someone else had posted this very same suggestion on Get Satisfaction some 2 months ago... i've gone through and read there post, and im convinced ours is better. Just not to sure how to show that to the moderators there.
I've filed a dispute and i guess we'll find out what happens =/
Same happened to my foodcraft topic :sad.gif:
All the other topics on food are one paragraph imageless posts with a lower quality, and they deleted mine :sad.gif:
Good Luck with the topic :biggrin.gif:
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
When people ask you to have an open mind, they are actually telling you to "stop believing what you believe," and to "start believing what I believe."
History never repeats itself. Events never happen twice.
someone else had posted this very same suggestion on Get Satisfaction some 2 months ago... i've gone through and read there post, and im convinced ours is better. Just not to sure how to show that to the moderators there.
I've filed a dispute and i guess we'll find out what happens =/
Same happened to my foodcraft topic :sad.gif:
All the other topics on food are one paragraph imageless posts with a lower quality, and they deleted mine :sad.gif:
Good Luck with the topic :biggrin.gif:
thats horrible... They shouldn't take 'who comes first' over quality... but i guess its more or less just the 'suggestion' Mojang will need... the rest they'll work out on their own.
But still, two (or more) similar topics can decide rather the implementation of the concept will turn out for better or for worse. Quality should still have a say in the matter, and that's what im determined to get the moderators at Get Satisfaction to notice. Just need to figure out 'how' ...
EDIT: in the end... if these grates get implemented regardless who's suggestion takes the credit. We'll still profit... i can't help but feel this is my fault though... i should have done more research before i posted this and got everyone involved in the effort.
Is this a necro yet?
either way I want people to see this.
The only way this will die out is if it gets implemented, or if Notch himself says it should. Until then im going to keep trying. To much went into this from many people for me to just up and let it die out like this..
Is this a necro yet?
either way I want people to see this.
The only way this will die out is if it gets implemented, or if Notch himself says it should. Until then im going to keep trying. To much went into this from many people for me to just up and let it die out like this..
I would agree with this thread surviving awhile. However, I also run a thread that I have put a few days total into, and is widely agreed upon. The issue being, once everyone says they enjoy the idea, there is nothing left to say, and the thread drops in the list. However, I support this until it dies a horrible death of implementation (because I don't think there is another way for this to die unless Notch clearly states this idea is not Minecraft worthy).
TL;DR: You missed nothing
PS: The OP could use another organization, with sections (description, purpose, graphics, redstone, support...etc). Right now it still seems a bit messy and unpolished. Just my 2 cents.
Is this a necro yet?
either way I want people to see this.
The only way this will die out is if it gets implemented, or if Notch himself says it should. Until then im going to keep trying. To much went into this from many people for me to just up and let it die out like this..
I would agree with this thread surviving awhile. However, I also run a thread that I have put a few days total into, and is widely agreed upon. The issue being, once everyone says they enjoy the idea, there is nothing left to say, and the thread drops in the list. However, I support this until it dies a horrible death of implementation (because I don't think there is another way for this to die unless Notch clearly states this idea is not Minecraft worthy).
TL;DR: You missed nothing
PS: The OP could use another organization, with sections (description, purpose, graphics, redstone, support...etc). Right now it still seems a bit messy and unpolished. Just my 2 cents.
I agree with landmine. A revamp of the OP would do wonders to the topic.
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
When people ask you to have an open mind, they are actually telling you to "stop believing what you believe," and to "start believing what I believe."
History never repeats itself. Events never happen twice.
Okay so this is how believe the grate would generally work.
*You can see through it from either angle.
*Fluids can easily fall through it.
*If an enemy like a skeleton is below it can shoot at you through it and you can too.
*Items as well can fall through it.
*When walked on makes a metal sound.
and pretty much this. Hopefully this does get introduced as I can see it as a great asset and if not a necessity for the game.
I agree with landmine. A revamp of the OP would do wonders to the topic.
If you guys think it'll help, then i'll get back to working on that then... just don't know when i'll have the time to really sit still long enough to do that. Gonna aim for later tonight if im not kept working too late *nods*
i dont know if there are any "rules" or "ethics" to it, but has anyone tried tweeting to jeb_ something like
"@jeb_ what are mojohg's thoughts about implimenting grates? like in this forum: <url>"
and yes i cant spell
and if someone does, they really should make it sound better, i'm just rambling
also, i'm not certain if it would work, tweeting, but i'd guess it wouldnt hurt, at least we would find out if they are aware of it
i would love to have this, i have made a large mob grinder and i really want a grate so i can take back allot of the resources that i have used to make it, like i want a few of my cactus' back and i want to get rid of this makeshift grate i made using Redstone and water so this would be awesome
Same happened to my foodcraft topic :sad.gif:
All the other topics on food are one paragraph imageless posts with a lower quality, and they deleted mine :sad.gif:
Good Luck with the topic :biggrin.gif:
When people ask you to have an open mind, they are actually telling you to "stop believing what you believe," and to "start believing what I believe."
History never repeats itself. Events never happen twice.
thats horrible... They shouldn't take 'who comes first' over quality... but i guess its more or less just the 'suggestion' Mojang will need... the rest they'll work out on their own.
But still, two (or more) similar topics can decide rather the implementation of the concept will turn out for better or for worse. Quality should still have a say in the matter, and that's what im determined to get the moderators at Get Satisfaction to notice. Just need to figure out 'how' ...
EDIT: in the end... if these grates get implemented regardless who's suggestion takes the credit. We'll still profit... i can't help but feel this is my fault though... i should have done more research before i posted this and got everyone involved in the effort.
-
View User Profile
-
View Posts
-
Send Message
Curse Premiumeither way I want people to see this.
The only way this will die out is if it gets implemented, or if Notch himself says it should. Until then im going to keep trying. To much went into this from many people for me to just up and let it die out like this..
I would agree with this thread surviving awhile. However, I also run a thread that I have put a few days total into, and is widely agreed upon. The issue being, once everyone says they enjoy the idea, there is nothing left to say, and the thread drops in the list. However, I support this until it dies a horrible death of implementation (because I don't think there is another way for this to die unless Notch clearly states this idea is not Minecraft worthy).
TL;DR: You missed nothing
PS: The OP could use another organization, with sections (description, purpose, graphics, redstone, support...etc). Right now it still seems a bit messy and unpolished. Just my 2 cents.
Hints&Tips Informative Guides for Minecraft
I agree with landmine. A revamp of the OP would do wonders to the topic.
When people ask you to have an open mind, they are actually telling you to "stop believing what you believe," and to "start believing what I believe."
History never repeats itself. Events never happen twice.
*You can see through it from either angle.
*Fluids can easily fall through it.
*If an enemy like a skeleton is below it can shoot at you through it and you can too.
*Items as well can fall through it.
*When walked on makes a metal sound.
and pretty much this. Hopefully this does get introduced as I can see it as a great asset and if not a necessity for the game.
-
View User Profile
-
View Posts
-
Send Message
Curse PremiumIf you guys think it'll help, then i'll get back to working on that then... just don't know when i'll have the time to really sit still long enough to do that. Gonna aim for later tonight if im not kept working too late *nods*
"@jeb_ what are mojohg's thoughts about implimenting grates? like in this forum: <url>"
and yes i cant spell
and if someone does, they really should make it sound better, i'm just rambling
also, i'm not certain if it would work, tweeting, but i'd guess it wouldnt hurt, at least we would find out if they are aware of it
(i think notch is still on vacation, correct?)
*Edit*
AND ITS A REAL MOD
Because setting forest fires and killing helpless animals is always okay!
Cause it would be quite epic.
I'll figure out what to use them with eventually.
You could use it as a dam floodgate that you could toggle. At least, thats what ill use them as. :biggrin.gif:
Because setting forest fires and killing helpless animals is always okay!