muncher, did you read this? it's toggle able, in other words, you don't need to watch it.
In fact, all these suggestions you say no to, ESPECIALLY those where you give no reason beyond opinion, you won't need to use them.
And i agree with popitop, except with the GET OUT part, you can stay, just don't go "no," the point of these forums is to ADD to ideas, not smash them into a pulp. don't like it? don't use it. or try to change it. i actually DREAD when i see you posted something.
So I could suggest the most grossly offensive thing to you and when you say you don't like it I can say "Don't us it" or "It's toggle-able"
Because that's all you doing!
Try proving to me why this idea is worth being in the game instead of saying "Wahh wahh wahh stop being mean."
Also to popitup telling me to ignore all the bad ideas on the forums is like putting a gabbering,terrible smelling monkey next to me and saying "If you don't like it just ignore it"
Cutscenes in games always feel very arbitrary and pointless. Why watch my character chasing animals or fighting creepers WHEN I COULD BE DOING IT MY SELF! Pointless.
...
......
.........
And you miss my point.
and besides, if you want it. use it, and if you don't want it, don't. it won't matter to you if you don't use it. however, some may actually want it in. so, if it's in, win-win, if it's not, win-lose. sort of like peaceful mode, some won't use it. doesn't mean it's a waste.
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
Paranoid: Moderate. Schizoid: Moderate. Schizotypal: High. Antisocial: Low. Borderline: Low. Histrionic: Moderate. Narcissistic: Moderate. Avoidant: Moderate. Dependent: Moderate. Obsessive-Compulsive: High. Does this make me nuts?
I think that cutscenes would be pretty nice! Make those completionist people try to collect all of the cutscenes.
Muncher, you basically said that this idea was the WORST on this site you have ever seen. I call bulls**t on that one. Ever thought your negative criticism is stopping the GREATEST idea from appearing because you make people fear they will get shot down? If you hate everyone else's idea, then you must have the best ideas, right?
I think that cutscenes would be pretty nice! Make those completionist people try to collect all of the cutscenes.
Muncher, you basically said that this idea was the WORST on this site you have ever seen. I call bulls**t on that one. Ever thought your negative criticism is stopping the GREATEST idea from appearing because you make people fear they will get shot down? If you hate everyone else's idea, then you must have the best ideas, right?
You made a great point my friend, I would play mc ssp all day just to get a motherf*cking cutscene that I want, and if someone says that I just play in peaceful, I could replay the cutscene of the creeper, so it shows that you did something in the game,yet, it's not an achievments-like thing, cause just you can see in your pc
I think that cutscenes would be pretty nice! Make those completionist people try to collect all of the cutscenes.
Muncher, you basically said that this idea was the WORST on this site you have ever seen. I call bulls**t on that one. Ever thought your negative criticism is stopping the GREATEST idea from appearing because you make people fear they will get shot down? If you hate everyone else's idea, then you must have the best ideas, right?
I try not to mince words when I post things. so if i don't like your idea I'll say so.
But some ideas I find so bad they would offend me to be put in minecraft, even if I did'nt use them.
Here's to all you people that like them.
Wouldn't the experience of fighting your first creeper, or placing your first torch be more memorable and have more of an impact on you if you did it your self? Does'nt putting a generic cutscene that everyone sees make the experience less special?
Think of it this way. Assuming you all played pokemon, wasn't it extremely special when you caught your first pokemon? It was something original to you and now one had the exact same experience as you. Wouldn't that experience be diminished if a generic cutscene that everyone saw played after you caught your pokemon? Same with minecraft.
Minecraft does'nt need cutscenes because the game revolves around experiences that player make for themselves. Adding cutscenes makes everyone experience the same, ruining the fun and origonality.
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
Quote from mjcabooseblu »
Muncher is right, listen to him, he can cure the blind and make paraplegics walk.
I think that cutscenes would be pretty nice! Make those completionist people try to collect all of the cutscenes.
Muncher, you basically said that this idea was the WORST on this site you have ever seen. I call bulls**t on that one. Ever thought your negative criticism is stopping the GREATEST idea from appearing because you make people fear they will get shot down? If you hate everyone else's idea, then you must have the best ideas, right?
I try not to mince words when I post things. so if i don't like your idea I'll say so.
But some ideas I find so bad they would offend me to be put in minecraft, even if I did'nt use them.
Here's to all you people that like them.
Wouldn't the experience of fighting your first creeper, or placing your first torch be more memorable and have more of an impact on you if you did it your self? Does'nt putting a generic cutscene that everyone sees make the experience less special?
Think of it this way. Assuming you all played pokemon, wasn't it extremely special when you caught your first pokemon? It was something original to you and now one had the exact same experience as you. Wouldn't that experience be diminished if a generic cutscene that everyone saw played after you caught your pokemon? Same with minecraft.
Minecraft does'nt need cutscenes because the game revolves around experiences that player make for themselves. Adding cutscenes makes everyone experience the same, ruining the fun and origonality.
...
and my point is missed
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
Paranoid: Moderate. Schizoid: Moderate. Schizotypal: High. Antisocial: Low. Borderline: Low. Histrionic: Moderate. Narcissistic: Moderate. Avoidant: Moderate. Dependent: Moderate. Obsessive-Compulsive: High. Does this make me nuts?
I think that cutscenes would be pretty nice! Make those completionist people try to collect all of the cutscenes.
Muncher, you basically said that this idea was the WORST on this site you have ever seen. I call bulls**t on that one. Ever thought your negative criticism is stopping the GREATEST idea from appearing because you make people fear they will get shot down? If you hate everyone else's idea, then you must have the best ideas, right?
I try not to mince words when I post things. so if i don't like your idea I'll say so.
But some ideas I find so bad they would offend me to be put in minecraft, even if I did'nt use them.
Here's to all you people that like them.
Wouldn't the experience of fighting your first creeper, or placing your first torch be more memorable and have more of an impact on you if you did it your self? Does'nt putting a generic cutscene that everyone sees make the experience less special?
Think of it this way. Assuming you all played pokemon, wasn't it extremely special when you caught your first pokemon? It was something original to you and now one had the exact same experience as you. Wouldn't that experience be diminished if a generic cutscene that everyone saw played after you caught your pokemon? Same with minecraft.
Minecraft does'nt need cutscenes because the game revolves around experiences that player make for themselves. Adding cutscenes makes everyone experience the same, ruining the fun and origonality.
But youuu, it's because, but, it's good cos well.. hmm, GODAMNIT, i don't know what to say...
Nope, I'm ignoring your point of "Just don't use it" because it's a flawed cop out argument that diminishes the worth of the idea instead of adding to it.
When you say "just don't use it" your admitting there is a reason someone would not want o use your idea, which shows that your idea is flawed, therefor showing this idea is bad.
The don't use it argument is a cop out idea and doesn't support any idea just diminishes from it so stop using it.
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
Quote from mjcabooseblu »
Muncher is right, listen to him, he can cure the blind and make paraplegics walk.
I think that cutscenes would be pretty nice! Make those completionist people try to collect all of the cutscenes.
Muncher, you basically said that this idea was the WORST on this site you have ever seen. I call bulls**t on that one. Ever thought your negative criticism is stopping the GREATEST idea from appearing because you make people fear they will get shot down? If you hate everyone else's idea, then you must have the best ideas, right?
I try not to mince words when I post things. so if i don't like your idea I'll say so.
But some ideas I find so bad they would offend me to be put in minecraft, even if I did'nt use them.
Here's to all you people that like them.
Wouldn't the experience of fighting your first creeper, or placing your first torch be more memorable and have more of an impact on you if you did it your self? Does'nt putting a generic cutscene that everyone sees make the experience less special?
Think of it this way. Assuming you all played pokemon, wasn't it extremely special when you caught your first pokemon? It was something original to you and now one had the exact same experience as you. Wouldn't that experience be diminished if a generic cutscene that everyone saw played after you caught your pokemon? Same with minecraft.
Minecraft does'nt need cutscenes because the game revolves around experiences that player make for themselves. Adding cutscenes makes everyone experience the same, ruining the fun and origonality.
well, look, he said when you SEE your first creeper it would zoom to him,just that, YOU would kill the creeper, and the torche, he said your 5 torch placed, so it isn't removing anithing special, just putting something new
But showing the player the creeper IS taking away something! Instead of the player discovering the creeper for them self the cutscene would show them the creeper right away, taking away the feeling of discovery you feel when your find your first creeper.
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
Quote from mjcabooseblu »
Muncher is right, listen to him, he can cure the blind and make paraplegics walk.
Nope, I'm ignoring your point of "Just don't use it" because it's a flawed cop out argument that diminishes the worth of the idea instead of adding to it.
When you say "just don't use it" your admitting there is a reason someone would not want o use your idea, which shows that your idea is flawed, therefor showing this idea is bad.
The don't use it argument is a cop out idea and doesn't support any idea just diminishes from it so stop using it.
that's not my point...
my point is, if you read carefully, if inculded, due to toggelablity, it is a win-win, if not inculded, it is a win-lose situation. and a fix for the creeper one is simple, only once you actually "discover" it. basically getting within 5 blocks of it, and you can clearly see it at the same time.
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
Paranoid: Moderate. Schizoid: Moderate. Schizotypal: High. Antisocial: Low. Borderline: Low. Histrionic: Moderate. Narcissistic: Moderate. Avoidant: Moderate. Dependent: Moderate. Obsessive-Compulsive: High. Does this make me nuts?
Nope, I'm ignoring your point of "Just don't use it" because it's a flawed cop out argument that diminishes the worth of the idea instead of adding to it.
When you say "just don't use it" your admitting there is a reason someone would not want o use your idea, which shows that your idea is flawed, therefor showing this idea is bad.
The don't use it argument is a cop out idea and doesn't support any idea just diminishes from it so stop using it.
that's not my point...
my point is, if you read carefully, if inculded, due to toggelablity, it is a win-win, if not inculded, it is a win-lose situation. and a fix for the creeper one is simple, only once you actually "discover" it. basically getting within 5 blocks of it, and you can clearly see it at the same time.
you made your point my friend, but it will be missed again
you made your point my friend, but it will be missed again
EVERY SINGLE ONE OF MY GODDAMN POINTS IS MISSED! THIS IS WHY I LOST FAITH IN HUMANITY! Rage aside, muncher, you, are, an, idea, basher.
and fadasa, thank you for being nice right there
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
Paranoid: Moderate. Schizoid: Moderate. Schizotypal: High. Antisocial: Low. Borderline: Low. Histrionic: Moderate. Narcissistic: Moderate. Avoidant: Moderate. Dependent: Moderate. Obsessive-Compulsive: High. Does this make me nuts?
Sorry, my bad, he said after 5 creepers be genereted in your chunk that would apear, so it's very probably that you see one before that
unless, like most new players, he was hiding in a small house or cave. More then five creepers spawn on your chunk per night, so unless the player was out adventuring at night they will not see the creeper.
Also showing the player the creeper once they see it is not good either. The game shows them the creeper and makes sure exactingly where it is and what it's doing, thus ruining the point of the creepers "creeping" and ruining the players first experience with the creeper.
and, this, idea, deserves, to, be, bashed,
How about showing me why this ideas deserves to be in the game instead of just trying to swat away my reasons with pointless and weak insults.
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
Quote from mjcabooseblu »
Muncher is right, listen to him, he can cure the blind and make paraplegics walk.
Sorry, my bad, he said after 5 creepers be genereted in your chunk that would apear, so it's very probably that you see one before that
unless, like most new players, he was hiding in a small house or cave. More then five creepers spawn on your chunk per night, so unless the player was out adventuring at night they will not see the creeper.
Also showing the player the creeper once they see it is not good either. The game shows them the creeper and makes sure exactingly where it is and what it's doing, thus ruining the point of the creepers "creeping" and ruining the players first experience with the creeper.
and, this, idea, deserves, to, be, bashed,
How about showing me why this ideas deserves to be in the game instead of just trying to swat away my reasons with pointless and weak insults.
1: This is a sandbox game, a game meant to be played the way the PLAYER wants it to be played
2: It can be used in machinmas that don't want to mod
3:
Quote from ez »
Discuss
Remember that these are discussion forums. Dropping into a suggestions thread to drop a quick yes/no vote is frowned upon since it typically doesn't contribute. If you see a suggestion you like or dislike, enter the thread only if you have the intention to contribute. If you have ideas for improvement, share them.
AND READ THE THREAD.
(less of a reason and more of a how you reply to topics, you clearly won't contribute to the topic(s)
4: you should give as much proof as i do for your side. that's beyond opinion, or personal experince. (similar to 3)
5: if done correctly, it might IMPROVE the game.
6:
7: just so you know, it could just pause, show a clip of a creeper chasing a player, or something else like that.
i just gave 4 reasons. now you.
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
Paranoid: Moderate. Schizoid: Moderate. Schizotypal: High. Antisocial: Low. Borderline: Low. Histrionic: Moderate. Narcissistic: Moderate. Avoidant: Moderate. Dependent: Moderate. Obsessive-Compulsive: High. Does this make me nuts?
SO your arguing for cutscenes that everyone would see, and would be very generic, yet you say post a video link to a video telling people to have their own ORIGINAL experiences in minecraft. you contradict yourself.
none of your other "arguments" made sense as they were more posting tips, so you have not given me any ways these cutscenes would add to the game or why the game needs them.
here are my reasons.
1. ruins origonal experiences. Takes the player personal experience and makes it generic and boring.
2. Is childish and don't make any sense. This is mostly or the jumping one. Why are the mobs jumping in a line? this never happens in game and is just dumb.
3. Cut scenes with minecraft would be generally ugly and difficult.
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
Quote from mjcabooseblu »
Muncher is right, listen to him, he can cure the blind and make paraplegics walk.
How about showing me why this ideas deserves to be in the game instead of just trying to swat away my reasons with pointless and weak insults.
Ok, this idea is just grat for players that like having some stop of gameplay, like me, if a game stop giving me things to do, I stop playing it, cutscenes would be good beacause Notch can put more of these in the game, always giving players something to "unlock", I stop playing ssp beacause I did almost every thing that I wanted to do, found diamonds, blow up my house with TNT, kill cows from punching them to the ground.
Another thing is that players who are playing in peaceful would not get all the cutscenes, encoraging them to play in easy to unlocking them.
It's good to advise players that THAT thing is deangerous, like beeing submerge, resting oly 1 bubble of air it would appear your char going to the surface and then breathing, good thing for that who don't wanna die by something that they don't know.
SO your arguing for cutscenes that everyone would see, and would be very generic, yet you say post a video link to a video telling people to have their own ORIGINAL experiences in minecraft. you contradict yourself.
none of your other "arguments" made sense as they were more posting tips, so you have not given me any ways these cutscenes would add to the game or why the game needs them.
here are my reasons.
1. ruins origonal experiences. Takes the player personal experience and makes it generic and boring.
2. Is childish and don't make any sense. This is mostly or the jumping one. Why are the mobs jumping in a line? this never happens in game and is just dumb.
3. Cut scenes with minecraft would be generally ugly and difficult.
by your own logic, your reasons are just as bad as mine muncher.
1: if toggleable, it won't ruin anything.
2: The game is aimed for everyone and "dumb" is opinion
3: beauty is in the eyes of the beholder and difficult? The Aether would be harder than this. The Nether was. Biomes were.
also
Quote from Fadasa »
Ok, this idea is just grat for players that like having some stop of gameplay, like me, if a game stop giving me things to do, I stop playing it, cutscenes would be good beacause Notch can put more of these in the game, always giving players something to "unlock", I stop playing ssp beacause I did almost every thing that I wanted to do, found diamonds, blow up my house with TNT, kill cows from punching them to the ground.
Another thing is that players who are playing in peaceful would not get all the cutscenes, encoraging them to play in easy to unlocking them.
It's good to advise players that THAT thing is deangerous, like beeing submerge, resting oly 1 bubble of air it would appear your char going to the surface and then breathing, good thing for that who don't wanna die by something that they don't know.
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
Paranoid: Moderate. Schizoid: Moderate. Schizotypal: High. Antisocial: Low. Borderline: Low. Histrionic: Moderate. Narcissistic: Moderate. Avoidant: Moderate. Dependent: Moderate. Obsessive-Compulsive: High. Does this make me nuts?
How about showing me why this ideas deserves to be in the game instead of just trying to swat away my reasons with pointless and weak insults.
Ok, this idea is just grat for players that like having some stop of gameplay, like me, if a game stop giving me things to do, I stop playing it, cutscenes would be good beacause Notch can put more of these in the game, always giving players something to "unlock", I stop playing ssp beacause I did almost every thing that I wanted to do, found diamonds, blow up my house with TNT, kill cows from punching them to the ground.
Another thing is that players who are playing in peaceful would not get all the cutscenes, encoraging them to play in easy to unlocking them.
It's good to advise players that THAT thing is deangerous, like beeing submerge, resting oly 1 bubble of air it would appear your char going to the surface and then breathing, good thing for that who don't wanna die by something that they don't know.
Would'nt it be better if the game rewarded you with something ingame, instead of some generic 5 second clip?
Your peaceful argument is valid, but there allready is a reward for playing on a harder difficulty. Mob drops. players on peaceful can't get tnt, and bows. The game should reward you with things like this istead of some generic movie clip.
QUIT ****ING USING THE TOGGLE OPTION ARGUMENT. IT IS A CRAPPY COP OUT ARGUMENT. TRY PROVING WHY THE IDEA IS GOOD INSTEAD OF TELLING ME TO NOT USE IT.
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
Quote from mjcabooseblu »
Muncher is right, listen to him, he can cure the blind and make paraplegics walk.
...
......
.........
And you miss my point.
and besides, if you want it. use it, and if you don't want it, don't. it won't matter to you if you don't use it. however, some may actually want it in. so, if it's in, win-win, if it's not, win-lose. sort of like peaceful mode, some won't use it. doesn't mean it's a waste.
Muncher, you basically said that this idea was the WORST on this site you have ever seen. I call bulls**t on that one. Ever thought your negative criticism is stopping the GREATEST idea from appearing because you make people fear they will get shot down? If you hate everyone else's idea, then you must have the best ideas, right?
http://www.youtube.com/freeloadinggamers
You made a great point my friend, I would play mc ssp all day just to get a motherf*cking cutscene that I want, and if someone says that I just play in peaceful, I could replay the cutscene of the creeper, so it shows that you did something in the game,yet, it's not an achievments-like thing, cause just you can see in your pc
I try not to mince words when I post things. so if i don't like your idea I'll say so.
But some ideas I find so bad they would offend me to be put in minecraft, even if I did'nt use them.
Here's to all you people that like them.
Wouldn't the experience of fighting your first creeper, or placing your first torch be more memorable and have more of an impact on you if you did it your self? Does'nt putting a generic cutscene that everyone sees make the experience less special?
Think of it this way. Assuming you all played pokemon, wasn't it extremely special when you caught your first pokemon? It was something original to you and now one had the exact same experience as you. Wouldn't that experience be diminished if a generic cutscene that everyone saw played after you caught your pokemon? Same with minecraft.
Minecraft does'nt need cutscenes because the game revolves around experiences that player make for themselves. Adding cutscenes makes everyone experience the same, ruining the fun and origonality.
...
and my point is missed
But youuu, it's because, but, it's good cos well.. hmm, GODAMNIT, i don't know what to say...
Nope, I'm ignoring your point of "Just don't use it" because it's a flawed cop out argument that diminishes the worth of the idea instead of adding to it.
When you say "just don't use it" your admitting there is a reason someone would not want o use your idea, which shows that your idea is flawed, therefor showing this idea is bad.
The don't use it argument is a cop out idea and doesn't support any idea just diminishes from it so stop using it.
well, look, he said when you SEE your first creeper it would zoom to him,just that, YOU would kill the creeper, and the torche, he said your 5 torch placed, so it isn't removing anithing special, just putting something new
that's not my point...
my point is, if you read carefully, if inculded, due to toggelablity, it is a win-win, if not inculded, it is a win-lose situation. and a fix for the creeper one is simple, only once you actually "discover" it. basically getting within 5 blocks of it, and you can clearly see it at the same time.
you made your point my friend, but it will be missed again
EVERY SINGLE ONE OF MY GODDAMN POINTS IS MISSED! THIS IS WHY I LOST FAITH IN HUMANITY! Rage aside, muncher, you, are, an, idea, basher.
and fadasa, thank you for being nice right there
unless, like most new players, he was hiding in a small house or cave. More then five creepers spawn on your chunk per night, so unless the player was out adventuring at night they will not see the creeper.
Also showing the player the creeper once they see it is not good either. The game shows them the creeper and makes sure exactingly where it is and what it's doing, thus ruining the point of the creepers "creeping" and ruining the players first experience with the creeper.
and, this, idea, deserves, to, be, bashed,
How about showing me why this ideas deserves to be in the game instead of just trying to swat away my reasons with pointless and weak insults.
1: This is a sandbox game, a game meant to be played the way the PLAYER wants it to be played
2: It can be used in machinmas that don't want to mod
3: (less of a reason and more of a how you reply to topics, you clearly won't contribute to the topic(s)
4: you should give as much proof as i do for your side. that's beyond opinion, or personal experince. (similar to 3)
5: if done correctly, it might IMPROVE the game.
6:
7: just so you know, it could just pause, show a clip of a creeper chasing a player, or something else like that.
i just gave 4 reasons. now you.
none of your other "arguments" made sense as they were more posting tips, so you have not given me any ways these cutscenes would add to the game or why the game needs them.
here are my reasons.
1. ruins origonal experiences. Takes the player personal experience and makes it generic and boring.
2. Is childish and don't make any sense. This is mostly or the jumping one. Why are the mobs jumping in a line? this never happens in game and is just dumb.
3. Cut scenes with minecraft would be generally ugly and difficult.
Ok, this idea is just grat for players that like having some stop of gameplay, like me, if a game stop giving me things to do, I stop playing it, cutscenes would be good beacause Notch can put more of these in the game, always giving players something to "unlock", I stop playing ssp beacause I did almost every thing that I wanted to do, found diamonds, blow up my house with TNT, kill cows from punching them to the ground.
Another thing is that players who are playing in peaceful would not get all the cutscenes, encoraging them to play in easy to unlocking them.
It's good to advise players that THAT thing is deangerous, like beeing submerge, resting oly 1 bubble of air it would appear your char going to the surface and then breathing, good thing for that who don't wanna die by something that they don't know.
by your own logic, your reasons are just as bad as mine muncher.
1: if toggleable, it won't ruin anything.
2: The game is aimed for everyone and "dumb" is opinion
3: beauty is in the eyes of the beholder and difficult? The Aether would be harder than this. The Nether was. Biomes were.
also
Would'nt it be better if the game rewarded you with something ingame, instead of some generic 5 second clip?
Your peaceful argument is valid, but there allready is a reward for playing on a harder difficulty. Mob drops. players on peaceful can't get tnt, and bows. The game should reward you with things like this istead of some generic movie clip.
QUIT ****ING USING THE TOGGLE OPTION ARGUMENT. IT IS A CRAPPY COP OUT ARGUMENT. TRY PROVING WHY THE IDEA IS GOOD INSTEAD OF TELLING ME TO NOT USE IT.