The Meaning of Life, the Universe, and Everything.
Join Date:
2/19/2014
Posts:
63
Member Details
Last edit: 22 jul 2014 12:00PM
INTRODUCTION
Getting bored of cutting a tree that don't fall down? Floating trees annoy you? Well, this suggestion is for you!
RÉSUMÉ
I've been thinking about a way to implement a solution to floating trees and boring sessions of cutting wood logs: The solution is to add a "Lumberjack" enchantment. This enchantment will help you to put down a tree way more faster than before and won't be too OverPowered (See "NOTES" section for all limitations).
AUTHOR’S NOTE
Yeah, I know, it look's like Timber!/Treecapitator Forge mod. But this suggestion is an axe enchantment, not a mod. But in fact, this suggestion was inspired by this mod.
It may be redundant, but mostly all suggestion don't have enough information. This is a suggestion, it can change, it's not final. If you don't support, try to figure out if something could be done to add this.
FORMULA
Cutting Time = Number of logs above the one been cut + The one been cut
(Minimum time to cut is 5 seconds)
NOTES
Specifications and limitations of the topic.
- English is not my main language, so i'm trying my best to be clear as possible.
- All trees takes a minimum of 5 seconds to cut down.
- For 2x2 trees, it would work the same starting from what block you cut. (Ex: A 2x2 jungle tree normaly have more than 1 stack of logs. 64 * 0.5 = 32 seconds to take down the entire tree.)
- Available at level 20 on the Enchantment table or with chest loots. (But considered as a rare enchantment)
- Durability of the item lowered by the number of blocks cutted
- Ignore all logs below the one been cut.
- Doesn't cut Leaves blocks.
- Only affect trees: If you try to cut two pieces of logs you placed, it will only cut one like it does normally.
- Axe can't have "Lumberjack" enchantment and Efficiency. (Reason: Everyone could cut down an entire forest in a second.)
- Only applicable to axes.
More explanation of the Lumberjack Axe's Enchantment.
- In theses examples, the player have an Iron Axe
- It takes 0.5 seconds to cut down 1 Wood Log
Example 1:
Cutting the tree here would take a total of 1.5 secondes if you start from BLOCK 2 because of the 2 Logs block above.
(Formula: 3 * 0.5 = 1.5 sec -> Converted to 5 seconds minimum)
Example 2:
Cutting the tree here would take a total of 1.0 secondes if you start from BLOCK 3 because there is 1 Logs block above.
(Formula: 2 * 0.5 = 1.0 sec -> Converted to 5 seconds minimum)
Example 3:
Cutting the tree here would take a total of 1.5 secondes if you start from BLOCK 1 because of the 3 Logs block above.
(Formula: 4 * 0.5 = 2.0 sec -> Converted to 5 seconds minimum)
Example 4:
Cutting the Oak Log here would take a total of 0.5 secondes and only cut this block. As I recall, it should only affect trees.
List of all the supporters of this topic. TOTAL: 30
The Meaning of Life, the Universe, and Everything.
Join Date:
5/12/2012
Posts:
72
Minecraft:
lolman128
Xbox:
killer_beast209
Member Details
while this is good and bad id like to add some ideas why not make it so that it wont always totally cut a tree down sometimes it will sometimes it wont it just depends on how lucky u are and maybe add it so if u cut the tree a certain way for example not exactly at said "base" then the rest of the tree would fall but would leave a stump for minor realism
It's not that its redundant, is that it's extremely redundant.
Still though, would I support? Eh, maybe. Though if I was forced to support or not support with no in-between. I'd probably not support, seeing how painfully easy it is to get wood. From a tree that is, and not any other variant of the word.
A little OP for an enchantment even, and it takes out a lot of the hard work, which is the point, I know, but the point of Minecraft is working hard for your stuff, instant wood is in creative mode, not survival. It's not that I like cutting down my trees, in fact it is a pain, it's just that you shouldn't be able to make an axe that cuts down trees semi instantly.
I do like the idea, however, of taking advantage of the whole 'gold weapons get better enchants' thing so that you can only get the enchantment on gold weapons, which pulls the working hard bit back in since you have to work really hard to find a heap of gold to insta-chop a whole forest.
Question: how does this enchantment work with branches and 2x2 trees?
- For 2x2 trees, it would work the same starting from what block you cut. (Ex: A 2x2 jungle tree normaly have more than 1 stack of logs. 64 * 0.5 = 32 seconds + 3 secs = total of 35 seconds to take down the entire tree.)
A little OP for an enchantment even, and it takes out a lot of the hard work, which is the point, I know, but the point of Minecraft is working hard for your stuff, instant wood is in creative mode, not survival. It's not that I like cutting down my trees, in fact it is a pain, it's just that you shouldn't be able to make an axe that cuts down trees semi instantly.
I do like the idea, however, of taking advantage of the whole 'gold weapons get better enchants' thing so that you can only get the enchantment on gold weapons, which pulls the working hard bit back in since you have to work really hard to find a heap of gold to insta-chop a whole forest.
For now though, no support.
- Durability of the item lowered by the number of blocks cutted
- Doesn't cut Leaves blocks.
- Axe can't have "Lumberjack" enchantment and Efficiency. (Reason: Everyone could cut down an entire forest in a second.)
- Available at level 20 on the Enchantment table or with chest loots. (like the Infinity Enchantment)
How this would be OP? It only save you the time to get to the top of the tree to take it down. Plus, the axe lose lots of his durability. You need an enchanting table and minimum 20 levels and luck to get that enchantment and it can break easily if your Axe is not Diamond.
Minecraft is more about exploring than trying to be a real woodcutter.
And if you still think it's too OP, there's always a way to balance stuff.
(Things in bold have been added right now.)
It's not that its redundant, is that it's extremely redundant.
Still though, would I support? Eh, maybe. Though if I was forced to support or not support with no in-between. I'd probably not support, seeing how painfully easy it is to get wood. From a tree that is, and not any other variant of the word.
This suggestion has been already done, but it can't be compared. There were no information at all. Of course you'll think it's OP as hell if there's no information at all. Adding restrictions to the enchantment won't make this too OP.
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
Click to read my Music Update suggestion and support it!
I support this idea. The time it takes to take down a large jungle tree (approximately 35 seconds, as mentioned above) seems balanced, but it should take longer to take down a tree of say, 6 blocks of oak wood. It seems fairly balanced as it is now. Support!
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
I need my beautiful little egg to grow up, so please, feed it those tasty clicks! Also, regarding the adults, they'll click you.
I support this idea. The time it takes to take down a large jungle tree (approximately 35 seconds, as mentioned above) seems balanced, but it should take longer to take down a tree of say, 6 blocks of oak wood. It seems fairly balanced as it is now. Support!
Thanks! Maybe we could add a minimum time for cutting out? Like 5 seconds?
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
Click to read my Music Update suggestion and support it!
It's not that its redundant, is that it's extremely redundant.
Still though, would I support? Eh, maybe. Though if I was forced to support or not support with no in-between. I'd probably not support, seeing how painfully easy it is to get wood. From a tree that is, and not any other variant of the word.
People like you seem to use the word redundant incorrectly. This would be a redundant suggestion if the post were to say, 'There should be an enchantment that allows players to gather multiple wood blocks because we need a way to collect a lot of wood fast. Did i mention the fact that this enchantment helps you cut down trees faster and with only one swing?' But you're right in the fact that wood is so easy to get, especially with efficiency V.
Alright, dude. Can you please stop with the "it isn't redundant to me so there it's not redundant!" That's not how it works. If an idea has been posted many times, it's redundant. Hands down. No argument. No matter how it looks "in your eyes".
People like you seem to use the word redundant incorrectly. This would be a redundant suggestion if the post were to say, 'There should be an enchantment that allows players to gather multiple wood blocks because we need a way to collect a lot of wood fast. Did i mention the fact that this enchantment helps you cut down trees faster and with only one swing?' But you're right in the fact that wood is so easy to get, especially with efficiency V.
I don't think I used the term incorrectly, but I will admit he put way more effort into this kind of idea than most. The concept is the same though, as you have the ability to make an entire tree fall down.
INTRODUCTION
Getting bored of cutting a tree that don't fall down? Floating trees annoy you? Well, this suggestion is for you!
RÉSUMÉ
I've been thinking about a way to implement a solution to floating trees and boring sessions of cutting wood logs: The solution is to add a "Lumberjack" enchantment. This enchantment will help you to put down a tree way more faster than before and won't be too OverPowered (See "NOTES" section for all limitations).
AUTHOR’S NOTE
Yeah, I know, it look's like Timber!/Treecapitator Forge mod. But this suggestion is an axe enchantment, not a mod. But in fact, this suggestion was inspired by this mod.
It may be redundant, but mostly all suggestion don't have enough information. This is a suggestion, it can change, it's not final. If you don't support, try to figure out if something could be done to add this.
FORMULA
Cutting Time = Number of logs above the one been cut + The one been cut
(Minimum time to cut is 5 seconds)
NOTES
Specifications and limitations of the topic.
- All trees takes a minimum of 5 seconds to cut down.
- For 2x2 trees, it would work the same starting from what block you cut. (Ex: A 2x2 jungle tree normaly have more than 1 stack of logs. 64 * 0.5 = 32 seconds to take down the entire tree.)
- Available at level 20 on the Enchantment table or with chest loots. (But considered as a rare enchantment)
- Durability of the item lowered by the number of blocks cutted
- Ignore all logs below the one been cut.
- Doesn't cut Leaves blocks.
- Only affect trees: If you try to cut two pieces of logs you placed, it will only cut one like it does normally.
- Axe can't have "Lumberjack" enchantment and Efficiency. (Reason: Everyone could cut down an entire forest in a second.)
- Only applicable to axes.
More explanation of the Lumberjack Axe's Enchantment.
- It takes 0.5 seconds to cut down 1 Wood Log
Example 1:
Cutting the tree here would take a total of 1.5 secondes if you start from BLOCK 2 because of the 2 Logs block above.
(Formula: 3 * 0.5 = 1.5 sec -> Converted to 5 seconds minimum)
Example 2:
Cutting the tree here would take a total of 1.0 secondes if you start from BLOCK 3 because there is 1 Logs block above.
(Formula: 2 * 0.5 = 1.0 sec -> Converted to 5 seconds minimum)
Example 3:
Cutting the tree here would take a total of 1.5 secondes if you start from BLOCK 1 because of the 3 Logs block above.
(Formula: 4 * 0.5 = 2.0 sec -> Converted to 5 seconds minimum)
Example 4:
Cutting the Oak Log here would take a total of 0.5 secondes and only cut this block. As I recall, it should only affect trees.
List of all the supporters of this topic.
TOTAL: 30
Capture_Map
SteveCraftwood
Mythril
FlaminBurrito2
abpop
Gold_Two
Somethingvalid
manman122
QlyoPhil
giantmart
ShinySurskit
Diegreenluke
BaxterNickolai
LeoGaming350
nahjay3
Mightjak11
cableialikers
_LoneWolfe_
DimensionPlant
Scorpionius
medved356
stnvegs
goldenninja037
bluelighting123
Archthious
tennisdude10
Zombie Killer
gvt123
HelpfulOnion
Ningaella
You like and support my topic? Check out my Music Update topic!
PROUD USER OF THE STEVE SKIN
Also, this is in a mod already, just to let you know.
http://www.minecraftforum.net/forums/mapping-and-modding/minecraft-mods/1281180-daftpvfs-mods-treecapitator-crystalwing
Enchantments dont work like this.
Also will make wood too easy to get. You cant get an efficiency 10 pickaxe legit. Very unbalanced.
You didn't even read the suggestion.
I support this.
<div style="width:100%;height:0;padding-bottom:100%;position:relative;"><iframe src="https://giphy.com/embed/smwSn7S9RYIoM" width="100%" height="100%" style="position:absolute" frameBorder="0" class="giphy-embed" allowFullScreen></iframe></div><p><a href="https://giphy.com/gifs/smwSn7S9RYIoM">via GIPHY</a></p>
It's not that its redundant, is that it's extremely redundant.
Still though, would I support? Eh, maybe. Though if I was forced to support or not support with no in-between. I'd probably not support, seeing how painfully easy it is to get wood. From a tree that is, and not any other variant of the word.
I do like the idea, however, of taking advantage of the whole 'gold weapons get better enchants' thing so that you can only get the enchantment on gold weapons, which pulls the working hard bit back in since you have to work really hard to find a heap of gold to insta-chop a whole forest.
For now though, no support.
- For 2x2 trees, it would work the same starting from what block you cut. (Ex: A 2x2 jungle tree normaly have more than 1 stack of logs. 64 * 0.5 = 32 seconds + 3 secs = total of 35 seconds to take down the entire tree.)
- Durability of the item lowered by the number of blocks cutted
- Doesn't cut Leaves blocks.
- Axe can't have "Lumberjack" enchantment and Efficiency. (Reason: Everyone could cut down an entire forest in a second.)
- Available at level 20 on the Enchantment table or with chest loots. (like the Infinity Enchantment)
How this would be OP? It only save you the time to get to the top of the tree to take it down. Plus, the axe lose lots of his durability. You need an enchanting table and minimum 20 levels and luck to get that enchantment and it can break easily if your Axe is not Diamond.
Minecraft is more about exploring than trying to be a real woodcutter.
And if you still think it's too OP, there's always a way to balance stuff.
(Things in bold have been added right now.)
This suggestion has been already done, but it can't be compared. There were no information at all. Of course you'll think it's OP as hell if there's no information at all. Adding restrictions to the enchantment won't make this too OP.
I need my beautiful little egg to grow up, so please, feed it those tasty clicks! Also, regarding the adults, they'll click you.Thanks! Maybe we could add a minimum time for cutting out? Like 5 seconds?
People like you seem to use the word redundant incorrectly. This would be a redundant suggestion if the post were to say, 'There should be an enchantment that allows players to gather multiple wood blocks because we need a way to collect a lot of wood fast. Did i mention the fact that this enchantment helps you cut down trees faster and with only one swing?' But you're right in the fact that wood is so easy to get, especially with efficiency V.
Alright, dude. Can you please stop with the "it isn't redundant to me so there it's not redundant!" That's not how it works. If an idea has been posted many times, it's redundant. Hands down. No argument. No matter how it looks "in your eyes".
I don't think I used the term incorrectly, but I will admit he put way more effort into this kind of idea than most. The concept is the same though, as you have the ability to make an entire tree fall down.