The Meaning of Life, the Universe, and Everything.
Location:
Off Topic & Suggestions
Join Date:
1/8/2014
Posts:
163
Location:
In the Celestial Plains
Minecraft:
TacoKingIII
Member Details
I'm not sure. Maybe put a | on either side of the script.
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
Current avatar: Amaterasu Omikami, or Amaterasu for short. Goddess of the sun, universe and everything that is good. Has a wolf form and a "human" form.
My Avatar is a Dalek, therefor your argument is... EXTERMINATED!!!
You know who can tell me something I already know? Me. All the time. I'm really good at telling me stuff I already know. I don't need help in that department. I don't know about others, but I can't imagine I'm alone here.
Close enough, just get riffs of the two [code]s and [/codes]
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
My Avatar is a Dalek, therefor your argument is... EXTERMINATED!!!
You know who can tell me something I already know? Me. All the time. I'm really good at telling me stuff I already know. I don't need help in that department. I don't know about others, but I can't imagine I'm alone here.
Thank you for the feedback, I'll have to think about all this, though.
First of all, it's deliberately devoid of any modern technology. This way, it fits in with Minecraft's atmosphere perfectly.
Secondly, the Musket's damage is fine, as the scarcity of it's ammo forces it to be used minimally, getting rid of any overpoweredness in this aspect.
Lastly, it will replace the sword in some situations, in the same way the sword replaces the bow in certain situations. In the same way, the sword and bow will replace the Musket in other situations. This is how it's supposed to be, as it forces the player to chose what he or she needs at that moment. This then allows the Bow, Sword, Musket and other weapons (i.e. Axes and Shovels) to be used equally. This is a great thing we don't see very much when we only have two weapons, but would see more of if Muskets were added.
Oh, I'm not telling you to change this, I'm agreeing with you. I love the idea and think it's something that should be added! Sorry for the confusion.
Thank you for the compliment, but I think Muskets fit in much better. Crossbows seem to be a more modern thing, even though they were around at the time of the Musket. I don't know, I'm a fan of The Walking Dead, so I wouldn't mind a Crossbow, but I think a Musket just fits more.
Crossbows have been around since the 5th century BC in China, and were heavily used in medieval warfare so they would fit BUT that's a whole new suggestion thread.
Crossbows have been around since the 5th century BC in China, and were heavily used in medieval warfare so they would fit BUT that's a whole new suggestion thread.
No, I meant that I understand exactly how long they've been around, but that crossbows are still used in a widespread way today. That makes them a more modern thing than Muskets, which haven't been used in like 150 years. Therefore, in my opinion, it makes more sense to include Muskets than Crossbows.
But I can see your side of things, and I wouldn't mind if crossbows were added too, I was only voicing my own opinion.
No, I meant that I understand exactly how long they've been around, but that crossbows are still used in a widespread way today. That makes them a more modern thing than Muskets, which haven't been used in like 150 years. Therefore, in my opinion, it makes more sense to include Muskets than Crossbows.
But I can see your side of things, and I wouldn't mind if crossbows were added too, I was only voicing my own opinion.
Your argument kind of fell in on itself when you said that crossbows are a more modern thing that muskets. Bows are used more than crossbows today and they exist in Minecraft.
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
Oh hey. Looks like you're reading my signature. That's nice. If you thought I was going to put something funny here, I'm not. I will however put a link to my suggestion about gold tools. I think it's fairly popular. It would be nice if it was added. Just click the link and look at it. Please? I'm desperate. http://www.minecraft...-arent-useless/
Your argument kind of fell in on itself when you said that crossbows are a more modern thing that muskets. Bows are used more than crossbows today and they exist in Minecraft.
They are more of a modern thing than Muskets. Crossbows are still used today, whereas Muskets haven't been used in almost 150 years. This seems pretty true to me, I don't get how this is "falling in on itself".
No, but somebody's making a mod out of my suggestion right now.
Ooo, that sounds good. I'll make sure to bookmark this page so I can get it when it's released! Does it use the same crafting recipes as you've suggested?
Ooo, that sounds good. I'll make sure to bookmark this page so I can get it when it's released! Does it use the same crafting recipes as you've suggested?
I'd like it to be the same as it's described in the original post. Crafting recipes included.
you say that the effect from firing a musket with gold armor is 7.5% i would say it should be the highest, as gold is more heavy in real life as well. it would add a little bit of realism
secondly: it would be cool if you couldnt fire the mustket for a specified amount of time upon leaving water, as the gunpowder needs time to dry, maybe like 1 minute
other than that full support
1. In real life, gold is the softest heavy metal. It's so flimsy it can be digested by the human body. It may be classified as "heavy", but it is extremely soft and malleable. Gold plated armor would be better than normal clothing (or leather armor) but not by that much. I feel saying 7.5% would be generous.
2. That might be a good idea. I'll have to think about it.
They are more of a modern thing than Muskets. Crossbows are still used today, whereas Muskets haven't been used in almost 150 years. This seems pretty true to me, I don't get how this is "falling in on itself".
Sorry what I said sounded kind of rude. Anyway, what I meant it that bows are used more commonly than crossbows today. Crossbows are used more than muskets. You sounded like you wanted muskets because they weren't used anymore and bows are both the oldest and most-used so that's where it faltered.
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
Oh hey. Looks like you're reading my signature. That's nice. If you thought I was going to put something funny here, I'm not. I will however put a link to my suggestion about gold tools. I think it's fairly popular. It would be nice if it was added. Just click the link and look at it. Please? I'm desperate. http://www.minecraft...-arent-useless/
Sorry what I said sounded kind of rude. Anyway, what I meant it that bows are used more commonly than crossbows today. Crossbows are used more than muskets. You sounded like you wanted muskets because they weren't used anymore and bows are both the oldest and most-used so that's where it faltered.
I see. I wasn't saying that, I just feel like Muskets fit more than crossbows either way. Who knows, maybe one day Muskets and Crossbows will be added to the game together.
Current avatar: Amaterasu Omikami, or Amaterasu for short. Goddess of the sun, universe and everything that is good. Has a wolf form and a "human" form.
Okay
||
It just shows the banner, not the code.
[code]Ok, after that, do [code], then type in the code, then do [/code]
[/code]
~yoshi9048
My best suggestion:
Mobs actually being varied???
Okay, here
[code][code][url=http://www.minecraftforum.net/forums/minecraft-discussion/suggestions/2252083-what-about-muskets-realistic-balanced-smp-friendly|_blank][img]http://www.mediafire.com/convkey/0dcd/uzoajwpz9q2wp16fg.jpg[/img][/url][/code]
[/code]
~yoshi9048
My best suggestion:
Mobs actually being varied???
Okay, I think I got it.
Oh, I'm not telling you to change this, I'm agreeing with you. I love the idea and think it's something that should be added! Sorry for the confusion.
Crossbows have been around since the 5th century BC in China, and were heavily used in medieval warfare so they would fit BUT that's a whole new suggestion thread.
No, I'm sorry for the misunderstanding, I hate it when that happens.
And thank you for agreeing with me.
No, I meant that I understand exactly how long they've been around, but that crossbows are still used in a widespread way today. That makes them a more modern thing than Muskets, which haven't been used in like 150 years. Therefore, in my opinion, it makes more sense to include Muskets than Crossbows.
But I can see your side of things, and I wouldn't mind if crossbows were added too, I was only voicing my own opinion.
Your argument kind of fell in on itself when you said that crossbows are a more modern thing that muskets. Bows are used more than crossbows today and they exist in Minecraft.
http://www.minecraft...-arent-useless/
They are more of a modern thing than Muskets. Crossbows are still used today, whereas Muskets haven't been used in almost 150 years. This seems pretty true to me, I don't get how this is "falling in on itself".
No, but somebody's making a mod out of my suggestion right now.
Ooo, that sounds good. I'll make sure to bookmark this page so I can get it when it's released! Does it use the same crafting recipes as you've suggested?
I'd like it to be the same as it's described in the original post. Crafting recipes included.
1. In real life, gold is the softest heavy metal. It's so flimsy it can be digested by the human body. It may be classified as "heavy", but it is extremely soft and malleable. Gold plated armor would be better than normal clothing (or leather armor) but not by that much. I feel saying 7.5% would be generous.
2. That might be a good idea. I'll have to think about it.
Thanks for the support, man.
Sorry what I said sounded kind of rude. Anyway, what I meant it that bows are used more commonly than crossbows today. Crossbows are used more than muskets. You sounded like you wanted muskets because they weren't used anymore and bows are both the oldest and most-used so that's where it faltered.
http://www.minecraft...-arent-useless/
I see. I wasn't saying that, I just feel like Muskets fit more than crossbows either way. Who knows, maybe one day Muskets and Crossbows will be added to the game together.