Just as the Title says I will be reviewing maps and being brutally honest in my reviews, which means i will not sugarcoat anything. I will be reviewing all types of maps, puzzle, CTM, Survival, adventure, etc.
I will be reviewing each map on a scale of 1 -25 and it will be broken up into 5 different categories: Gameplay, Atmosphere, Progression, Creativity, and Storyline. Here is how each will be broken up into
5 - Gameplay wanted to keep me going, Had a lot of fun playing this map. Amazing
4 - Good gameplay mechanics. Parts could use improvement, but I had fun.
3 - Some gameplay mechanics are already commonly used. Needs more originality
2 - Needs improvement. Needs to be changed.
1 - Could not handle playing your map. Please change or delete
5 - Atmosphere was refreshing to view. Loved looking at the map. Very appealing
4 - Map looks great, can see you put some time and effort into making it, just some small errors
3 - Decently good, but can tell that you just went over vanilla minecraft. Nothing new
2 - Bad, attempts to change the map were lacking. Really not good to look at
1 - Horrible. Almost threw up looking at this map
5 - Pacing was perfect. Had linear progression from Easy to Hard. No random difficulty spikes or Overpowered items in the beginning
4 - The map was fun but not perfect, had some random difficulty spikes
3 - Progressed through the map relatively easy, never got difficult at all.
2 - Needs more improvement. The Map creator needs to spend more time and effort into maps.
1 - Way to Easy or Impossible to complete no inbetween at all, please rework your map
5 - Story kept me interested the entire time. Absolutely loved it, cant wait to play a squeal
4 - Story was great and original, great way to keep a person hooked
3 - Maps story is exciting, but nothing new, please become more original
2 - Story was a copy and paste from another map
1 - So much little thought was put into this map, that I would amazed that the creator would think it would be good
5 - It is clear to see that the map creator put so much time and effort into each and every part of the map. The originality is off the charts here. Please play this map for this rating alone
4 - Map creator put a lot of time into the map, Looks great, no complaints
3 - Map originality is good, but needs improvement
2 - Please become a little more creative with your map, think of better puzzles, make bigger structures. Do not be simple
1 - Horrible, copy and paste from another map, no thought put into this at all
Map Creators: Please use these ratings as motivation to improve your map, or if you like your rating please use this on your topic to show it off.
Please Post in this thread an application for the map you want using this format:
Name of Map:
Name of Map Creator:
Genre of Map:
Estimated time of completion of map:
Link to the map: