When I started this, I never thought I would get much feedback or appreciation. Thanks so much, guys!
You put forth the effort and in turn make a great suggestion that adds diversity to an existing part of the game which fits perfectly while mitigating a primary problem that many players have? You're bound to get such a reply... you definitely deserve it
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
“You have made a place in my heart where I thought there was no room for anything else. You have made flowers grow where I cultivated dust and stones." - al'Lan Mandragoran
"Sene sovya caba'donde ain dovienya" - Matrim Cauthon
I like this! But we don't need the facial hair, sure it's possible for a woman to have facial hair but I think it's best to leave the facial hair out.
Mostly support!
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
I made a Feed The Beast modpack! Simply type "Experiment812390" without quotes into the 3rD party codes area and you can see the mods list and install!
Don't be a pedant, or take things out of context on purpose.
"don't quote yourself in your signature it makes you look silly" ~ Oden_The_Fish
#Baum4God
my profile picture is the A-10 thunderbolt II the successor of the first thunderbolt used in WWII by the USAF both excel in air support and ground attacks
the A-10 also sports the GAU-8 Avenger a 30MM hydraulic gatling type autocannon
The Meaning of Life, the Universe, and Everything.
Join Date:
7/20/2015
Posts:
150
Location:
The Dark Side
Minecraft:
Don't You Want To Know?
Member Details
Very detailed, and i think this is a very good idea to start off with. Not only will it be easier to find who your trading with, but now each villager looks 'special' as in they all look different.
Support
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
I miss missing you now and then Sometimes before it gets better The darkness gets bigger The person that you’d take a bullet for is behind the trigger Oh We’re fading fast I miss missing you now and then
I kind of like it, but it's almost too diverse and complex. Not that it would be hard to do, but something that was always charming about villagers to me was that they were all similar. They were like a bunch of little creatures "hmm"ing around the village doing nothing. Diversity isn't bad, but conformity is what makes the villagers in minecraft kind of iconic and unique.
Also, you also said that with Alex in the game, gender is now a thing. That's not really true for mobs. If you count a skin as gender, then it was added long ago with female skins. As of right now, there is no difference between males and females in minecraft, and adding eyelashes to make them seem female seems a little pointless, considering having males and females changes nothing. Also, adding males and females in the game besides skins could create some problems. Yeah, probably just dumb people getting offended for no reason, but I have a feeling Mojang is trying to stay far away from problems, which is probably why they haven't added genders.
I like the overall idea of diversity, but going too far, like into adding genders could cause some probably, and I don't think is a good idea. However, I do very much commend you on the post itself. It's very well done.
Even though you can already differentiate villages with name tags, but they are hard to obtain, This is a very good suggestion and would bring more diversity in villages and give them an additional level of customisation with addition to clothing.
Yes, it would add much more diversity if villagers had different races just like humans in real life. You could finally know which villager you want to trade with as well. Unless the place is filled with the same villagers. I feel like it would be more realistic as well. Since horses, rabbits and sheep have different colours, I think it'd be a great addition to add different races in villagers. The only thing we'd need to add next is different breeds of cattle, dog, and pigs. Full support.
Edit: Why don't villagers have brown eyes? Seeing that it is the most common eye color in the world it'd make sense for the villagers to inherit brown eyes.
A God that holds you over the pit of Hell, much as one holds a spider or some loathsome insect over the fire, abhors you, and is dreadfully provoked. - Jonathan Edwards
Yes, it would add much more diversity if villagers had different races just like humans in real life. You could finally know which villager you want to trade with as well. Unless the place is filled with the same villagers. I feel like it would be more realistic as well. Since horses, rabbits and sheep have different colours, I think it'd be a great addition to add different races in villagers. The only thing we'd need to add next is different breeds of cattle, dog, and pigs. Full support.
Edit: Why don't villagers have brown eyes? Seeing that it is the most common eye color in the world it'd make sense for the villagers to inherit brown eyes.
There are brown eyes. I called them Hazel because I can't tell the difference between Hazel and brown. Thanks for the support!
This idea would be very helpful with finding that one Villager with that cheap trade, and add some diversity to Villages instead of seeing all those Villager clones walking around. About the only problem is that the facial hair undermines the concept of them being gender neutral, and adding female Villagers wouldn't be a good idea. But I see no proper way to fix this without reworking the entire idea, but the idea itself I enjoy.
What if one parent had dark skin and the other had pale skin? Would the child be tan?
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
A God that holds you over the pit of Hell, much as one holds a spider or some loathsome insect over the fire, abhors you, and is dreadfully provoked. - Jonathan Edwards
I don't think genetics works that way. I'm not an expert, so I may be wrong, but I'm pretty sure genetics doesn't come up with middle grounds from parents.
Support, this seems like a good idea. The only issue I have is that it kind of hurts the androgyny of the villagers, which is present in just about every mob in the game including themselves. Mojang seem quite strictly against giving mobs genders, and these villagers seem very masculine for the most part.
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
Formerly Gamelord. Pixelmon Server Owner. Server IP: pixelmonprisma.mc-server.net | Server Discord:https://discord.gg/HkK855b
I don't think genetics works that way. I'm not an expert, so I may be wrong, but I'm pretty sure genetics doesn't come up with middle grounds from parents.
Support, this seems like a good idea. The only issue I have is that it kind of hurts the androgyny of the villagers, which is present in just about every mob in the game including themselves. Mojang seem quite strictly against giving mobs genders, and these villagers seem very masculine for the most part.
As much as I agree with you, there's no way to diversify without implying gender in some way. Facial hair adds a lot of diversity that otherwise wouldn't be there but also implies that they are men.
In my defense, Men can have eyelashes too, and Women sometimes have facial hair. After all, this is the primitive land of Minecraft. No way to shave. Cows in Minecraft have masculine and feminine features, such as horns and udders.
When I started this, I never thought I would get much feedback or appreciation. Thanks so much, guys!
You put forth the effort and in turn make a great suggestion that adds diversity to an existing part of the game which fits perfectly while mitigating a primary problem that many players have? You're bound to get such a reply... you definitely deserve it
I like this! But we don't need the facial hair, sure it's possible for a woman to have facial hair but I think it's best to leave the facial hair out.
Mostly support!
I made a Feed The Beast modpack! Simply type "Experiment812390" without quotes into the 3rD party codes area and you can see the mods list and install!
Don't be a pedant, or take things out of context on purpose.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Oden so what I'm soup? Fish soup?
"don't quote yourself in your signature it makes you look silly" ~ Oden_The_Fish
#Baum4God
my profile picture is the A-10 thunderbolt II the successor of the first thunderbolt used in WWII by the USAF both excel in air support and ground attacks
the A-10 also sports the GAU-8 Avenger a 30MM hydraulic gatling type autocannon
OHHH U FELL FOR IT! OOOOOHHH
More complex villagers? That's a great idea! Maximum Support!
Current avatar: Ralsei from Deltarune.
Not to subtle. But not to much.
THE SUPPORT IS OFF THE CHARTS!
"In my experience there's no such thing as luck."
Very detailed, and i think this is a very good idea to start off with. Not only will it be easier to find who your trading with, but now each villager looks 'special' as in they all look different.
Support
I miss missing you now and then
Sometimes before it gets better
The darkness gets bigger
The person that you’d take a bullet for is behind the trigger
Oh
We’re fading fast
I miss missing you now and then
~Miss Missing You by Fall Out Boy
I kind of like it, but it's almost too diverse and complex. Not that it would be hard to do, but something that was always charming about villagers to me was that they were all similar. They were like a bunch of little creatures "hmm"ing around the village doing nothing. Diversity isn't bad, but conformity is what makes the villagers in minecraft kind of iconic and unique.
Also, you also said that with Alex in the game, gender is now a thing. That's not really true for mobs. If you count a skin as gender, then it was added long ago with female skins. As of right now, there is no difference between males and females in minecraft, and adding eyelashes to make them seem female seems a little pointless, considering having males and females changes nothing. Also, adding males and females in the game besides skins could create some problems. Yeah, probably just dumb people getting offended for no reason, but I have a feeling Mojang is trying to stay far away from problems, which is probably why they haven't added genders.
I like the overall idea of diversity, but going too far, like into adding genders could cause some probably, and I don't think is a good idea. However, I do very much commend you on the post itself. It's very well done.
Partial Support.
Please read these two threads:
http://www.minecraftforum.net/forums/minecraft-discussion/suggestions/2572194-please-read-this-before-making-a-suggestion-v2-0
http://www.minecraftforum.net/forums/minecraft-discussion/suggestions/44180-for-the-critics-ftc
Suhport. Now I can have more realistic cities.
I just took the Minecraft Noob test! Check out what I scored. Think you can beat me?!
To take the test, check out
http://minecraftnoobtest.com/test.php
War, war never changes.
The Beginning.
http://technoterra.myminicity.com
Even though you can already differentiate villages with name tags, but they are hard to obtain, This is a very good suggestion and would bring more diversity in villages and give them an additional level of customisation with addition to clothing.
Support.
This is the best suggestion I have seen. Star rating can go past the max if it is good enough so 100/10
They need to hatch, pls click them! *shows eggs* they need atleast 400 clicks in a few days to hatch. Support them.. Click them all
Thank you good sir. For your support I have clicked your eggs.
Yes, it would add much more diversity if villagers had different races just like humans in real life. You could finally know which villager you want to trade with as well. Unless the place is filled with the same villagers. I feel like it would be more realistic as well. Since horses, rabbits and sheep have different colours, I think it'd be a great addition to add different races in villagers. The only thing we'd need to add next is different breeds of cattle, dog, and pigs. Full support.
Edit: Why don't villagers have brown eyes? Seeing that it is the most common eye color in the world it'd make sense for the villagers to inherit brown eyes.
A God that holds you over the pit of Hell, much as one holds a spider or some loathsome insect over the fire, abhors you, and is dreadfully provoked. - Jonathan Edwards
There are brown eyes. I called them Hazel because I can't tell the difference between Hazel and brown.
Thanks for the support!
Ohhhhh. Oops. I should fix that.
#SkunkTheIdiot
This idea would be very helpful with finding that one Villager with that cheap trade, and add some diversity to Villages instead of seeing all those Villager clones walking around. About the only problem is that the facial hair undermines the concept of them being gender neutral, and adding female Villagers wouldn't be a good idea. But I see no proper way to fix this without reworking the entire idea, but the idea itself I enjoy.
Partial Support
What if one parent had dark skin and the other had pale skin? Would the child be tan?
A God that holds you over the pit of Hell, much as one holds a spider or some loathsome insect over the fire, abhors you, and is dreadfully provoked. - Jonathan Edwards
Hmm. I didn't think of that. Yeah, I guess.
I don't think genetics works that way. I'm not an expert, so I may be wrong, but I'm pretty sure genetics doesn't come up with middle grounds from parents.
Support, this seems like a good idea. The only issue I have is that it kind of hurts the androgyny of the villagers, which is present in just about every mob in the game including themselves. Mojang seem quite strictly against giving mobs genders, and these villagers seem very masculine for the most part.
Nice Work! I hope this gets noticed!
As much as I agree with you, there's no way to diversify without implying gender in some way. Facial hair adds a lot of diversity that otherwise wouldn't be there but also implies that they are men.
In my defense, Men can have eyelashes too, and Women sometimes have facial hair. After all, this is the primitive land of Minecraft. No way to shave. Cows in Minecraft have masculine and feminine features, such as horns and udders.