The Meaning of Life, the Universe, and Everything.
Join Date:
5/20/2011
Posts:
55
Member Details
I think you should be able to put chests in boats like donkey and put leads on them so you can carry them when you paddle. Its natural when you think about it in history, I think its kind of ironic that there are more over land methods of transport in minecraft first.
The Meaning of Life, the Universe, and Everything.
Join Date:
5/20/2011
Posts:
55
Member Details
i think there should be ships tbh. you should be able to make them any size you want and put chests and crafting tables on them. also some sort of turrent system so you can shoot at things like maybe a harpoon gun that shoots something craftable like arrows, or a cannon.
No Support! it will be too op. And it will also kills the reason of why should we hardly look for donkey and tame them hardly if instead we can use boats.
No Support! it will be too op. And it will also kills the reason of why should we hardly look for donkey and tame them hardly if instead we can use boats.
Can donkeys swim? No. And it's not OP at all considering right now hauling lots of stuff across the ocean is a real hastle unless you have a shulker box.
Jokes aside, we have minecart chests, and two person boats now. Crating a Boat with Chest (combine a boat and chest, like with current minecarts) and sacrificing a passenger slot would fit quite nicely.
Donkeys already fulfill this purpose within the game, and it would disrupt balance to create a more easily-found duplicate of them. There's a reason why movable transport is not easily accessible, and it's not an oversight.
No Support! it will be too op. And it will also kills the reason of why should we hardly look for donkey and tame them hardly if instead we can use boats.
Donkeys already fulfill this purpose within the game, and it would disrupt balance to create a more easily-found duplicate of them. There's a reason why movable transport is not easily accessible, and it's not an oversight.
This does not have my support.
How would a boat with a chest make a donkey obsolete? Last I checked, it was pretty tough to row a boat across the grassy Plains or up the snowy Extreme Hills...
Since donkeys would be for land travel and these would be for naval travel, I could definitely support it.
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
"Most plans are critically flawed by their own logic. A failure at any step will ruin everything after it. That's just basic cause and effect. It's easy for a good plan to fall apart. Therefore, a plan that has no attachment to logic cannot be stopped. The success or failure of any given step will have no impact on the macro level."
-Red Mage, 8-Bit Theater
"90% of the Internet's statistics are made-up, and 7/8 of its quotes are misattributed."
-Abraham Lincoln, 16th US President
Donkeys already fulfill this purpose within the game, and it would disrupt balance to create a more easily-found duplicate of them. There's a reason why movable transport is not easily accessible, and it's not an oversight.
This does not have my support.
Can boats travel over land? Can donkeys travel over sea? We already have minecarts and animals with chests. Now that boats have a second entity slot, why wouldn't you be able to put a chest instead of an entity slot
OP: support
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
Click the dragon/egg that is on top to help me raise my dragons
How would a boat with a chest make a donkey obsolete? Last I checked, it was pretty tough to row a boat across the grassy Plains or up the snowy Extreme Hills...
Since donkeys would be for land travel and these would be for naval travel, I could definitely support it.
It doesn't make donkeys obsolete. Donkeys are harder to get and transport across the sea (requires a donkey, saddle, chest, lead, and boat). This is on purpose. To create something that would more easily do this function with just wood as materials would be to disrupt game balance progression.
It doesn't make donkeys obsolete. Donkeys are harder to get and transport across the sea (requires a donkey, saddle, chest, lead, and boat). This is on purpose. To create something that would more easily do this function with just wood as materials would be to disrupt game balance progression.
I don't know if I would count being able to move a couple of stacks of items slightly faster as something that absolutely shatters game balance. How often are you really moving massive amounts of stuff from one place to the other until you are well established and have the means to do it way faster (Shulker Boxes, Llamas, Nether travel, etc.)? It seems more like a non issue as most players typically build a base and hunker down there until they have the means to do whatever they want. At least that is my experience.
If Minecraft was more of a game about having to get to specific biomes for different resources I would say it is unbalanced, but 99% of them can be found in any biome and the 1% can usually be transplanted from one biome to another (crops or saplings or specific mobs) without needing to carry a chest full.
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
Want some advice on how to thrive in the Suggestions section? Check this handy list of guidelines and tips for posting your ideas and responding to the ideas of others!
It doesn't make donkeys obsolete. Donkeys are harder to get and transport across the sea (requires a donkey, saddle, chest, lead, and boat). This is on purpose. To create something that would more easily do this function with just wood as materials would be to disrupt game balance progression.
I think you're missing my point, and I certainly don't understand yours. You make it sound as if the entire purpose of a donkey is to lead it onto a boat and use it on the water. I, on the other hand, view donkeys as useful to ride around on land. The chest-boat doesn't perform the same function as a donkey because boats don't travel on land!
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
"Most plans are critically flawed by their own logic. A failure at any step will ruin everything after it. That's just basic cause and effect. It's easy for a good plan to fall apart. Therefore, a plan that has no attachment to logic cannot be stopped. The success or failure of any given step will have no impact on the macro level."
-Red Mage, 8-Bit Theater
"90% of the Internet's statistics are made-up, and 7/8 of its quotes are misattributed."
-Abraham Lincoln, 16th US President
I suggest that this idea be moved to the reddit Minecraft Suggestions. It's one that would be great to introduce to the game, and can benefit with overseas transportation.
Most methods of item transportation require a certain investment of effort/resources. Minecarts need rails which take a lot of iron/gold. Donkeys need finding, taming, saddles and you often need to create pathways. Ender chests require obsidian and hunting in Nether for blazes. And Shulker boxes... ugh. But then again, an Ender chest full of Shulker boxes is a thing of beauty and ptetty much obsoletes all else - much as Elytra with rockets completely changes travel.
However, boat with chest strikes me as way too easy to make - just a bit of wood. And additional waterways can very easily be created with pick, shovel and bucket.
Inventory constraint seems like a rather important factor and such an easy way to pretty much double inventory early on does seem a bit OP.
However, with aquatic update and water becoming a lot less safe, chest boats seem like a good tradeoff for the danger of being around water.
I think you should be able to put chests in boats like donkey and put leads on them so you can carry them when you paddle. Its natural when you think about it in history, I think its kind of ironic that there are more over land methods of transport in minecraft first.
Considering you can have 2 entities in boats now, I'd frankly have nothing against this.
SUPPORT
If this helps at all, I support this.
I would love this! Chests in your boats? It's less common than you think!
Giant👏 Meteor👏 2020👏
i think there should be ships tbh. you should be able to make them any size you want and put chests and crafting tables on them. also some sort of turrent system so you can shoot at things like maybe a harpoon gun that shoots something craftable like arrows, or a cannon.
No Support! it will be too op. And it will also kills the reason of why should we hardly look for donkey and tame them hardly if instead we can use boats.
Can donkeys swim? No. And it's not OP at all considering right now hauling lots of stuff across the ocean is a real hastle unless you have a shulker box.
OP: Support.
Considering that two entities can now fit in boat, it sounds feasible.
Would turn a boat into a good fishing vessel due to the extra storage.
Support.
BA
1) Tame donkey
2) Put donkey in boat
3) ???
4) Profit!
Jokes aside, we have minecart chests, and two person boats now. Crating a Boat with Chest (combine a boat and chest, like with current minecarts) and sacrificing a passenger slot would fit quite nicely.
Support
Check out my Youtube channel, where I build a theme park in vanilla Minecraft!
https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLeCiIIOoWhe-mq3nYd_nXXrKw9MkjnUU7
Donkeys already fulfill this purpose within the game, and it would disrupt balance to create a more easily-found duplicate of them. There's a reason why movable transport is not easily accessible, and it's not an oversight.
This does not have my support.
If you are planning to make a suggestion, please read this.
If you want to know more, you can read this.
For those who complain about post-Beta generation, you might want to see this.
I SUPPORT this but it should be a crafting recipe: A boat combined with a chest. Then of course two players would not be able to sit in it, just one.
YouTube: Backdraft Gaming
Twitter: @BackdraftGamer
Facebook: facebook.com/BackdraftGaming
How would a boat with a chest make a donkey obsolete? Last I checked, it was pretty tough to row a boat across the grassy Plains or up the snowy Extreme Hills...
Since donkeys would be for land travel and these would be for naval travel, I could definitely support it.
"Most plans are critically flawed by their own logic. A failure at any step will ruin everything after it. That's just basic cause and effect. It's easy for a good plan to fall apart. Therefore, a plan that has no attachment to logic cannot be stopped. The success or failure of any given step will have no impact on the macro level."
-Red Mage, 8-Bit Theater
"90% of the Internet's statistics are made-up, and 7/8 of its quotes are misattributed."
-Abraham Lincoln, 16th US President
Can boats travel over land? Can donkeys travel over sea? We already have minecarts and animals with chests. Now that boats have a second entity slot, why wouldn't you be able to put a chest instead of an entity slot
OP: support
Click the dragon/egg that is on top to help me raise my dragons
http://www.minecraftforum.net/forums/off-topic/forum-games/2824114-delete-the-block-above-you
It doesn't make donkeys obsolete. Donkeys are harder to get and transport across the sea (requires a donkey, saddle, chest, lead, and boat). This is on purpose. To create something that would more easily do this function with just wood as materials would be to disrupt game balance progression.
If you are planning to make a suggestion, please read this.
If you want to know more, you can read this.
For those who complain about post-Beta generation, you might want to see this.
I don't know if I would count being able to move a couple of stacks of items slightly faster as something that absolutely shatters game balance. How often are you really moving massive amounts of stuff from one place to the other until you are well established and have the means to do it way faster (Shulker Boxes, Llamas, Nether travel, etc.)? It seems more like a non issue as most players typically build a base and hunker down there until they have the means to do whatever they want. At least that is my experience.
If Minecraft was more of a game about having to get to specific biomes for different resources I would say it is unbalanced, but 99% of them can be found in any biome and the 1% can usually be transplanted from one biome to another (crops or saplings or specific mobs) without needing to carry a chest full.
Want some advice on how to thrive in the Suggestions section? Check this handy list of guidelines and tips for posting your ideas and responding to the ideas of others!
http://www.minecraftforum.net/forums/minecraft-discussion/suggestions/2775557-guidelines-for-the-suggestions-forum
I think you're missing my point, and I certainly don't understand yours. You make it sound as if the entire purpose of a donkey is to lead it onto a boat and use it on the water. I, on the other hand, view donkeys as useful to ride around on land. The chest-boat doesn't perform the same function as a donkey because boats don't travel on land!
"Most plans are critically flawed by their own logic. A failure at any step will ruin everything after it. That's just basic cause and effect. It's easy for a good plan to fall apart. Therefore, a plan that has no attachment to logic cannot be stopped. The success or failure of any given step will have no impact on the macro level."
-Red Mage, 8-Bit Theater
"90% of the Internet's statistics are made-up, and 7/8 of its quotes are misattributed."
-Abraham Lincoln, 16th US President
I suggest that this idea be moved to the reddit Minecraft Suggestions. It's one that would be great to introduce to the game, and can benefit with overseas transportation.
Totally support this! It would add a whole new dimension to sea-faring adventures and deep water fishing expeditions!
Most methods of item transportation require a certain investment of effort/resources. Minecarts need rails which take a lot of iron/gold. Donkeys need finding, taming, saddles and you often need to create pathways. Ender chests require obsidian and hunting in Nether for blazes. And Shulker boxes... ugh. But then again, an Ender chest full of Shulker boxes is a thing of beauty and ptetty much obsoletes all else - much as Elytra with rockets completely changes travel.
However, boat with chest strikes me as way too easy to make - just a bit of wood. And additional waterways can very easily be created with pick, shovel and bucket.
Inventory constraint seems like a rather important factor and such an easy way to pretty much double inventory early on does seem a bit OP.
However, with aquatic update and water becoming a lot less safe, chest boats seem like a good tradeoff for the danger of being around water.
Support for 1.13+
I reaaaaaaaly like this idea. If you visualize it in your mind, its actually a neat texture
Much Support.