Minecraft Forums

Quote from DiamondSwordSlayers»

One more question, will it resemble the types of wagons the old areon settlers used with the white cloth as a roof or will it be open?

I had in mind an open top wagon, but this idea isn't for me, this is for everyone. I want everyone to be satisfied with it.

Nice idea. Simple, yet, effective. Support.

Hey, I have been looking into 3d modeling and I decided to try my first project. I made a few renders of what I thought that the wagon would possibly look like.

http://imgur.com/a/mVUoJ#0

Quote from Ivya»

Hey, I have been looking into 3d modeling and I decided to try my first project. I made a few renders of what I thought that the wagon would possibly look like.

http://imgur.com/a/mVUoJ#0

Oh wow, that's great! Would you mind if I used that in the post, giving credit to you for the pictures?

Quote from Haldore»

Oh wow, that's great! Would you mind if I used that in the post, giving credit to you for the pictures?

Of course! I am glad you like it. I know they aren't the best so if someone else comes and makes better ones, I won't be hurt if you put them up instead.

This should be sent to mojang!

I put one of your pictures up so that everyone can see it. Again thank you for making that.

I fully support the idea of the wagon, but the textures you presented seem like they would fit better in a mod more than vanilla Minecraft (to me at least). I love how you balanced it against the minecart and I can see myself using this in my SSP world to explore, and the way you allowed it to be crafted using vanilla materials is a plus for me as well. Full support; I'm sure that, in time, I can get over the textures if it was added.

I like it. Support

Quote from Kingpin6969»

Support, I love this idea and actually makes horses useful and you can carry your chests maybe in the back so you won't have to carry it all in your inventory? Very nice idea.

Yes, in my post I said that there would be chests in the back of it for hauling stuff, they just aren't pictured in the model that Inya made for me.

Quote from S1ay3r»

I really like this idea. It's sensible, well-thought-out and overall, justifiable. As you said, what's the point of making a minecart track somewhere far far away for something which you'll quickly be done with when you could have something for efficient, but not necessarily quick, transport.

FULL SUPPORT

Thank you a lot for the constructive support! I'm glad to know people understand everything that I listed in my post as clearly as I meant it! Hopefully one day we, as a community, can get this implemented into Minecraft.

Quote from Deonyi»

I think the wagon is too large. Surely just a smallish 2-wide boat with wheels will suffice? The wheels also look a bit too detailed.

Wagons generally weren't a small item, back in the day. The picture on the OP is just a representation made by one of the supporters of this post. My original thoughts were not a covered wagon.

YES this has to be made it doesnt matter if its a mod or not

i think that there should be open top closed top (like a chuck wagon) and player transport that would be capable of transporting like 5 players and it would be covered (not quite a chuck wagon but maybe like a open walled tent ) im not sure of the crafting recipes maybe the first cart that would be crafted (the open top cart) then it would be changed by adding a furnace for the covered cart (it would have only a single chest's space but it would have a furnace and crafting table so you can cook some food since its a chuck wagon) and the player transport would be like wool or something (in a 2x2 crafting grid )

anyways in any form SUPPORT!!!!

Maybe you should have to put the chests manually in. This way players can get in the wagon if there is no chest in side it.

Quote from MrWubzy»

I fully support the idea of the wagon, but the textures you presented seem like they would fit better in a mod more than vanilla Minecraft (to me at least). I love how you balanced it against the minecart and I can see myself using this in my SSP world to explore, and the way you allowed it to be crafted using vanilla materials is a plus for me as well. Full support; I'm sure that, in time, I can get over the textures if it was added.

The textures for it were not my design, and I assure you I'd rather them not add another texture if they didn't have to. I'd much rather the texture be a wood texture that already exists in the game and for the canvas top the white wool texture could be used.
I gave a description in the OP of the intended size of the wagon that I am suggesting, a wagon without the canvas that is pictured. It will be approximately 1.5 meters tall, 2 meters wide, and 3 meters long. But this is just my idea, all suggestions are welcome, and I'm very open to changing anything if you have a better idea than mine.

Quote from Oden_The_Fish»

YES this has to be made it doesnt matter if its a mod or not

i think that there should be open top closed top (like a chuck wagon) and player transport that would be capable of transporting like 5 players and it would be covered (not quite a chuck wagon but maybe like a open walled tent ) im not sure of the crafting recipes maybe the first cart that would be crafted (the open top cart) then it would be changed by adding a furnace for the covered cart (it would have only a single chest's space but it would have a furnace and crafting table so you can cook some food since its a chuck wagon) and the player transport would be like wool or something (in a 2x2 crafting grid )

anyways in any form SUPPORT!!!!

Open top is what I'm suggesting. I don't think there needs to be multiple types of wagons for the following reasons.

This is not designed as a multiplayer transport: The recipe is expensive enough to balance out its pro's yet cheap enough that everyone could make one fairly quickly in the game if that was their goal.

Chuck wagon: You can put a furnace and a crafting table into the double chest in the open top wagon that I am suggesting and achieve the same function. So this version of the wagon would be redundant and not needed.

Quote from xtylorx»

Maybe you should have to put the chests manually in. This way players can get in the wagon if there is no chest in side it.

This is not being suggested as a multi-player transportation system. The wagon is expensive enough to balance the pros of it yet cheap enough that people can easily build one if they want to. Hence the reason the chests are part of the recipe.

So far the best wagon suggestion ever!





SUPPORT!!!

Quote from CyborgKing0»

So far the best wagon suggestion ever!





SUPPORT!!!

I thank you for your support and praise. Are there any suggestions for improving my idea any?

I'm really into this idea! Excellent thinking sir!

Full Support