsive: High. Does this make me nuts?
Also, to those who think you cannot do a roleplaying game in minecraft without mods...
I've successfully Played a roleplaying game in HALO REACH.
HALO REACH DAMMIT.
Dude, I think we get the whole aspect of your super special "role" playing gamestyle and how you can apply it to ****ing everything ever. Can you get over it already, because apparently your super special awesome role playing style is perfect, revolutionary, unfallable and infinitely adaptable, and has nothing to do with this topic since it most likely uses none of the game engine systems that are being addressed?
Jesus ****ing christ. For 3 whole pages you have been dragging on and on about this special "I am playing the role of whatever the **** I want in any world I desire at any timeline I wish" Role Playing system, and I think you have conveyed, with your first post in this thread, that this is not addressing the role playing system you are thinking of.
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
Trollcalling is the act of trying to convince other users that a poster is a troll and/or accusing other users of being trolls. This is a bannable offense. Please report trolling, do not advertise it or react to it.
It's a New Genra of Game, What I'd call it is Sandbox/Adventure
Quote from Steeley »
What type of game is minecraf then?
FPS? No, only 1 weapon that fires
Platformer? Nope
puzzle? Get real
action? No
survival? You have to consider the creative and resources side
RPG? Yes! You play the role of someone stranded trying to survive while farming and mining! Not all RPGs involve turns, minecraft is an RPG what you don't want is a action RPG like Final Famtasy or Oblivion which is understandable as that would require a residing of the entire minecraft system, it would work with the block idea but it would have to be controlled, so you couldn't break down all buildings.
It's a New Genra of Game (It made up a new kind of Genra), What I'd call it is Sandbox/Adventure
Quote from Steeley »
TLDR (too long, didn't read) minecrafts an RPG, word your comments better please.
...dude, it had TLDRs (I don't even know what that word means, someone elaborate), and please read the OP Before posting, like you should do, is that even a rule?
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
These guys make awesome art for Mods (Items, New Blocks and Mobs)
I will be using them soon
I'm Starting to be known as a Balancer, A.K.A. I'm starting to become pessimist
About the different weapons, why have notch code pointless stuff like that when they COULD make flying mounts dragons,mobs, blocks, and different plants other than wheat. Wouldnt you rather have all that than a dagger, a shurken, a war hammer, throwing knifes, and so on.
#1. I like listing things, so I'm gonna list some stuff
#2. These aren't just a "Little" girl's Opinion, these are multiple peoples opinions, and I'm pretty sure most people will value just her opinion over a 5:1 Ratio if you and your friends are 5, but we have more or less a 1:2 Ratio (you always being the left)
#3. These "Facts" are applying to MOST of the redundant RPG Threads that pop up saying, we should have a leveling system where we can only use wood tools at level 1 and then at level 5 you can use Stone tools and etc., etc., morebullshit., morebullshit. or we should have 1Googleplex more weapons that are all reskinned swords with different stat tweaks, Or a bunch of Requests for Realistic from people who aren't codders
I think you should be happy we have less RPG Spam
I can tell you right now, that if you want those things, go find levelcraft, download Balkons weapon mod and download Millenaire, you should be set until the next patch/update
#4. Of course these are hyperboles
I think it had done a pretty good job doing so since I haven't seen any RPG threads like these popping up
I will be using them soon
I'm Starting to be known as a Balancer, A.K.A. I'm starting to become pessimist
Obviously those other people who agree with her didn't take the time to whine about it either. So it must not be as important as you may think. Also, the spam about RPG's isn't up to you or anyone else besides Notch himself, and the staff he has chosen to moderate these forums. If he had chosen you to do so, I'd appreciate it, but, seeing as he has not, anything you say or do contains no merit or point. Get over it, find something new to do other than whine about there being RPG threads. You will soon find out that most of the people on this game are willing to do such a change, only a minority don't want it. There are way more important suggestions/information threads than this, which should be stickied.
Notch does not want to make Minecraft an RPG, and this sticky says why. The majority of the people who play Minecraft do not want a change, and want to keep it a sandbox game. This is a very important thread that tells people why their RPG ideas will not work for Minecraft, thus removing stupid, unneeded, already made suggestions.
Notch has never said that he didn't want an RPG, so therefore, you are incorrect. A Role Playing Game is simply a mode where a role is given, and you must play that roles. I personally don't care what he does to the game, its his game. But, if he implemented an RPG system, I wouldn't care, it'd only be better than what it is now. I don't understand why people should just sit around complaining about it, if the suggestion is about RPG's, and it is a bad one, let the Moderators/Administrators handle it.
- Someone who likes Minecraft the way it is, withouth this stuff
- Someone who understands what Minecraft is about and basically is more intelligent then the first
- Is someone who is sick and tired of seeing redundant RPG ideas in the forum, and is thankful that we will have to explain the general reasons why, less often
- Is someone who is sick and tired of seeing redundant RPG ideas that do not fit Minecraft Vanilla
#2. So you want specifically someone chosen to do the job, when there is almost no one to do the job?
Think of this as a Lack of official workers and some people are taking the Lead, I am not, I'm just reinforcing this, a meer labour worker
#3. we will be getting Moderators soon enough, soon after we make the switch
#4. It's up to Notch and the people who he let's moderate these forums? I think, if Notch roamed these forums, he would be thankful for less spam of RPG threads, you can even go ask him on twitter, doubt he will respond with anything useful, (this is really badly written I know, sorry, It's just late)
#5. Yeah cause Notch is really gonna choose me? Notch doesn't have time to moderate these forums, so he choose Curse (People with Pink Names) to be "Everything (Moderator of the who Site, Who Decides Almost Everything)" and they choose people in Yellow to be "Sectional Admins" and people in red to be "Site Admins", so technically you would only be happy if Criticsquid himself told you something like this, and the Words I say contain no value, no point?
Well that is a bit ignorant, but I see where you are coming from, since I did not create the game,
My Words don't have any value or merrit of what can't be implemented and what can,
But some of us know how Minecraft works and gets people, with it's Innovative style of gameplay and simplicity, yes Minecraft has potential for amazing RPGs, but in my Opinion keep it out of Vanilla
#6. I am not whining about being RPG threads, I'm "Whining" about the Bad RPG threads, the ones that we can all agree (most of us anyways) that they are game breaking and some times, literally stupid, this here was stickied so we don't find as much already posted threads that are against the rules to do, since this has gone up, I think it has done it's job of making less Already Suggested Mirror Threads
#7. Most people would be happy to go through a change where Minecraft Survival becomes Minecraft RPG?...some people wouldn't mind, but some people wouldn't update Minecraft anymore...if you know what I mean
#8. Can you please Name the informative threads that need or should be stickied instead of this one? and is the title blunt or attractive enough that it gets the attention of the people who are about to post? would it be able to be changed to do so?
Please list them, and I'll give you my (so called) "worthless" Opinions on them
P.S. It's rare to see a suggestive thread for Minecraft to get stickied, So far there has only been 1 (Since I've been here) good luck actually finding one that all (or atleast 99%) of the Minecraft Public + Mods and that makes sense and etc.
You know that is the Real Description of an RPG, but you also know what kind of RPG this is talking about, (Minecraft is technically an RPG since I'm playing the role of Steve)
I now think you have no idea how the suggestion forum works, do you?
It works by Everyday people, suggestion ideas and then other people, criticising, trolling, improving and building upon said idea, saying let the mods handle it is really not-smart since they aren't always on and like us, they have a life (+ you don't see a lot of suggestion thread moderators for some reason)
I will be using them soon
I'm Starting to be known as a Balancer, A.K.A. I'm starting to become pessimist
Say hello to Terraria
I will be using them soon
I'm Starting to be known as a Balancer, A.K.A. I'm starting to become pessimist
Not an RPG
It's minecraft.
In 2D.
With awesome stuff.
Do want.
I will be using them soon
I'm Starting to be known as a Balancer, A.K.A. I'm starting to become pessimist
I don't think it is REALLY REALLY 2D minecraft, I just call it that for ease.
I will be using them soon
I'm Starting to be known as a Balancer, A.K.A. I'm starting to become pessimist
Minecraft = Sandbox
meaning do anything you want thats not linear. If i want to play a role i use a mod to suit how i want it . Mine craft can be changed to want you want, the issues you raise are just logical issues that can be sorted out with a structured system. Say we make a main thread which has a mod for currency, Everyone gets the code of the currency and can adapt it with modloader to use in their mod, Like mergeing IC , Bluiders and Millnere cash to one type of currency would be so much better With more structure all those issues you raise can be solved.
I've successfully Played a roleplaying game in HALO REACH.
HALO REACH DAMMIT.
Dude, I think we get the whole aspect of your super special "role" playing gamestyle and how you can apply it to ****ing everything ever. Can you get over it already, because apparently your super special awesome role playing style is perfect, revolutionary, unfallable and infinitely adaptable, and has nothing to do with this topic since it most likely uses none of the game engine systems that are being addressed?
Jesus ****ing christ. For 3 whole pages you have been dragging on and on about this special "I am playing the role of whatever the **** I want in any world I desire at any timeline I wish" Role Playing system, and I think you have conveyed, with your first post in this thread, that this is not addressing the role playing system you are thinking of.
It's a New Genra of Game (It made up a new kind of Genra), What I'd call it is Sandbox/Adventure
...dude, it had TLDRs (I don't even know what that word means, someone elaborate), and please read the OP Before posting, like you should do, is that even a rule?
I will be using them soon
I'm Starting to be known as a Balancer, A.K.A. I'm starting to become pessimist