Wow really, your going to decide if you should disable it in SMP by a poll? This should be up to server owners and not the players. Obviously alot more players will be voting then server owners, so this is a complete fail.
SMP already has mods that the server owners can install that allows players to spawn stuff. If they run a legit server, this is considered a hack, plain and simple. So please don't use a poll to make this decision.
And I would suggest a Minecraft Forum mod/admin to removed this thread if he doesn't disable it in SMP in the next version. I thought these forums didn't support SMP hacks?
Edit: Just wanted to quote something from the "Read Before Posting" thread.
NEVER:
Post Illegal Activity:
- Anything referring to Minecraft hacks;
- Any link or reference to third-party clients or game interfaces;
SMP already has mods that the server owners can install that allows players to spawn stuff.
SSP does not.
If a server hasn't taken the initiative to start anti-griefing and anti-hack scripts, I'd say this mod is the least of their worries.
This is not a multiplayer mod.
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
Quote from VIROS »
It is the equivalent of saying
"We should add drug trafficking to the game to attract more Mexicans. I'm not saying that I'm racist, it is just that most Mexicans traffic drugs."
SMP already has mods that the server owners can install that allows players to spawn stuff.
SSP does not.
If a server hasn't taken the initiative to start anti-griefing and anti-hack scripts, I'd say this mod is the least of their worries.
This is not a multiplayer mod.
I never said this mod should be removed completely, this mod is great for SSP and I'm sure at some point I will use it on SSP. However it IS a SMP mod, it has been tested to work on SMP, therefore it is an SMP/SSP mod. The SMP side of this mod should be considered a hack and I feel the creator of this mod should disable it in SMP and not simply leave the decision up to a poll voted on by the players.
The SMP side of the mod is clearly a hack and there really is no debating that. But if this mod continues to work on SMP after the next version, it should be removed from the forums until it has been disable in SMP. If SMP inventory hacks are allowed on the forums then where is the line drawn for posting hacks on the forums?
And please by all means, point me to some anti-hacking server mod that would stop this hack.
Also I just want to point out, I am by no means a mod/admin here on the forums, I'm just simply voicing my concern for keeping SMP safe from hackers. If people want to disagree with me on that issue, fine. But I will fight back.
Edit: Just thought of a good way to fix this problem. Why not make it so that when someone uses this mod on SMP it simply issues and spawn item command instead. That way if server admins have installed a mod that allows for item spawning, this mod will continue to work on SMP. However if the server admins are running a legit server without item spawning, it wont work.
I'm well aware you're not a mod, and running in here waving around the rulebook like a kindergartner tattling on someone eating glue is obnoxious at best. Adopting an attitude of lofty snobbishness isn't really appreciated, ever.
"but i wasn't snobbish" Sarcastic rhetorical questions and mini-modding fit the bill. If it causes multiplayer problems, okay. Just come in, mention that it's being used as a griefing tool, and leave it at that. You don't have to start a mini-crusade to get everything shut down.
Slightly more on-topic; Could you add feathers to the spawn list? They're absent, and it'd be nice to have them for custom arrow purposes.
Then again, if you've got an add-by-ID method in the works, I guess that request doesn't really matter.
Also, the kit idea sounds pretty damn handy. I hope it works out.
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
Quote from VIROS »
It is the equivalent of saying
"We should add drug trafficking to the game to attract more Mexicans. I'm not saying that I'm racist, it is just that most Mexicans traffic drugs."
Ok this is going out ofcontrol, I never intended it to work with SMP.The poll majority says No, so I will make it disable in SMP.OR I can make logs appear in console.
You don't have to start a mini-crusade to get everything shut down.
I'm sorry but I feel like I do since the poll is 24 to 15 (Currently). 24 in favor of NOT disabling it in SMP. I'm sorry but I don't think asking the community if a hack for SMP should be allowed or not is right. And I certainly want to fight back to make sure that the "Yes, disable it in SMP" choice wins.
I really don't care what you think about me, I did not intend for this argument to get personal... but whatever, you took it there.
Anyways I feel like if I didn't say what I had to say, the poll would have continued to go in the direction of "No, don't disable it in SMP", I never meant to make it seem like I wanted the whole mod "shut down", that was never my intention, sorry if it seemed that way.
Good luck with your mod Austen and thanks! It will be replacing InvEdit for me whenever I start work on my SSP test projects again. :biggrin.gif:
However, I now get this when I press "I" or open a chest:
Minecraft has crashed!
----------------------
Minecraft has stopped running because it encountered a problem.
If you wish to report this, please copy this entire text and email it to [email protected].
Please include a description of what you did when the error occured.
--- BEGIN ERROR REPORT a1dce528 --------
Generated 12/10/10 11:22 PM
Minecraft: Minecraft Alpha v1.2.6
OS: Windows XP (x86) version 5.1
Java: 1.6.0_22, Sun Microsystems Inc.
VM: Java HotSpot(TM) Client VM (mixed mode), Sun Microsystems Inc.
LWJGL: 2.4.2
OpenGL: Intel(R) HD Graphics version 2.1.0 - Build 6.14.10.5303, Intel
java.lang.NullPointerException
at fp.b(SourceFile:67)
at af.a(SourceFile:131)
at ex.a(SourceFile:113)
at ex.a(SourceFile:46)
at kb.b(SourceFile:331)
at net.minecraft.client.Minecraft.run(Minecraft.java:533)
at java.lang.Thread.run(Unknown Source)
--- END ERROR REPORT 230de291 ----------
Whaha very cool i tried it out and its fully working! cool!
But you should add every item or a bar where you can type a item ID in (including a download able IDList.txt )
or make it open source so peaple can add their own items to it
And i fully support this guys idea.
EDIT*
Also there is a spelling error on page four with the latest update.
It gave me a black screen, I fixed it. But, I'm not using it since it does something to my Minecraft. Sorry
EDIT: Nevermind! It's working now, EPIC mod! Perfect for building my Christmas house. :3
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
Quote from Cave Johnson »
All right i've been thinking.. when life gives you lemons, don't make lemonade, MAKE LIFE TAKE THE LEMONS BACK. GET MAD! I DON'T WANT YOUR DAMN LEMONS! WHAT AM I SUPPOSED TO DO WITH THESE?
I think the snow block the menu gives is the wrong one - it appears in your inventory as the actual snow that covers the top of a block, not the actual block of four snowballs.
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
Quote from VIROS »
It is the equivalent of saying
"We should add drug trafficking to the game to attract more Mexicans. I'm not saying that I'm racist, it is just that most Mexicans traffic drugs."
I think the snow block the menu gives is the wrong one - it appears in your inventory as the actual snow that covers the top of a block, not the actual block of four snowballs.
I'm sorry I didn't know if you meant "snow" or "snow block".My apologies, in v.5, on page 5, i'll add snow blocks.
OFF TOPIC:
B
a
l
l
s
SMP already has mods that the server owners can install that allows players to spawn stuff. If they run a legit server, this is considered a hack, plain and simple. So please don't use a poll to make this decision.
And I would suggest a Minecraft Forum mod/admin to removed this thread if he doesn't disable it in SMP in the next version. I thought these forums didn't support SMP hacks?
Edit: Just wanted to quote something from the "Read Before Posting" thread.
SSP does not.
If a server hasn't taken the initiative to start anti-griefing and anti-hack scripts, I'd say this mod is the least of their worries.
This is not a multiplayer mod.
I never said this mod should be removed completely, this mod is great for SSP and I'm sure at some point I will use it on SSP. However it IS a SMP mod, it has been tested to work on SMP, therefore it is an SMP/SSP mod. The SMP side of this mod should be considered a hack and I feel the creator of this mod should disable it in SMP and not simply leave the decision up to a poll voted on by the players.
The SMP side of the mod is clearly a hack and there really is no debating that. But if this mod continues to work on SMP after the next version, it should be removed from the forums until it has been disable in SMP. If SMP inventory hacks are allowed on the forums then where is the line drawn for posting hacks on the forums?
And please by all means, point me to some anti-hacking server mod that would stop this hack.
Also I just want to point out, I am by no means a mod/admin here on the forums, I'm just simply voicing my concern for keeping SMP safe from hackers. If people want to disagree with me on that issue, fine. But I will fight back.
Edit: Just thought of a good way to fix this problem. Why not make it so that when someone uses this mod on SMP it simply issues and spawn item command instead. That way if server admins have installed a mod that allows for item spawning, this mod will continue to work on SMP. However if the server admins are running a legit server without item spawning, it wont work.
"but i wasn't snobbish" Sarcastic rhetorical questions and mini-modding fit the bill. If it causes multiplayer problems, okay. Just come in, mention that it's being used as a griefing tool, and leave it at that. You don't have to start a mini-crusade to get everything shut down.
Slightly more on-topic; Could you add feathers to the spawn list? They're absent, and it'd be nice to have them for custom arrow purposes.
Then again, if you've got an add-by-ID method in the works, I guess that request doesn't really matter.
Also, the kit idea sounds pretty damn handy. I hope it works out.
I'm sorry but I feel like I do since the poll is 24 to 15 (Currently). 24 in favor of NOT disabling it in SMP. I'm sorry but I don't think asking the community if a hack for SMP should be allowed or not is right. And I certainly want to fight back to make sure that the "Yes, disable it in SMP" choice wins.
I really don't care what you think about me, I did not intend for this argument to get personal... but whatever, you took it there.
Anyways I feel like if I didn't say what I had to say, the poll would have continued to go in the direction of "No, don't disable it in SMP", I never meant to make it seem like I wanted the whole mod "shut down", that was never my intention, sorry if it seemed that way.
Good luck with your mod Austen and thanks! It will be replacing InvEdit for me whenever I start work on my SSP test projects again. :biggrin.gif:
MY WIFE FOR HIRE!
V.4 Now Available For Download!!!!
ItemStack Size Setter
A Chest Button To Menu Selecter(opens up a chest gui)
Kits
with multiplayer?
However, I now get this when I press "I" or open a chest:
Minecraft has crashed!
----------------------
Minecraft has stopped running because it encountered a problem.
If you wish to report this, please copy this entire text and email it to [email protected].
Please include a description of what you did when the error occured.
--- BEGIN ERROR REPORT a1dce528 --------
Generated 12/10/10 11:22 PM
Minecraft: Minecraft Alpha v1.2.6
OS: Windows XP (x86) version 5.1
Java: 1.6.0_22, Sun Microsystems Inc.
VM: Java HotSpot(TM) Client VM (mixed mode), Sun Microsystems Inc.
LWJGL: 2.4.2
OpenGL: Intel(R) HD Graphics version 2.1.0 - Build 6.14.10.5303, Intel
java.lang.NullPointerException
at fp.b(SourceFile:67)
at af.a(SourceFile:131)
at ex.a(SourceFile:113)
at ex.a(SourceFile:46)
at kb.b(SourceFile:331)
at net.minecraft.client.Minecraft.run(Minecraft.java:533)
at java.lang.Thread.run(Unknown Source)
--- END ERROR REPORT 230de291 ----------
And i fully support this guys idea.
EDIT*
Also there is a spelling error on page four with the latest update.
EDIT: Nevermind! It's working now, EPIC mod! Perfect for building my Christmas house. :3
Fun forum about lamps
When using it yesterday I was just thinking this needed a crafting thing, and BAM. You did it, awesome :tongue.gif:.
Again, thanks and keep up the good work!
My personal website - http://dkillone.com/
I'm sorry I didn't know if you meant "snow" or "snow block".My apologies, in v.5, on page 5, i'll add snow blocks.
OFF TOPIC:
B
a
l
l
s
O
f
S
t
e
e
l