Minecraft Forums

Quote from Golbolco»

80% works, soup doesn't really quench your thirst as much as hunger, I guess.

Really not a soup satisfies both so thirsty

Quote from DrWeegee»

Ok, yes. It's been suggested many times. We heard you about that a few times now.

You proven your point - The idea has been suggest many times.

But does that really mean that you can't support an idea? That the whole idea's value is lost?

That's saying that a suggestion has no potential just because the idea has been thought of already.

Look at that one muskets thread. While I don't really like the idea, it is a really good idea, well thought out and balanced.

But since the idea's been suggested already, I guess I can't give it any support at all.

Kinda weird logic, you think...? I don't know, might just be me.

I just posted the original criticism, if it helps.

And to clarify, it's not that it's been already suggested ONCE, it's that it's been suggested many times over.

The muskets idea was pure genius though.

Quote from Jhonter»

Really not a soup satisfies both so thirsty

How about golden apples? Golden apples in real life are delicious, juicy and sweet.

Quote from DrWeegee»

Ok, yes. It's been suggested many times. We heard you about that a few times now.

You proven your point - The idea has been suggest many times.

But does that really mean that you can't support an idea? That the whole idea's value is lost?

That's saying that a suggestion has no potential just because the idea has been thought of already.

Look at that one muskets thread. While I don't really like the idea, it is a really good idea, well thought out and balanced.

But since the idea's been suggested already, I guess I can't give it any support at all.

Kinda weird logic, you think...? I don't know, might just be me.

I thought the same way :/

Quote from megabyte12345»

I just posted the original criticism, if it helps.

And to clarify, it's not that it's been already suggested ONCE, it's that it's been suggested many times over.

The muskets idea was pure genius though.

All criticism whether constructive or not, is valid

Quote from Golbolco»

How about golden apples? Golden apples in real life are delicious, juicy and sweet.

I think you're mixed up a bit on what exactly a Golden apple in Minecraft is...

It's not a yellow apple.

But rather... An apple wrapped up in solid gold....... Ore...

Or gold ore blocks.

Quote from DrWeegee»

I think you're mixed up a bit on what exactly a Golden apple in Minecraft is...

It's not a yellow apple.

But rather... An apple wrapped up in solid gold....... Ore...

Or gold ore blocks.

Indeed... It's a bit disgusting when you think about ingesting multiple blocks of gold with a very small apple. Though, pure gold is non-toxic, so it's not that bad, right? Though there's still the problem of chewing it all up. Your Minecraft character must have metal teeth.

Quote from Golbolco»

How about golden apples? Golden apples in real life are delicious, juicy and sweet.

I'd mention the DrWeegee what spoke, the golden apple is but a block of a food

Quote from DrWeegee»

I think you're mixed up a bit on what exactly a Golden apple in Minecraft is...

It's not a yellow apple.

But rather... An apple wrapped up in solid gold....... Ore...

Or gold ore blocks.

He took the words out of my mouth, kkk

Quote from Golbolco»

Indeed... It's a bit disgusting when you think about ingesting multiple blocks of gold with a very small apple. Though, pure gold is non-toxic, so it's not that bad, right? Though there's still the problem of chewing it all up. Your Minecraft character must have metal teeth.

Truth kkkkk

Not really for the thirst bar and fruits. I do however like the idea of an apple tree, making it easier to get apples.

Partial Support.

Quote from Nickstarwars1»

Not really for the thirst bar and fruits. I do however like the idea of an apple tree, making it easier to get apples.

Partial Support.

Thanks for Partial Support

I'm glad Edison didn't have people claiming the light bulb was oversuggested lol. Personally, no offense but just claiming

oversuggestion just... I don't know. I would like to see this so-called "card" banned. This idea here proves my point.

The poster did put in a good deal of effort and even introduced some new ideas. Actually come to think of it

I change my vote to full support.

I am usually collecting apples and carrots anyways and I just store them away until I need a night vision potion

or to cure a zombie. It'd be nice to have a bit of extra use for them.

But as for the overall idea what would be the negative/positive side-effects of the thirst bar?

Would there be consequences for overhydration as well as dehydration?

Quote from Cerroz»

I also want to mention that if you "break the barrier" with an idea that's generally hated with excellent details, it might go in the suggestions hall of fame.

That's true. Remember why muskets got up there?

Actually, you know, with a bit of polishing, this may be a hall-of-fame-worthy suggestion. (in my opinion)

Quote from Wolfhusband»

I'm glad Edison didn't have people claiming the light bulb was oversuggested lol. Personally, no offense but just claiming

oversuggestion just... I don't know. I would like to see this so-called "card" banned. This idea here proves my point.

The poster did put in a good deal of effort and even introduced some new ideas. Actually come to think of it

I change my vote to full support.

I am usually collecting apples and carrots anyways and I just store them away until I need a night vision potion

or to cure a zombie. It'd be nice to have a bit of extra use for them.

But as for the overall idea what would be the negative/positive side-effects of the thirst bar?

Would there be consequences for overhydration as well as dehydration?

Thanks For support, I am extremely honored. On the negative / positive is that as you already said we will not have to stand guarding as many apples or carrots they would have more utility and it would be positive. I think it would have a sort of "saturation" as there is hunger. A point can also be positive to negative, and some to others is that with the seat bar, there would be a little more difficult.

I am also thinking of a "Dehydration Potion" like the poison potion, but I think that would make a "hunger potion" First, to stay kind of balanced know?

And thanks again for the support.

Quote from Cerroz»

I never though I'd say this, but this is the best thread about thirst I've ever seen. Excellent work on the images. Sadly, I still don't support - the hunger bar is still enough and I'd rather not have the extra management. On the bright said again, if this was added, I wouldn't complain as hard as if any other version of a thirst suggestion was implemented.

A huge no-no I'm seeing is the apple tree. Mojang wouldn't make apples somewhat rare and then just add a tree specifically for them.

I also want to mention that if you "break the barrier" with an idea that's generally hated with excellent details, it might go in the suggestions hall of fame.

Thank you for real, it was my first thread that gave hard, stayed up late doing any of these images, and I'm grateful to see all this support. Hall of fame? Really? Omg ...

Quote from megabyte12345»

That's true. Remember why muskets got up there?

Actually, you know, with a bit of polishing, this may be a hall-of-fame-worthy suggestion. (in my opinion)

Oh man, fame hall? I did not think this idea could be considered all that, but thanks for the great support.

[deleted]

Quote from The_Strange_Traveler»

Very well thought out suggestion, I think this will make people have to prepare more for going out on an adventure. Also, people will have to think before filling up your inventory with baked potatoes. I just think that the cup of water, orange juice and lemon juice fill up to much of the thirst bar.

Support.

Thanks for the support :D. Yes people would have to prepare much before making any adventure. Your suggestion is that the juices are too fill the bar and they were "diminished"?

No support. Two reasons:

Food is already too common. We don't need more ways to get food faster. If anything, we need less food.

Thirst is just a copy/pasted hunger bar that shifts around food desirability a little bit. I suppose that it does balance out the foods a little bit, but having to memorize a new system just for the purpose of balancing the current micromanaging is too much for too little effect. It is a clever new way to present an old idea in a way that isn't stupid, but it still makes things more complicated than they need to be.

I gotta say im a fan! Full Support.