@Panda, I got to talk to the judges, I haven't evens seen some of them online in a while; If need be I will need to look for another judge,
So judging won't start yet, I'm going to wait until Sunday mid-day and make a list of all the entrys, get the judges to give there results, and bam it will be done
After this I do want to host another contest with the success of this one, it will be a bit smaller, and Halloween themed (kind of)
I've already made the write up for the next contest, I'm going to start it off soon.
Hint; its Halloween related, and its not a common thing you see with skins (but at the same time possible). The next contest will also be story based, but not as heavily as this one was suppose to be.
Also, if your intrested in judging, please let me know. I'm going to make a list of entrys and put them on the front post after I'm done making a skin
I've already made the write up for the next contest, I'm going to start it off soon.
Hint; its Halloween related, and its not a common thing you see with skins (but at the same time possible). The next contest will also be story based, but not as heavily as this one was suppose to be.
Also, if your intrested in judging, please let me know. I'm going to make a list of entrys and put them on the front post after I'm done making a skin
I would like to be a judge :biggrin.gif:
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
When light fades, darkness shall rise from the depths of the world and consume all.
wait this contest is over dang it(oh well my skin probably wouldnt work since all the skin eitors i know have pre made skins.does miners need cool shoes work in this contest?)
Contest is about done guys, unless you want 10 points off your entry dont bother.
Next contest will probley be announced this Friday, so look for that.
Heres a hint; its Halloween related, and that is themed to a "darker" theme. I need judges for this one two, so if your intrested ask right now (I need to see some proof of fourm activity and good skin-making if you want to do this)
14 people, I thank you for entering in the contest; I will ask the judges to follow my scale and all.
Creativity (10) - Do you have some nice creative input?
Descriptive (10) - Do you have nice background information on your characters and story?
Quality (10) - Are your skins decent?
is how the judging will work
I will have the due dates from the judges be Wensday, so whoever gives a score to me on each of the skin will need to go by this scale.
(It will probably take an hour or two at most)
There is no prizes as I'm broke and can't do much but plug you in my thread if I haven't done so yet. (With a custom icon and everything)
14 people, I thank you for entering in the contest; I will ask the judges to follow my scale and all.
Creativity (10) - Do you have some nice creative input?
Descriptive (10) - Do you have nice background information on your characters and story?
Quality (10) - Are your skins decent?
is how the judging will work
I will have the due dates from the judges be Wensday, so whoever gives a score to me on each of the skin will need to go by this scale.
(It will probably take an hour or two at most)
There is no prizes as I'm broke and can't do much but plug you in my thread if I haven't done so yet. (With a custom icon and everything)
Thank you all for entering!
holy crap i did horrible :sad.gif: i thought my skins would of been third
14 people, I thank you for entering in the contest; I will ask the judges to follow my scale and all.
Creativity (10) - Do you have some nice creative input?
Descriptive (10) - Do you have nice background information on your characters and story?
Quality (10) - Are your skins decent?
is how the judging will work
I will have the due dates from the judges be Wensday, so whoever gives a score to me on each of the skin will need to go by this scale.
(It will probably take an hour or two at most)
There is no prizes as I'm broke and can't do much but plug you in my thread if I haven't done so yet. (With a custom icon and everything)
Thank you all for entering!
I'm a little confused. Are those our scores at the top?
Also: I would like to be a judge for the next contest.
I got rather busy and was unable to compete in this. Had to take care of a friend's cat while he is celebrating his honeymoon with his lovely new wife, and then I also just got promoted to Moderator of Planet Minecraft. By the way, we intend to start launching official contests over there, TwiDragon.
I got rather busy and was unable to compete in this. Had to take care of a friend's cat while he is celebrating his honeymoon with his lovely new wife, and then I also just got promoted to Moderator of Planet Minecraft. By the way, we intend to start launching official contests over there, TwiDragon.
@studnicky - tell your friends that I wish them a happy marriage! Also grats on the moderator position!
I actually did have this up on PMC, but it never got any notice. However, I do look over there some times for a contest, not frequently, but I will go there a bit more if need be :3
I got rather busy and was unable to compete in this. Had to take care of a friend's cat while he is celebrating his honeymoon with his lovely new wife, and then I also just got promoted to Moderator of Planet Minecraft. By the way, we intend to start launching official contests over there, TwiDragon.
so that's where you have been. well congrats to your friend, and congrats on making Mod on Planet Minecraft. Hope you guys don't get irritated with how much trash gets flagged a day.
and you are also launching a contest? wouldn't it make more sense to time these things to be consecutive to not take entries from each other?
Panda
Creativity: 4/10
Description: 5/10
Quality: 4/10
Total: 13/30
Kool41d - scored lowest
Creativity: 1/10
Description: 3/10
Quality: 1/10
Total: 4/30
Comments: Completely unoriginal idea and character designs which he just ripped off the anime Gundam Wing. It would have been better if he came up with his own story and characters for a starter.
Witten - scored highest
Creativity: 8/10
Description: 6/10
Quality: 7/10
Total: 21/30
Comments: Witten was pretty orginal with his ideas. While everyone else with with a generic World of Warcraft theme, Witten used an actual Minecraft world. His art was also pretty detailed and he gave a very straight forward summary of his characters.
If you're posting our individual judgements then add that I'm a video game developer and programmer who started off producing RPG titles that have been praised for originality and good writing
ADEBAR - 15/30 Creativity 3
Rather generic, no interesting points Descriptive 5
Full descriptions into backstory with open endings, cliche Quality 4
Features are mixed, incorrect usage of detail, no logical shading at all, no differential shading, faces are out of proportion, skin tones too drastic
JaPwnagePanda - 17/30 Creativity 6
Widely different, lots of unique features Descriptive 5
Wasn't interesting, cliche Quality 6
Noise rarely used (This is a plus), proportions mostly correct, no shading at all, some skins lack detail
K00L4ID - 14/30 Creativity 4
Despite all-human party, the characters show uniqueness in design toward each other Descriptive 6
Interesting, but cliche Quality 4
Skins are a mess of pixels, trying too hard to show detail, faces out of proportion, but has some attempt at logical shading
roxthesox - 18/30 Creativity 6
All quite original Descriptive 6
Too much unneeded detail making it longer than needed, some characters have original ideas Quality 6
All skins try to be unique, no logical shading, clever use of skins, some incorrect usage of the lower torso.
macreddin - 18/30 Creativity 6
All the characters fit nicely as a party with uniqueness among them Descriptive 6
Good size to read and keep interested, but not much detail on how they met as a group Qualilty 6
Used the ambient occlusion for good logical shading, but uses it too strongly! Some incorrect usage of the lower torso, skins seem to have a mess of noise slapped over them which ruined them
Woop_Woop - 13/30 Creativity 3
Palette doesn't extend very far, designs share too many similarities, not much thought into design Descriptive 5
Wasn't interesting and is cliche Quality 5
Good use of hat layer, no logical lighting, textures are a mess of pixels, some creases would have looked good
KaboomyWizard - 13/30 Creativity 2
Boy and girl generics plus a scientist Descriptive 8
Chunky descriptions made it good to read, got a nice sense of personality from characters without the waffle of back story, "mad scientist" is rather cliche Quality 3
Skin tones entirely wrong, no shading at all, noise slapped over, incorrect usage of lower torso, scientist doesn't look like one, but faces are in proportion
wittenkwirk - 20/30 Creativity 7
Unique ideas here, very original Descriptive 7
Easy to read, obviously written to work in the Minecraft world, fun to read too Quality 6
I can see what they are which is good, faces are badly out of proportion, no shading at all, noise used, but the colours used are absolutely brilliant, unfortunately uses full black which isn't good with MC's lighting engine
DasIchHalt - 17/30 Creativity 5
Cliche ideas, but stays fun Descriptive 5
Cliche, not very interesting to read Quality 7
Directional shading is used very slightly, but the colours are too broad in palette and skins seem messy with noise, skin tones are a bit odd too
Hanuik - 19/30 Creativity 7
Cliche, but very well thought out Descriptive 6
Reading descriptions is fun and interesting, the descriptions work with each other too, good back story, I can see this description working in a real RPG scenario Quality 6
Some evidence of logical shading, but really isn't much, clothing detail very good, but too much noise created from usage of effects, I really liked looking at them though, they work well together and colours are well used. Face detail is to harsh
Zeldaguy64 - 21/30 - My top scorer Creativity 8
Some super unique and original ideas here! Some cliche though Descriptive 6
Well thought-through, difficult to read, but works with each other nicely Quality 7
I can see what they are, colour palettes not broad enough, good shading used, good use of hat layer, all-round excellent, let down by the Milky 3 using fully black and white colours, not good with Minecraft's lighting engine
geesegeese - 14/30 Creativity 4
Only some of the characters show uniqueness in design Descriptive 6
Engaging descriptions, easy to read, good to read, some hints of cliche Quality 4
Mouths are massive! Good use of logical lighting, but too much noise, no broad colour palette with some of them (Skin tones are weird), skins look too similar, and some don't look too much like their title
JaxTuren - 17/30 Creativity 6
Brilliant ideas with the first 4 characters Descriptive 5
Easy to read, but at least some information on the knight would have been good, wouldn't work very well in a real RPG scenario Quality 6
The king is very good, no logical shading on any skins, too much noise used on some, colours are too weak with others, lots of detail put into clothes
camo7 - 11/30 - My lowest scorer Creativity 1
All based on the Halo universe, not much thought given into designs Descriptive 4
As a Bungie fan myself, these do not do justice to the Bungie mythos and the characters aren't too interesting, they're as interesting as a B.o.B. Quality 6
I can tell what they are which is good, some logical shading was attempted, faces lack detail, the alternative McKenzie skin was a good idea, skins are mostly edits and recolours of each other. Steven is related to Steve.
Kaboomy - 11
C - 1
D - 4
Q - 6
Had nothing original to add, very bland. I can't see these charachters being in a game. The skins are generic and there isn't a good story to go with them.
Witten - 24
C - 8
D - 9
Q - 7
Great skins you got there, you were really descriptive, and you executed everything nicly. There was a few problems with some cliches and shading, but there tiny problems that can be looked passed.
DasIchHalt - 16
C - 5
D - 5
Q - 6
Hanuik - 21
c - 6
D - 8
Q - 7
ZeldaGuy - 21
C - 7
D - 8
Q - 6
Adebar - 19
C 5
D 9
Q 5
GeeseGeese - 19
C - 7
D - 4
Q - 8
Jax - 17
C - 5
D - 3
Q - 9
Camo - 14
C - 1
D - 6
Q - 7
iEirikra
(Note from Twi - Her math got screwed up a bit, I fxied it when adding scores) Adebar - 15 http://www.minecraft...70#entry8764770 Creativity 8/10 - characters and names are creative, they do not look alike or anything like that... and someone really needs creativity to write that much for background story xD
Descriptive 5/10 - honestly: i didnt read them... they are waaay too big and i dont have enough time, background information needs to be brief...
Quality 2/10 - no shadows, needs texture for skin and hair and better texture for clothing, most of the colors he used are awful (they are do-not-touch-for-skins, like the green on the skin of Gur'thok or the blue on Kayther)....
Kaboomy - 4 http://www.minecraft...30#entry8666730 Creativity 1/10
Descriptive 1/10
Quality 2/10 Really? 1 boy, 1 girl, a scientist....
skins: no shadow, skin is just plain pink, really common, no originality... the only good thing is some parts of the clothing... story: cliche... nothing new... he didnt put effort on this ._.
Zeldaguy - 33 http://www.minecraft...33#entry8723133 Creativity 9/10
Descriptive 8/10
Quality 8/10 Really original skins and nicely done, the description had some cliche but its ok, it made me laugh some times xD and yeah... i really liked it (:
(Sorry, i would add more but I dont have enough time :c )
geesegees 24 http://www.minecraft...63#entry8770063 Creativity 7/10
Descriptive 10/10 - really really nice c: I enjoyed reading it... it was simple and interesting
Quality 7/10 - no shadowing, nice texture for skin, clothing and hair, liked the no-eye effect on the zombie, didnt liked the black&white effect on female warrior and male rogue tho
JaxTuren - 15 http://www.minecraft...47#entry8807147 Creativity 6/10 - nice ideas, tho it needs to improve the way he expose them
Descriptive 3/10
Quality 6/10 - it seems like he tried to make some shadowing but it needs work on the half of the skins. same face and hair (just different side) for Valora Percival and Jaden Navarro. the armor looks more like clothing than metal..
camo7 - 14 http://www.minecraft...96#entry8827196 Creativity 1/10 - Halo all over again.
Descriptive 6/10
Quality 7/10 - they are great but the only thing that changes between the men are the colors... miss shading...
Thank you all for joining; I'm sorry there is no big prize or anything, but I hope you all had fun!
I hope to see you all again on the Halloween contest that will start this friday!
lol (Note from Twi - Her math got screwed up a bit, I fxied it when adding scores)
sorry for that... maybe i forgot to change the total score when i modified some of the individual ones....
oh and P.S. english is not my native language soo... maybe some things i said are confusing, sorry for that too 'n.n
So judging won't start yet, I'm going to wait until Sunday mid-day and make a list of all the entrys, get the judges to give there results, and bam it will be done
After this I do want to host another contest with the success of this one, it will be a bit smaller, and Halloween themed (kind of)
Hint; its Halloween related, and its not a common thing you see with skins (but at the same time possible). The next contest will also be story based, but not as heavily as this one was suppose to be.
Also, if your intrested in judging, please let me know. I'm going to make a list of entrys and put them on the front post after I'm done making a skin
I would like to be a judge :biggrin.gif:
Oh well next contest will do...
Next contest will probley be announced this Friday, so look for that.
Heres a hint; its Halloween related, and that is themed to a "darker" theme. I need judges for this one two, so if your intrested ask right now (I need to see some proof of fourm activity and good skin-making if you want to do this)
pt 41pt127-Panda - pt 59
-Kool41d - pt 61
-roxthesox - pt 81
-maccreddin - pt84
-Woop_Woop - pt85
-Kaboomy - pt93
-Witten - pt97
-DasIchHalt - pt102
-Hanuik - pt108
-Zeldaguy - pt115
-geesegees - pt128
-JaxTuren - pt113
-camo7 - pt136
14 people, I thank you for entering in the contest; I will ask the judges to follow my scale and all.
Creativity (10) - Do you have some nice creative input?
Descriptive (10) - Do you have nice background information on your characters and story?
Quality (10) - Are your skins decent?
is how the judging will work
I will have the due dates from the judges be Wensday, so whoever gives a score to me on each of the skin will need to go by this scale.
(It will probably take an hour or two at most)
There is no prizes as I'm broke and can't do much but plug you in my thread if I haven't done so yet. (With a custom icon and everything)
Thank you all for entering!
holy crap i did horrible :sad.gif: i thought my skins would of been third
I'm a little confused. Are those our scores at the top?
Also: I would like to be a judge for the next contest.
Like a bawss.
Also, the contests sound bawss.
@studnicky - tell your friends that I wish them a happy marriage! Also grats on the moderator position!
I actually did have this up on PMC, but it never got any notice. However, I do look over there some times for a contest, not frequently, but I will go there a bit more if need be :3
I plan on having the results by Wensday - Friday.
so that's where you have been. well congrats to your friend, and congrats on making Mod on Planet Minecraft. Hope you guys don't get irritated with how much trash gets flagged a day.
and you are also launching a contest? wouldn't it make more sense to time these things to be consecutive to not take entries from each other?
SO EXITED. :smile.gif:
Judges
Me
Varuna
xilefian
iEirikra
I will place the comments of each Judges highest and lowest score
NOTE - These are rounded.
Witten - 22/30 [1ST PLACE]
Zeldaguy - 22/30 [1ST PLACE]
Roxthesox - 21/30 [2ND PLACE]
Adebar - 17/30 [3RD PLACE]
Hanuik - 17/30 [3RD PLACE]
geesegees - 17/10 [3RD PLACE]
Panda - 16/30
Maccreddin - 15/30
Woop_Woop - 15/30
KoolKid - 14/30
JaxTuren - 14/30
DasIchHalt - 13/30
camo7 - 13/30
Kaboomy - 9/30 [LAST PLACE]
Here is what the judges said; I just cut this out of there PMs to me, so here
Varuna
Creativity: 6/10
Description: 7/10
Quality: 5/10
Total: 18/30
Panda
Creativity: 4/10
Description: 5/10
Quality: 4/10
Total: 13/30
Kool41d - scored lowest
Creativity: 1/10
Description: 3/10
Quality: 1/10
Total: 4/30
Comments: Completely unoriginal idea and character designs which he just ripped off the anime Gundam Wing. It would have been better if he came up with his own story and characters for a starter.
roxthesox:
Creativity: 5/10
Description: 7/10
Quality: 6/10
Total: 18/30
Maccreddin
Creativity: 2/10
Description: 2/10
Quality: 6/10
Total: 10/30
Woop_Woop
Creativity: 4/10
Description: 4/10
Quality: 4/10
Total: 12/30
Kaboomy
None of his links work?
Witten - scored highest
Creativity: 8/10
Description: 6/10
Quality: 7/10
Total: 21/30
Comments: Witten was pretty orginal with his ideas. While everyone else with with a generic World of Warcraft theme, Witten used an actual Minecraft world. His art was also pretty detailed and he gave a very straight forward summary of his characters.
DasIchHalt
Creativity: 1/10
Description: 1/10
Quality: 3/10
Total: 5/30
Hanuik
Creativity: 3/10
Description: 4/10
Quality: 6/10
Total: 13/30
Zeldaguy
Creativity: 6/10
Description: 6/10
Quality: 7/10
Total: 19/30
Geesegeese:
Creativity: 2/10
Description: 3/10
Quality: 4/10
Total: 9/30
JaxTuren
Creativity: 1/10
Description: 2/10
Quality: 4/10
Total: 7/30
camo7
Creativity: 1/10
Description: 5/10
Quality: 6/10
Total: 12/30
xilefian
ADEBAR - 15/30
Creativity 3
Rather generic, no interesting points
Descriptive 5
Full descriptions into backstory with open endings, cliche
Quality 4
Features are mixed, incorrect usage of detail, no logical shading at all, no differential shading, faces are out of proportion, skin tones too drastic
JaPwnagePanda - 17/30
Creativity 6
Widely different, lots of unique features
Descriptive 5
Wasn't interesting, cliche
Quality 6
Noise rarely used (This is a plus), proportions mostly correct, no shading at all, some skins lack detail
K00L4ID - 14/30
Creativity 4
Despite all-human party, the characters show uniqueness in design toward each other
Descriptive 6
Interesting, but cliche
Quality 4
Skins are a mess of pixels, trying too hard to show detail, faces out of proportion, but has some attempt at logical shading
roxthesox - 18/30
Creativity 6
All quite original
Descriptive 6
Too much unneeded detail making it longer than needed, some characters have original ideas
Quality 6
All skins try to be unique, no logical shading, clever use of skins, some incorrect usage of the lower torso.
macreddin - 18/30
Creativity 6
All the characters fit nicely as a party with uniqueness among them
Descriptive 6
Good size to read and keep interested, but not much detail on how they met as a group
Qualilty 6
Used the ambient occlusion for good logical shading, but uses it too strongly! Some incorrect usage of the lower torso, skins seem to have a mess of noise slapped over them which ruined them
Woop_Woop - 13/30
Creativity 3
Palette doesn't extend very far, designs share too many similarities, not much thought into design
Descriptive 5
Wasn't interesting and is cliche
Quality 5
Good use of hat layer, no logical lighting, textures are a mess of pixels, some creases would have looked good
KaboomyWizard - 13/30
Creativity 2
Boy and girl generics plus a scientist
Descriptive 8
Chunky descriptions made it good to read, got a nice sense of personality from characters without the waffle of back story, "mad scientist" is rather cliche
Quality 3
Skin tones entirely wrong, no shading at all, noise slapped over, incorrect usage of lower torso, scientist doesn't look like one, but faces are in proportion
wittenkwirk - 20/30
Creativity 7
Unique ideas here, very original
Descriptive 7
Easy to read, obviously written to work in the Minecraft world, fun to read too
Quality 6
I can see what they are which is good, faces are badly out of proportion, no shading at all, noise used, but the colours used are absolutely brilliant, unfortunately uses full black which isn't good with MC's lighting engine
DasIchHalt - 17/30
Creativity 5
Cliche ideas, but stays fun
Descriptive 5
Cliche, not very interesting to read
Quality 7
Directional shading is used very slightly, but the colours are too broad in palette and skins seem messy with noise, skin tones are a bit odd too
Hanuik - 19/30
Creativity 7
Cliche, but very well thought out
Descriptive 6
Reading descriptions is fun and interesting, the descriptions work with each other too, good back story, I can see this description working in a real RPG scenario
Quality 6
Some evidence of logical shading, but really isn't much, clothing detail very good, but too much noise created from usage of effects, I really liked looking at them though, they work well together and colours are well used. Face detail is to harsh
Zeldaguy64 - 21/30 - My top scorer
Creativity 8
Some super unique and original ideas here! Some cliche though
Descriptive 6
Well thought-through, difficult to read, but works with each other nicely
Quality 7
I can see what they are, colour palettes not broad enough, good shading used, good use of hat layer, all-round excellent, let down by the Milky 3 using fully black and white colours, not good with Minecraft's lighting engine
geesegeese - 14/30
Creativity 4
Only some of the characters show uniqueness in design
Descriptive 6
Engaging descriptions, easy to read, good to read, some hints of cliche
Quality 4
Mouths are massive! Good use of logical lighting, but too much noise, no broad colour palette with some of them (Skin tones are weird), skins look too similar, and some don't look too much like their title
JaxTuren - 17/30
Creativity 6
Brilliant ideas with the first 4 characters
Descriptive 5
Easy to read, but at least some information on the knight would have been good, wouldn't work very well in a real RPG scenario
Quality 6
The king is very good, no logical shading on any skins, too much noise used on some, colours are too weak with others, lots of detail put into clothes
camo7 - 11/30 - My lowest scorer
Creativity 1
All based on the Halo universe, not much thought given into designs
Descriptive 4
As a Bungie fan myself, these do not do justice to the Bungie mythos and the characters aren't too interesting, they're as interesting as a B.o.B.
Quality 6
I can tell what they are which is good, some logical shading was attempted, faces lack detail, the alternative McKenzie skin was a good idea, skins are mostly edits and recolours of each other. Steven is related to Steve.
Twidragon/Me
-Creativity - 4
-Descriptive - 6
-Quality - 7
Kool4ID - 18
-C - 7
-D - 6
-q - 5
Roxthesox - 23
-C-9
-D-7
-Q-7
Macreddin - 18
-C - 6
- D - 6
- Q - 6
WoopWoop - 18
C - 7
D - 5
Q - 6
Kaboomy - 11
C - 1
D - 4
Q - 6
Had nothing original to add, very bland. I can't see these charachters being in a game. The skins are generic and there isn't a good story to go with them.
Witten - 24
C - 8
D - 9
Q - 7
Great skins you got there, you were really descriptive, and you executed everything nicly. There was a few problems with some cliches and shading, but there tiny problems that can be looked passed.
DasIchHalt - 16
C - 5
D - 5
Q - 6
Hanuik - 21
c - 6
D - 8
Q - 7
ZeldaGuy - 21
C - 7
D - 8
Q - 6
Adebar - 19
C 5
D 9
Q 5
GeeseGeese - 19
C - 7
D - 4
Q - 8
Jax - 17
C - 5
D - 3
Q - 9
Camo - 14
C - 1
D - 6
Q - 7
iEirikra
Adebar - 15
http://www.minecraft...70#entry8764770
Creativity 8/10 - characters and names are creative, they do not look alike or anything like that... and someone really needs creativity to write that much for background story xD
Descriptive 5/10 - honestly: i didnt read them... they are waaay too big and i dont have enough time, background information needs to be brief...
Quality 2/10 - no shadows, needs texture for skin and hair and better texture for clothing, most of the colors he used are awful (they are do-not-touch-for-skins, like the green on the skin of Gur'thok or the blue on Kayther)....
Panda - 18
http://www.minecraft...39#entry8467139
Creativity 6/10
Descriptive 6/10
Quality 4/10
Kool41d - 19
http://www.minecraft...53#entry8474753
Creativity 6/10
Descriptive 7/10
Quality 6/10
roxthesox - 23
http://www.minecraft...75#entry8582175
Creativity 8/10
Descriptive 8/10
Quality 7/10
maccreddin - 15
http://www.minecraft...28#entry8610728
Creativity 5/10
Descriptive 6/10
Quality 4/10
Woop_Woop - 18
http://www.minecraft...45#entry8616745
Creativity 6/10
Descriptive 4/10
Quality 6/10
Kaboomy - 4
http://www.minecraft...30#entry8666730
Creativity 1/10
Descriptive 1/10
Quality 2/10
Really? 1 boy, 1 girl, a scientist....
skins: no shadow, skin is just plain pink, really common, no originality... the only good thing is some parts of the clothing... story: cliche... nothing new... he didnt put effort on this ._.
Witten - 32
http://www.minecraft...86#entry8673686
Creativity 8/10
Descriptive 8/10
Quality 8/10
DasIchHalt - 13
http://www.minecraft...82#entry8687782
Creativity 3/10
Descriptive 3/10
Quality 7/10
Hanuik - 21
http://www.minecraft...06#entry8710206
Creativity 6/10
Descriptive 7/10
Quality 8/10
Zeldaguy - 33
http://www.minecraft...33#entry8723133
Creativity 9/10
Descriptive 8/10
Quality 8/10
Really original skins and nicely done, the description had some cliche but its ok, it made me laugh some times xD and yeah... i really liked it (:
(Sorry, i would add more but I dont have enough time :c )
geesegees 24
http://www.minecraft...63#entry8770063
Creativity 7/10
Descriptive 10/10 - really really nice c: I enjoyed reading it... it was simple and interesting
Quality 7/10 - no shadowing, nice texture for skin, clothing and hair, liked the no-eye effect on the zombie, didnt liked the black&white effect on female warrior and male rogue tho
JaxTuren - 15
http://www.minecraft...47#entry8807147
Creativity 6/10 - nice ideas, tho it needs to improve the way he expose them
Descriptive 3/10
Quality 6/10 - it seems like he tried to make some shadowing but it needs work on the half of the skins. same face and hair (just different side) for Valora Percival and Jaden Navarro. the armor looks more like clothing than metal..
camo7 - 14
http://www.minecraft...96#entry8827196
Creativity 1/10 - Halo all over again.
Descriptive 6/10
Quality 7/10 - they are great but the only thing that changes between the men are the colors... miss shading...
Thank you all for joining; I'm sorry there is no big prize or anything, but I hope you all had fun!
I hope to see you all again on the Halloween contest that will start this friday!
sorry for that... maybe i forgot to change the total score when i modified some of the individual ones....
oh and P.S. english is not my native language soo... maybe some things i said are confusing, sorry for that too 'n.n